2 ms·
The other side of the coin is NASA is rarely rewarded for success, but is punished for failure and it's a problem rife in the space industry - you can't have a
by XorNot 13y ago
The other side of the coin is NASA is rarely rewarded for success, but is punished for failure and it's a problem rife in the space industry - you can't have a mission fail.
One of the things the Deep Space Industries people were feeling confident about was they were signing all their contracts to have a 1/3 success criteria - they could launch 3 spacecraft, but would have fulfilled the contract if only 1 succeeds. That little bit of leeway, they think, will allow them to try new things and definitely lower costs.
Obviously some of this you can't do with manned missions, but its still a big cost saver when you change how you balance the equations. One of the things driving the CubeSat movement at the moment is the ability to fail - the low cost is encouraging people to take non-spacerated components, launch them, and see what happens, which then turns them into space-rated components (for a given mission envelope).
- akiselev 13y agoThanks for bringing this up! In my general aerospace engineering class, taught by several active engineers and project managers from JPL, one of the professors did a rough estimate and figured that NASA could double the number of launches without effecting budget or success rate. He thinks that, save for a few critical infrastructure missions, the diminishing returns get to such an extreme that they add no benefit to most missions. However, because NASA has to play politics for an ever shrinking pie, they can't afford to take no-brainer risks like launching ten missions instead of five because four failures looks worse than two, even if they both represent 40% failure rates.