4 ms·
Sorry, but "sticking up" for what exactly? Eich's defenders seem to treat him like a child...like, he doesn't know how to phrase a statement like, "I'm against
by danso 13y ago
Sorry, but "sticking up" for what exactly? Eich's defenders seem to treat him like a child...like, he doesn't know how to phrase a statement like, "I'm against civil unions, not gays, which is why I donated to Prop 8". This isn't about Eich being punished for a "mistake" back in 2008, his detractors are unhappy that Eich does not believe that Prop 8 was a mistake, back in 2008 and today, six years later.
I'm not going to get into a debate about whether Prop 8 was right or wrong. But don't treat this like it's a witch hunt for long past grievances. Until he says otherwise, Eich is a supporter of Prop 8. That doesn't make him evil, that doesn't make him incapable of holding leadership. But for people for whom Prop 8 is a big deal, I think it's understandable why they would continue to press the issue with Eich and his leadership.
- saraid216 13y agoEffectively, people are saying that we should defend Eich for the same reason we should defend weev: less that they are people and more that they are pawns.
- smsm42 13y agoProp 8 was not about civil unions. If you want to discuss it, at least get your facts right. Benefits equality, etc. that is commonly understood under civil union umbrella existed in California long before prop 8, and prop 8 was not going to change that. Check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_partnership_in_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_partnership_in_Califo... For people for whom prop 8 is a big deal it would be a good thing to at least know what it was about.
- bunderbunder 13y agoWell, it depends on what you mean by "commonly understood under civil union umbrella". A lot of people mistakenly believe that civil unions are just a separate-but-equal version of marriage. That version of civil unions is a fairy tale. Speaking as one member of a couple that finally gave up on making a civil union work and went ahead with an actual marriage a few years back, I can say that there's a night-and-day difference between the two. The institutional benefits that were available to us as a legally recognized civil union could be counted on one hand, and most of them were still not quite the same as what married people get. People who only have a civil union aren't allowed to share health savings accounts the way married people can, for example. The number of finacial and convenience perks we acquired the day after our marriage license got filed with the county clerk, on the other hand, are practically innumerable. We feel like shits for exercising the privilege we enjoy as a heterosexual couple. But we're getting pragmatic in our old age, so here we are.
- smsm42 13y agoWhatever you understand under "civil union", prop 8 was not about it. It was specifically about "marriage". All the rest was already covered by California law. You can say it looks like "separate but equal" and benefits and other equality measures in domestic partnerships are not enough and only full recognition of same-sex unions as "marriage" is true equality. That's fine. But that doesn't make those who supported prop 8 opposition to civil unions or domestic partnerships as they are called in CA - in fact, domestic partnerships by that time in California were done deal and had the same status with regard to all law and benefits as marriage. But they could not be called marriage and were separate and different status. That was what prop 8 was about, not opposition to civil unions. Those are just different things.
- bunderbunder 13y ago> in fact, domestic partnerships by that time in California were done deal and had the same status with regard to all law and benefits as marriage. They couldn't have. The federal government does not recognize civil unions, and many of the benefits of marriage come in through federal law. Even with that corner of DOMA being repealed, a state can still effectively cut people off from the vast majority of marriage benefits simply by offering only "civil unions" and not true marriage. Your misunderstanding of this point is exactly what I was getting at with the post above - one characteristic that is inextricably linked to things like the Prop 8 debate is that a huge percentage of people taking part in it simply don't understand the basic facts of the situation.
- smsm42 13y agoI wasn't talking about federal benefits, I was talking about California specifically and the state law in California. What I am not getting here is how California could control federal benefits? Could you specify which vast majority of benefits prop 8 would cut off? It certainly does not include insurance, taxes, pension, unemployment & disability benefits, survivor benefits, etc. as I see that those are covered by California domestic partnership law. As for federal ones, doesn't federal government controls those? Obama issuing regulation to equate benefits of domestic partnerships to those of marriages certainly suggests it is under federal control - otherwise why would the President do it?
- wwweston 13y ago> I'm not going to get into a debate about whether Prop 8 was right or wrong. Take a look at why you wrote that statement, and you start to understand why Eich didn't want to make it about that either. Also take a look at what he did say: https://brendaneich.com/2014/03/inclusiveness-at-mozilla/ https://brendaneich.com/2014/03/inclusiveness-at-mozilla/ if we're going to talk about his ability to phrase statements. EDIT: downvoted into fairly negative territory for linking to Eich's statement and pointing out that prop 8 discussion is hazardous? Really? That reinforces the point, not contradicts it.
- danso 13y agoSure...but I'm not being considered for a position as CEO. Which means, among other things, that I'm not the person who makes the executive decisions that governs the company's policies and initiatives. Part of the privilege of being a peon is that I don't have to explain what I think because no one cares. Part of the problem of being CEO is that people do care...heavy is the head that wears the crown, and such. I've read his statement, and his interviews. What in his statement contradicts my assertions? I think Eich was a sincere supporter of Prop 8, now and today, and he has said nothing to step back from that. Which means that people who are bothered by Prop 8 should not seem out of place to ask him for an answer. While we're looking at his other statements, check this one out: http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/apr/01/mozilla-ceo-brendan-eich-refuses-to-quit http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/apr/01/mozilla-ce... > Eich refused to be drawn on whether he would donate to a Proposition 8 style campaign again in the future. “I don't want to do hypotheticals,” he said. “I haven't thought about that issue and I really don't want to speculate because it's not relevant.” I'm not a CEO, and I'm not someone who has to deal with Eich being my CEO. But I can understand why people who are in the latter situation may not simply settle for: "Well, if Eich says it's not relevant to how he'll act as CEO, then it must not be relevant".
- wwweston 13y ago> Part of the problem of being CEO is that people do care...heavy is the head that wears the crown, and such. Which is to say, you agree that someone might have a reason to avoid getting into discussing prop 8 itself, you agree that the magnification factor exists for a CEO (and therefore that Eich has a greater reason to avoid making the discussion about prop 8 than you do) -- you just think he also has a correspondingly greater need to address, because this is about governance. Right? > Which means, among other things, that I'm not the person who makes the executive decisions that governs the company's policies and initiatives. If the issue was Mozilla governance, it might be reasonable enough to wonder and perhaps even speculate about what Eich's support of prop8 meant for that in a vacuum of other information (though corresponding a donation to motivations is hardly a transparent act). But there really wasn't a vacuum. Anyone who cared to see what an Eich-influenced Mozilla would be like doesn't have to speculate based on his prop 8 donation, they just need to look at the organization's history, given that he's been a significant influence since day 1. Looking at the internal support -- even from people who are clearly on the other side of prop8 from Eich -- also says something. And the statement I linked to gave the world very clear guidance about his intentions on that front and easy standards based on which to judge him. In other words, the governance issues were pretty clearly addressed. If this wasn't about governance of Mozilla, why does Eich have any more obligation than you do to provide a statment? > I've read his statement, and his interviews. What in his statement contradicts my assertions? That he doesn't know how to make a clear statement treating the relevant issues, or that his defenders treat him as if he's like that.