2 ms·
I use Firefox, mainly because I like it and it allows me to create my own browser with addons. I don't use Chrome, mainly because I don't like it, and it doesn'
by a3n 13y ago
I use Firefox, mainly because I like it and it allows me to create my own browser with addons. I don't use Chrome, mainly because I don't like it, and it doesn't allow as much customization as Firefox; it also seems to try to prevent me from doing things that Google doesn't like, like downloading Youtube videos.
I sympathize with people's suspicion of advertising worming its way into Firefox. And as the worms bore, there's a danger that Firefox as we know it could disappear in place. If Mozilla allows its survival to depend on advertising, it will be difficult for Mozilla to oppose advertisers.
But my greater fear is that Firefox could disappear altogether. I really don't see how such a large organization of paid people (and I do not begrudge them their livelihood) can exist without either advertising, paid use, or some kind of consulting. Paid use isn't looking good. I suppose it helps that Firefox is vaguely an anti-trust antidote for Chrome.
Years ago I felt uneasy about gmail's increasing awareness of me as me. As that unease grew over the years I thought about alternatives. Eventually I chose a paid alternative, and I've been happy with it for a few years.
I'm feeling uneasy about Firefox now. Not so much about the danger of it pimping for advertisers, but about its very viability. And I'm thinking about alternatives, because as much as I'd like to, say, pay for some version of Firefox that ensures its survival, I have zero control over whether that will ever be on offer.
PrivateFox, from the article, is interesting, despite its problems, but it still depends on Mozilla's survival.
What I've been gravitating toward is uzbl (which is ironically un usable for most web users today), or something like it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uzbl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uzbl http://www.uzbl.org/ http://www.uzbl.org/
It has its own existential issues, being mainly today lack of users, which would matter later when the uzbl devs run out of interest and retire or otherwise move on. What I like about the idea of it is that it's minimal and composable, a la the Unix philosophy. The composable part would take much more work on my part than merely installing a Firefox addon. But in the end it would be possible (if difficult) to create my own browser, which Firefox and its addons make easy.
uzbl as is will never be an alternative for most web users (although some packaging of common features could appeal to a slightly larger group). But small niche projects do live on, and I'm hopeful for uzbl.
My other alternatives are along the lines of text browsers like lynx or links2, but those are options for a true, advertising/surveillance dominated web dystopia. Still, they're on the list. (And you web developers should be using them now, to see what happens for users with accessibility issues, or who just can't or won't use javascript.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynx_%28web_browser%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynx_%28web_browser%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Links_%28web_browser%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Links_%28web_browser%29
- scrollaway 13y ago> it also seems to try to prevent me from doing things that Google doesn't like, like downloading Youtube videos. Can you elaborate? The Chrome Web Store probably does that, but Chrome itself?
- a3n 13y agoI vaguely remember (it's been a couple years) installing an addon to download videos, then trying to download a yt video and being told "no." Sorry, that's the best I can remember.
- scrollaway 13y agoThat sounds like a problem with the addon, not chrome. Or the addon forcefully limited itself due to the web store's policies. I'll give you that the chrome web store is a lot less open than mozilla addons but chrome's infrastructure certainly doesn't prevent you from doing what you want. (Source: I do it)
- a3n 13y agoWhich addon do you use? I do occasionally use Chrome.
- scrollaway 13y agoYoutube Options. It's not available on the web store though for the reasons I highlighted. But really I mostly use the wonderful youtube-dl tool. http://rg3.github.io/youtube-dl/ http://rg3.github.io/youtube-dl/
- zimpenfish 13y agoYeah, I've seen more than one "flash downloader" give a "Policy disables this extension on youtube.com" message in Chrome.
- spyder 13y agoThey have policy against downloaders, but they only apply it if it's used on their product (YouTube) and allows it for other sites. And Chrome made it hard (for the not tech-savy users) to install extensions from outside of Web Store. So basically they are blocking chrome extensions that conflicts with their interests.