6 ms·
The Guardian and Washington Post win the 2014 Pulitzer Prize for Public Service
- subdane 13y agoThe awards are for breaking the Snowden secret surveilance revelations.
- danso 13y agoJournalism geekery: the "Public Service" award is often considered the best of the Pulitzers, partly because it is relatively equally distributed among smaller, lesser-known organizations as well as the big organizations...so it's sort of a implicit statement on how great journalism shouldn't be dependent on market size and staff resources. So when a big organization like the Washington Post, and the Guardian US, win it, that's a strong statement. They could've just as likely been given the National or Investigative reporting awards. (also, unlike the other prizes, there is no cash prize for the Public Service award) The WaPo has won it before, including for Watergate and the Walter Reed investigation: http://www.pulitzer.org/bycat/Public-Service http://www.pulitzer.org/bycat/Public-Service
- etiam 13y agoIn terms of importance, I think this was practically a given, but I've seen statements from people doubting if the Pulitzer Prize Board would have the courage to make a decision that still wouldn't sit well with certain powerful people. Turns out they did. I'm very pleased to see that. Congratulations to the winners!
- swombat 13y agoGlad to see they didn't pull a TIME magazine...
- willvarfar 13y ago(please explain?)
- logn 13y agoTime named Pope Francis person of the year and Edward Snowden runner up.
- jxf 13y agoTime Magazine has an annual feature called "Person of the Year", in which they devote the cover story of the issue to talking about the most influential person of the year. There is a perception among some people that the selection process is biased away from controversial figures. Last year's Person of the Year was Pope Francis; some people thought it should have been (e.g.) Edward Snowden. He was the runner-up.
- cabalamat 13y ago> There is a perception among some people that the selection process is biased away from controversial figures Its's more than a perception, they've tacitly admited it. Wikipedia: As a result of the public backlash it received from the United States for naming the Khomeini as Man of the Year in 1979, Time has shied away from using figures that are controversial in the United States due to commercial reasons. Time's Person of the Year 2001, immediately following the September 11, 2001 attacks, was New York City mayor Rudolph Giuliani, although the stated rules of selection, the individual or group of individuals who have had the biggest effect on the year's news, made Osama bin Laden a more likely choice. The issue that declared Giuliani the Person of the Year included an article that mentioned Time's earlier decision to elect the Ayatollah Khomeini and the 1999 rejection of Hitler as "Person of the Century". The article seemed to imply that Osama bin Laden was a stronger candidate than Giuliani, as Adolf Hitler was a stronger candidate than Albert Einstein.
- untog 13y agoIt's kind of sad, really. Person Of The Year should not necessarily be a positive thing - just the most important person of the year. But we're long since past that now.
- 13y ago
- spacefight 13y agoThis is great news and well deserved. I hope that the price strongly motivates those in charge at either news company to press on with their coverage.
- hpriebe 13y agoInteresting to see that the runner up - Newsday - was selected for using digital tools to expose shootings, beatings and other concealed misconduct by some Long Island police officers. This highlights the increasingly complimentary role of digital tools and traditional reporting. Anyone know what kind of digital tools they used? Anyone know of other digital tools journalists/the press use to investigate/uncover content?
- danso 13y agoData journalism geek here: All sorts of tools, but really, Excel and Access are adequate enough to be game-changers...this is because data has no standardized form when you get to local jurisdictions. Jeremy Singer-Vine, formerly of the Wall Street Journal, was named a Pulitzer finalist for National Reporting this year (http://www.pulitzer.org/finalists/2014? http://www.pulitzer.org/finalists/2014?): > John Emshwiller and Jeremy Singer-Vine of The Wall Street Journal - For their reports and searchable database on the nation’s often overlooked factories and research centers that once produced nuclear weapons and now pose contamination risks. HNers may remember some of Jeremy's stuff recently making the front page, including: Reverse Engineering xkcd's Frequency: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7290868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7290868 Txtbirds: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4763147 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4763147
- 001sky 13y agoExcel and Access are adequate enough to be game-changers Without doubting your point here, do you think access to data is driving the underlying ability to leverage these tools? Or is it just people have now started to look harder at the problems with an analytic toolkit in mind?
- danso 13y agoI think access to data is key. One of the hardest challenges is dealing -- in an empirical manner -- with paper documents, or anything that doesn't come in a spreadsheet...which, until relatively recently, was the norm of information distribution. But I think we (as a society) are just beginning to make use of data, in terms of analysis and general computational thinking. To go back to the domain of journalism...Aron Pilhofer, who heads the interactive news team at the New York Times, said that in "one day...we can teach you the skills that if mastered would allow you to do 80 percent of all the computer-assisted reporting that has ever been done" (http://knight.stanford.edu/life-fellow/2012/times-editor-says-media-not-driven-to-data-journalism/ http://knight.stanford.edu/life-fellow/2012/times-editor-say...)...I think this is still the case. As an example, you don't have to go back much further than last year's Public Service Pulitzer...probably my favorite winner in modern times: http://www.pulitzer.org/citation/2013-Public-Service http://www.pulitzer.org/citation/2013-Public-Service The reporters took a sensational story (off-duty cops being caught on YouTube egregiously breaking the speed limit) and opted to do an empirical analysis. But of course, what they were trying to find -- cops who broke the law by speeding -- was inherently non-existent, in terms of public records (because it is the cops who determine whether the law is broken). So instead, the reporters requested toll booth records, which recorded the passing through of each cop car. Taking distance divided by time, they were able to prove so convincingly how egregious the abuse was that Florida police stations pretty much rolled over and immediately repented. Besides whatever database they used to hold the data, the analysis here is literally elementary level. This is not to say that the reporters' had it easy (they still had to do all the footwork, interviews, confrontations, and fact-checking, among other things), but it just goes to show you how many important stories are out there, in every jurisdiction, that only need someone who cares enough to do some counting and arithmetic. I kind of love the Public Service awards because of how they recognize these relatively non-sexy, but incredibly important stories done by determined and clever journalists.
- jwr 13y ago...while Edward Snowden, the source of all the information they published, is being hunted down and prosecuted. Hmm.
- orky56 13y agoReporting what was discovered and obtaining such information are separate actions that deserve their own consequences. It doesn't automatically make it right nor does it automatically make it wrong.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoSo I guess Glenn Greenwald is officially a journalist.
- dublinben 13y agoGreenwald isn't named in the award announcement. He'll still be listed as a blogger in the traditional press.
- dobbsbob 13y agoNo love for Der Spiegel?
- abat 13y agoPulitzers are US only. Technically, The Guardian US (and not UK) won.
- e15ctr0n 13y agoThe full list of winners[0] and runners-up[1] is available on pulitzer.org. [0] http://www.pulitzer.org/node/8501 http://www.pulitzer.org/node/8501 [1] http://www.pulitzer.org/finalists/2014 http://www.pulitzer.org/finalists/2014