9 ms·
Earth to Mozilla: Come back home
- natch 13y agoAnother red flag Doc doesn't mention here is the fact that Mozilla now requires extraordinary knowledge to disable JavaScript in Firefox. There are broadly useful reasons to have this available as a toggle in the common UI (such as when you want to save an image from a site that uses JavaScript to prevent right clicks), yet it's hidden inside of the cryptic (to most users) about:config. And why might this be? There could be several reasons all in play at once, including an attempt to protect users from themselves (think: The Nanny Browser), but I would just point out that the advertising infrastructure Mozilla increasingly relies on, with its cross-site user tracking, leans heavily on JavaScript. It would appear that with that as a counter incentive, Mozilla has chosen to side with the ad networks, instead of with the users, in choosing which options to expose for easy control.
- middus 13y agoOrdinary users do not want to disable JavaScript. Hell, they don't even know what it is. Advanced users like you can still use NoScript or about:config.
- jakub_g 13y agoThis was exactly the explanation from Mozilla side and it makes sense. The reason for the decision was people telling "my internet stopped working" (white pages) once they've disabled JS by accident.
- 72deluxe 13y agoIt's an interesting thought: should we be dumbing down everything or just engaging in a bit of education instead and helping people understand what JavaScript does and its use on web pages? The manual for my car mentions things that must be done for maintenance. They don't dumb it down. Meanwhile in computer land we hide all options and dumb everything down to "protect" the user. There is a difference between being easy to use and molly-coddling. It is a difficult balance to get it seems!
- AndrewDucker 13y agoExactly. In order to do complex tasks you get out the manual, open the hood, and get to work. And in order to do something equally complex in Mozilla you grab the help, open about:config and get to work. Your car doesn't put complex details on the dashboard, and neither should Mozilla.
- masklinn 13y ago> It's an interesting thought: should we be dumbing down everything This is not a case of "dumbing down everything", the ability to remove javascript is still there, what is not there is one (of formerly 3) often inadvertently used method for it. > The manual for my car mentions things that must be done for maintenance. Disabling javascript is not maintenance, it's a significant structural change in the browser's abilities, like removing the car's suspension. And it makes no sense to put that as a switch on the car's dash.
- quanticle 13y ago>The manual for my car mentions things that must be done for maintenance. Your car has a manual that describes maintenance. It doesn't have a button next to the radio that ejects the engine.
- varkson 13y agoWho reads a car manual? If you want to continue that, you could consider the manual to be about:config. No one is stopping you from reading the manual or going to about:config, but it's not required.
- pjc50 13y agoIf you want something used by millions of people, you have to make it as simple as possible. Insisting that people learn about the invisible internals is more likely to put them off using it than to result in them learning.
- kijin 13y agoToo many people mistakenly disable JavaScript every time a Java vulnerability hits the news, and there was a period not too long ago when a new Java vuln seemed to appear every other week. It was around this time that the "disable JavaScript" option disappeared from Firefox.
- blisterpeanuts 13y ago>> Ordinary users do not want to disable JavaScript But sometimes "ordinary" users do need to disable Javascript. Wouldn't it make more sense to put in a pop-up "Disabling Javascript will potentially break lots of websites. Are you sure? Y/N" It's perhaps a tempest in a teapot, since these ordinary blokes will simply follow a different set of connect-the-dots instructions they found while searching for "how do I save an image from XYZ website?"
- jamespo 13y agoOr you could just install noscript. Do you think your average user would know to click a "disable javascript" button when they find right-clicking an image blocked anyway?
- natch 13y agoYes you could, if you knew about it and trusted it. I think there's a spectrum of skills, not a binary split amongst user skills. Hard to say where the average user is with disabling JavaScript, because skill levels are multidimensional.
- crististm 13y agoResistance is futile - we'll be assimilated. In the mean time, the GNU fork is looking promising if they actually start working on it.
- keeperofdakeys 13y agoRemoving the settings option for javascript was almost certainly not a move for advertising/tracking. The simple fact is, too many web pages are turning into web applications, so turning off javascript has no use on the modern web. Therefore they took away the option.
- stephen_g 13y agoI think if you want to disable JavaScript, you probably know what about:config is and how to use Google... I think it does make sense to hide an option that pretty much breaks most of the Internet. As long as it's still in about:config I think that's reasonable. By the way, you can download any image on the page from the Media tab in Page Properties, if I remember correctly.
- jacquesm 13y agoIt's actually a pretty bad development that most websites will no longer function without javascript. Graceful degradation was once one of the hallmarks of good tradecraft, and imo it should remain that way. The server should adapt to the client, not the other way around.
- mike-cardwell 13y agoThat's not true. Most websites function fine without javascript.
- okasaki 13y agoIf you turn off javascript, most sites become at best read-only. A good chunk don't work at all or partially break in ways that make the site unusable even for viewing (e.g. flickr). I'm trying to think of sites of that degrade nicely. I can only really think of HN and gmail.
- mike-cardwell 13y ago"If you turn off javascript, most sites become at best read-only" No. That is not the case. People keep saying this, but it is false.
- jessaustin 13y agoDo you have some other counterexamples?
- bradgessler 13y agohttp://limi.net/checkboxes-that-kill/ http://limi.net/checkboxes-that-kill/ does a great job explaining why Mozilla killed the checkbox for disabling JavaScript.
- Grue3 13y agoNo, it does a terrible job at explaining this. The browser's job is to display the webpage under the constraints set by the user, "javascript off" being one of the common constraints. If the page works incorrectly under this constraint, this is the problem of the webmaster who created it. The whole idea that Javascript is absolutely necessary for browsing is what's killing Internet with extremely slow websites and makes it insecure.
- sp332 13y agoJavaScript is not slow. If I set a constraint "Don't use the letter 'e' on this page" and the text is garbled, is that the fault if the webmaster? Disabling the letter 'e' intentionally is very uncommon. If Firefox ships the option, they will have to support all the people who complain that pages are broken because they forgot or didn't know about the "feature."
- zimpenfish 13y agoBut when you say "one of the common constraints", do you have any figures for how common? How many people as a %age of Firefox users, for example, switch Javascript off? If it's less than 5%, removing the checkbox is a perfectly fine decision.
- kevingadd 13y agoTurning off JS ruins the internet. I say this as an avid NoScript fan (been running it for nearly a year) - the vast majority of websites will fail (often mysteriously) with JS disabled, even if you use some curated whitelist. You need a lot of technical knowledge and debugging sense to figure out what you can/can't disable.
- varkson 13y agoThat's why I stopped using NoScript long ago. Things should just work, and NoScript doesn't let things just work. It'd be good if it had a list or something, but I have no clue what it would actually block/allow, since that's specific to the user's purpose.
- Ygg2 13y agoI enjoy the challenge of figuring out how to disable some parts of site. It's a trial and error affair, but very interesting sometimes. It helps you realize how sites are built. It's not for faint of heart though.
- varkson 13y agoI can understand that. I'm a webdev by trade, mainly maintenance so that's more or less what I do day in day out.
- crististm 13y agoNo, it doesn't break the Internet. It breaks a large majority of sites that transform our PCs into computing black holes sucking all free CPU cycles into nothingness. I guess you are right...
- okasaki 13y agoSince we're on the topic. I wish they would at least create an option that makes the javascript part operate in a way that I don't have to disable PaX on Firefox. It is both the most critical desktop application to be protected and one of the very few that can't be. Even X.Org works fine with PaX these days.
- gphilip 13y agoWhat is PaX?
- aaronem 13y ago"PaX is a patch for the Linux kernel that implements least privilege protections for memory pages. The least-privilege approach allows computer programs to do only what they have to do in order to be able to execute properly, and nothing more. PaX was first released in 2000." [1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PaX http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PaX
- KMag 13y agoPaX prevents pages from being marked executable if they were ever writable, even if they are first (or simultaneously) marked non-executable. This means that no JITs are compatible with PaX. Not allowing pages to be simultaneously executable and writable has a lot of merit, but the stricter restrictions of PaX are a hard sell. It would be nice if PaX had an option to just disallow pages that are simultaneously writable and executable. It would be interesting to see a model where processes that were very restricted via the Linux Capabilities framework were allowed to execute pages that were once (but no longer) writable. This would allow programs such as browsers to run JITs in OS-level sandboxes. Edit: actually, I wonder if PaX allows shared pages that are executable in one process and writable in another. That would be another interesting model.
- kijin 13y agoIt is indeed disturbing that Mozilla's finances depend so much on advertising. No matter how well-intentioned the folks at Mozilla Foundation/Corporation might be, it's difficult for human beings to avoid getting side-tracked when their wallet are running thin and there's easy money up for grabs out there. But I don't think the author's suggestions are compatible what what we (or at least, I) want Firefox to be, either. 1. Spinning off a variant named PrivateFox just sends the message that the regular Firefox will no longer respect your privacy. It will also make regular, free, not-private Firefox users second-class citizens of the Internet. People deserve to have their privacy protected, regardless of whether they can pay or not. In fact, people who can't pay (minors, the poor, citizens of oppressive third-world regimes, etc.) are often in need of the most protection. Moreover, even if you can afford PrivateFox, the payment creates a paper trail that might negate the benefit of using PrivateFox. 2. Crowdsourcing sounds cool, but only if everyone benefits. There's no point in creating "The World’s First Fully Private Browser" and keeping it proprietary. If there exists technology to improve everyone's privacy, it should be included in every copy of Firefox by default. 3. Intentcasting is an interesting concept, but in the context of a web browser it sounds like just another "Ubuntu sends my searches to Amazon" debacle waiting to happen. If I want good privacy, I probably don't want to tell faceless multinational corporations what I want to buy, either. Unfortunately, the only alternative that I can think of is a variant of Wikimedia Foundation's annual donation drive. As a long-time Firefox fan, I would certainly donate as much as I can. (Is there someone at Mozilla who can give creepy stares in a banner ad as well as Jimmy Wales does?) But again there's a problem: Mozilla's budget is several times the size of Wikimedia's (300MM vs. 80MM), and I'm not sure that the moral value of Firefox, although significant, exceeds that of Wikipedia. Mozilla needs to be seriously trimmed down if they're ever going to be supported by donations.
- 1ris 13y agoThere is the tor browser that is this a Firefox that respects privacy.
- kijin 13y agoTor browser is made by EFF, and the only reason it doesn't threaten vanilla Firefox's market share is because tor is slow as hell. If Mozilla made two versions of Firefox that were just as fast as each other but only one of them respected privacy, there would be no reason for anyone to choose the non-privacy-respecting version.
- drill_sarge 13y agoThe moment they start to integrate somekind of ads (yes, I heard the rumor/plans) in Firefox they are dead. It doesn't even matter if they don't track, aren't intrusive or whatever. The users will run away.
- huhtenberg 13y agoThis already happened. http://www.zdnet.com/mozilla-to-deliver-ads-in-its-firefox-browser-7000026216/ http://www.zdnet.com/mozilla-to-deliver-ads-in-its-firefox-b...
- nnethercote 13y agoDepends on your definition of "happened", I guess. It was announced, but no patches implementing anything like this have landed in any code repositories, let alone been released.
- huhtenberg 13y agoIt's a statement of direction. It is far more troubling than any specific patch that adds ads.
- kevingadd 13y agoRun away to what? An ad-supported, privacy-undermining browser like Chrome? A constantly outdated and insecure browser like IE? Safari? Don't be ridiculous.
- sleepyhead 13y agoWhat is ridiculous about Safari?
- kevingadd 13y agoSee ygg2's response above. Safari is only an option for people willing to lock themselves into Apple's (increasingly closed-off) walled garden.
- Cowicide 13y agoI really do like the crowdsource funding idea. I like that idea better than building a new app where you pay for privacy. I'd rather Firefox itself be more focused on privacy and the project be rewarded by the public with crowdsource funds as it does so. It wouldn't bother me one bit if they even included a reminder to donate after every upgrade, etc. on the update landing page, etc.
- kevingadd 13y agoAs much as I identify with the motivations behind this post, it's utterly out of touch. The author complains about the realities of ad-supported business when the truth is that the for-pay browser market died out over a decade ago because it simply was not a sustainable way to operate a business. Even if Microsoft hadn't begun giving IE away for free, someone else would have eventually - they'd swoop in with their VC money, demolish the browser market entirely with a pricing race-to-the-bottom, and then explode like all startups do and leave us screwed. At least when Microsoft did this, they kept shipping their browser afterwards (other than that IE development pause... sigh.) Ideas like intentionally fragmenting the userbase (with some absurd idea like 'PrivateFox') merely contribute to the issues he highlights; if revenue to fund development is scarce, why would you actively undermine your revenue base and waste resources on the product that is destroying your revenue? It's absurd, no sane organizational leader - moral imperative or not - would ever do this. Mozilla cannot do this. Hypothetical revenue sources like crowdfunding and intentcasting are great, but it would be utterly irrational for Mozilla to switch wholesale to some new unproven revenue model. Even if it works for a while, eventually they run the risk of scorching the earth (like how Zynga and co completely obliterated viral pathways on Facebook, effectively destroying their revenue streams). If you want Mozilla to adopt a new business model, you'll need to find a new business model that will actually work at their scale, then prove it works. They can't afford to undermine their extremely important efforts (on Firefox, etc.) just to satisfy your curiosity and desires for an ideal world.
- noelwelsh 13y agoHow much can I up vote this? There has been actual research into how much people value their online information (clicks and so forth). The result from one study is a median of 7 Euros (about USD10; http://arxiv.org/pdf/1112.6098.pdf http://arxiv.org/pdf/1112.6098.pdf). Not much to build a business on.
- nubela 13y agoI am the author of Javelin Browser (javelinbrowser.com , for Android), and I think I founded a business model (that works) that is entirely opposite of Firefox's and Chrome's, VPN services. In fact, Javelin is so pro-consumer that it has Ad-Block built-in. In less than a month, I'm edging close to 50k downloads with a good retention rate (installed users), and with revenue coming in from Pro accounts and VPN subscriptions. The long term plan is to grab the market share by focusing on a Pro-Consumer experience, all whilst enabling a better secure and decentralised internet.
- izolate 13y agoWant to really gain some "pro-consumer" points? Open source it.
- general_failure 13y agoI think that "some" points is mostly negligible.
- Ygg2 13y agoWhile I disagree with article, I do wonder, what should Mozilla do to not suffer the shrinkage further? On other side there is Google which can advertise their own browser on their site, plus there is IE which ship their browser with Windows. How do you compete with those?
- netcan 13y agoUp to now, they competed with "those" by being better.
- Ygg2 13y agoRight, but in my opinion lately they have gotten a lot of better, but their userbase isn't following suit. Right now their only slight fault is probably their dev tools aren't as sharp as Chrome, but performance wise it starts, and works equally or better than Chrome.
- netcan 13y agoI guess equally or better than isn't good enough. It was a lot better than IE6/7 when I started using it. It was still a log slog to make 1% gains in market share. People didn't even think of browsers as an application you can replace. It was just the internet. Firefox won by being good enough that users nagged other users into replacing IE. They definitely were and I think we have FF to thank for a lot of the improvements to the web. I love it when companies compete simply on being better. It's probably more controversial, but I appreciate Apple for the same reason. They don't use "crutches" like corporate support, lock-ins or cheap prices. For the most part they set out to make something people will want to buy with their own money even though its more expensive. I think Apple are losing mobile phone market share for the same reason. That strategy sets a high quality bar. You need to be substantially better than the competition. When it works, it pushes the whole bar up and everyone benefits, even consumers who choose the easiest/cheapest option. Maybe Firefox's smartest strategy isn't 'make the best browser' anymore. I'm not going to call on them to abandon it though. I say try to make the best browser and if they fail, c'est la vie.
- _pmf_ 13y agoHere's an open letter from me: fuck you and your cancerous spyware. Advertising ruined TV, and businesses like yours are hell bent on ruining the web, too. Here's a novel idea: build something people want to use, not something that helps scamming people into buying something they don't need.
- kirab 13y agoThen please be constructive and explain Mozilla how else they'll get their 300 millions operating budget each year
- throw_away12847 13y agoUhhh higher more developers to get features out? I thought that was the whole point of making the organization in the first place.
- Ygg2 13y agoWell, they are getting features out. They need to pass some tests, but the amount of features that are made on a daily level is quite large: This features added aggregated on a weekly level http://firefoxnightly.tumblr.com/ http://firefoxnightly.tumblr.com/
- _pmf_ 13y ago> Then please be constructive and explain Mozilla how else they'll get their 300 millions operating budget each year They should probably start with dropping their yak shaving shenanigans (Rust, Persona et. al.), nice toys as their are.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> They should probably start with dropping their yak shaving shenanigans (Rust, Persona et. al.), nice toys as their are. So, you are saying that Mozilla should stop having long-focus technical efforts to develop technologies to support the future of the open web, and leave long-focus technical development to the commercial browser vendors? Seems to me that might help the balance sheet in the short-term, at the expense of Mozilla permanently -- and quite likely distantly -- trailing the commercial vendors as the latters' long-focus efforts come to fruition and Mozilla is forced to play catch-up, but Mozilla lacks such innovation of their own.
- chintan39 13y agoCan Firefox fall at this stage?
- bgarbiak 13y agoI share the anxiety with the author, but what else one can choose if no Firefox? Chrome now pushes Google Now down every throat, Opera has Google set as a default search engine and doesn't allow to change that, Safari is Mac only, IE is hard to customize and lacks addons. Others are often unusable/unstable or lack crucial features (codecs, synchronization).
- PavlovsCat 13y ago> Opera has Google set as a default search engine and doesn't allow to change that You mean the search bar when opening a new tab? True, that's always Google. But if you go to settings, the third thing from the top is managing search engines, and setting the default to use for things entered in the address bar :)
- ajb 13y agoHmm. Here's another business-model idea for Mozilla, just off the top of my head: allow people to set a price on their privacy, and take a cut. - People who are really worried get to set the price to a level no-one will pay; other people maximise revenue, - Mozilla's incentives are aligned with users rather than advertisers (because they have to work to prevent giving away private information for free if they want to sell it).
- jbb555 13y agoI was kind of nodding until I read "Apple clearly cares about customers (witness the success of their stores, and customer service that beats all the competition’s" Hahahaha/
- rbanffy 13y agoWell... While they certainly focus their care on some kinds of users, I have nothing but stellar things to say about their customer service. All my Apple machines have longer productive lives than my other computers.
- Brakenshire 13y agoI don't know the details of Mozilla's finances, but they should be treating their current income as a windfall, not as a reliable future income stream. i.e. their expenses should be significantly less than their revenue, and they should invest the balance, and attempt to create a trust which is capable of financing itself in perpetuity, in the same way as medical research charities like the Wellcome Trust.
- uuid_to_string 13y agoIs this the same fellow who has called for the end of "calf-cow"? I like his thinking. I do the majority of my "web surfing" without a graphical web browser. This makes reading much faster and easier. The www is a sewer of advertising. Users need "garbage filters" to be able to "surf the web". Sadly they are trying to rely on browsers to do the cleanup for them. But mainstream browsers are on the side of advertising. Conflict of interest.
- peterwwillis 13y agoTwo things: 1. Reinventing the wheel Does anyone here remember how Firefox started? It was one guy who was sick to death of how bloated the Mozilla browser had gotten, and just wanted something that worked. PrivateFox is essentially the same thing, except instead of a bloated browser platform, we have a bloated world-wide web, and we're trying to "thin it down". What Doc is suggesting is not only spinning up yet-another-Firefox, but that we should have to pay for the privilege of having a browser experience which isn't incredibly annoying and frustrating. I'm from the Open Source community. We don't pay for our code, we download it for free and give it away, because it's just what you do as a good person. It's given away by people on their personal hosting or by university mirrors and other donated resources. What we don't do is try to extort cash from users so that they can have a half-decent experience getting and using our content. 2. The web is not consumer culture It seems that Doc is certain that the way we currently consume content on the web is good, and permanent, and we have to work around what's on the web and how business is done today. Doc shows many examples of how we should pay for our web content - either in a proprietary browser, or crowdfunding, or 'direct consumerism' - consumer culture without the need for advertising, essentially. I didn't get on the internet to pay for a web browser that gives me the privilege of non-annoying content. I got on the internet because somebody paid to provide me a service, either out of generosity, or after being paid by me for some other good or service. Game servers funded by game sales. Journals funded by the top 1% of power users. Chat servers hosted by donations or for free. Porn sites funded by member subscriptions (yes, I went there). There are many ways to get paid for the services or content you provide. Advertising is the most annoying, most deceptive and most harmful way to do it. There is no reason we have to put up with the status quo and accept ridiculous websites with shitty content and a bad user experience just because they're "free". I say fuck the ad industry. I really don't need most of what's on the web. If I really needed it, I would pay for it, same as with everything else in my real life. I don't live in a home with "featured content by name brands". I pay my rent. I don't drive a free car "featuring new technology by ZomboCom Inc"; I pay off a loan. I don't drink free sodas with e-ink wifi-enabled rolling banner ads; I pay the $1 for my damn soda. There is no need to support everything you consume with advertisements. -- Paying for a browser that specifically gives me a non-shitty browsing experience is the equivalent of telling the ad industry you love them so much you're willing to pay them off to stop the onslaught of ads. I have another way of telling the ad industry what I think: by boycotting all websites with advertising. I'm not going to miss the lack of content, either; because you can't miss what you don't know exists. I propose a browser add-on that disables all hyperlinks to sites that are funded by advertising. This would create a smaller, more intimate, more content-oriented internet. It would encourage community and sharing, and increase the quality of content. It would reduce unnecessary noise and distraction. And it would force content producers to actually find out what users find worthwhile, and if they really want to pay for it, in one way or another.
- a3n 13y agoI use Firefox, mainly because I like it and it allows me to create my own browser with addons. I don't use Chrome, mainly because I don't like it, and it doesn't allow as much customization as Firefox; it also seems to try to prevent me from doing things that Google doesn't like, like downloading Youtube videos. I sympathize with people's suspicion of advertising worming its way into Firefox. And as the worms bore, there's a danger that Firefox as we know it could disappear in place. If Mozilla allows its survival to depend on advertising, it will be difficult for Mozilla to oppose advertisers. But my greater fear is that Firefox could disappear altogether. I really don't see how such a large organization of paid people (and I do not begrudge them their livelihood) can exist without either advertising, paid use, or some kind of consulting. Paid use isn't looking good. I suppose it helps that Firefox is vaguely an anti-trust antidote for Chrome. Years ago I felt uneasy about gmail's increasing awareness of me as me. As that unease grew over the years I thought about alternatives. Eventually I chose a paid alternative, and I've been happy with it for a few years. I'm feeling uneasy about Firefox now. Not so much about the danger of it pimping for advertisers, but about its very viability. And I'm thinking about alternatives, because as much as I'd like to, say, pay for some version of Firefox that ensures its survival, I have zero control over whether that will ever be on offer. PrivateFox, from the article, is interesting, despite its problems, but it still depends on Mozilla's survival. What I've been gravitating toward is uzbl (which is ironically un usable for most web users today), or something like it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uzbl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uzbl http://www.uzbl.org/ http://www.uzbl.org/ It has its own existential issues, being mainly today lack of users, which would matter later when the uzbl devs run out of interest and retire or otherwise move on. What I like about the idea of it is that it's minimal and composable, a la the Unix philosophy. The composable part would take much more work on my part than merely installing a Firefox addon. But in the end it would be possible (if difficult) to create my own browser, which Firefox and its addons make easy. uzbl as is will never be an alternative for most web users (although some packaging of common features could appeal to a slightly larger group). But small niche projects do live on, and I'm hopeful for uzbl. My other alternatives are along the lines of text browsers like lynx or links2, but those are options for a true, advertising/surveillance dominated web dystopia. Still, they're on the list. (And you web developers should be using them now, to see what happens for users with accessibility issues, or who just can't or won't use javascript.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynx_%28web_browser%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynx_%28web_browser%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Links_%28web_browser%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Links_%28web_browser%29