6 ms·
When I was something like 13, I went to my first computer trade show, where on vendor was touting tools that would let non-programmers write software for the mi
by wpietri 13y ago
When I was something like 13, I went to my first computer trade show, where on vendor was touting tools that would let non-programmers write software for the minicomputers of the day, eliminating the need for those expensive programmer guys.
Ever since, I've seen people selling similar notions. Whether or not they work, I expect we'll see a number of similar tools on the market. As things like magnetic healing bracelets demonstrate, not actually working is no barrier to selling a product.
- AdrianRossouw 13y agoWe've been waiting for a long long time now. http://www.cs.nott.ac.uk/~cah/G51ISS/Documents/NoSilverBullet.html http://www.cs.nott.ac.uk/~cah/G51ISS/Documents/NoSilverBulle... abstract reasoning doesn't become any easier because it's done via the form of pictures. If any of this stuff was actually remotely possible, we'd all be building our software from UML diagrams right now.
- wlievens 13y agoRight tool for the right job. Wiring UI controls and data sources together in LabVIEW is easy, but it all falls apart when you need to implement a non trivial algorithm.
- stormbrew 13y agoProgramming for non-programmers is an oxymoron to begin with. Even using Excel is programming. I've become convinced that one of the reasons this field has failed so spectacularly in the past is because people are trying to achieve something that is literally impossible. In order to communicate with computers you have to become computer literate. Or at least, it's far easier (and will remain so for a while yet) for a flexible human to become computer literate than for an inflexible machine to become human literate. Finding better ways to make humans computer literate is and will for a long time be a much better path to make computers more accessible, and it's largely what's worked to get us to the point we're at now.
- ebiester 13y agoLet's operationalize it then: We need tools that bring the learning curve down and allow people to develop their own basic tools to make their lives easier, while storing the data on a central location. Amazing things have been done in Excel, but have you ever seen a department have locking issues? "Can you close the spreadsheet so I can get in?" Yeah, we need multiuser excel, or perhaps a google docs equivalent that can be hosted internally.
- analyst74 13y agoThat's why SharePoint is so prevalent in corporate networks, despite being hated by programmers and users alike.
- Perdition 13y ago>We need tools that bring the learning curve down and allow people to develop their own basic tools to make their lives easier This won't achieve much because the issue is that most people can't think about the problems they face in a structured way. Modern programming isn't hard, all you need to learn is a handful of control structures and how to do I/O, and there are a multitude of tools to take away the tedious bits. But if you can't describe the problem you are trying to solve in a structured way than no non-AI tool will help. P.S. I remember being considered a Wizard in a non-technical university course because I looked up some Excel tutorials and built a spreadsheet with some basic calculations and graphing. This wasn't technically hard, but most of my classmates lacked the ability to comprehend the relationships between different cells and tables in Excel.
- bjelkeman-again 13y agoModern programming isn't hard you say, for a programmer I'd like to add. I have never been able to program well with something like a programming language as I can seem to hold enough information in my head structured that way. Building giant spreadsheets is easy though. I don't think programming is for everyone, but more people could learn than today.
- pcurve 13y agoThese vendors (like Pega Systems) will never go away, because they always find ways to dupe senior management into believing that there's a silver bullet to software development. So as long as there are non-tech savvy senior management around wielding disproportionate influence over IT procurement, billions will be made selling Hocus Pocus IT solutions. "Never write code! Use drag and drop interface! Let business make on-the-fly changes!"
- chongli 13y agoSilly gimmicks like that are not the way programmer jobs get eliminated. More powerful programming languages and better tools are what do the job. That and the ever-expanding universe of libraries for every task under the sun. If you can hire one programmer to use an open source library to build an application that'd take 10 programmers to write from scratch, you eliminate 9 jobs (obviously).
- collyw 13y agoI have noticed the same. I am now building a database for my work with a good web framwork, that would have taken a team of 5 a few years back.
- gedrap 13y agoWell, it kind of evolved into 'programming for everyone!' nowadays. And I believe, that is the wrong direction. Sure, we need to make learning programming more available. There are A LOT of people in non-English speaking countries where the language is a barrier for entry. Many people say that people could make tools for their own use. It looks easy for us, programmers, when we eat, breath code. But for people with no background in programming, it's a lot to learn. Let's make programming even easier to study but please stop shoving it down people throats putting it as something you can learn in a weekend when you are bored.
- collyw 13y agoI wasn't aware that English was used as a programming language. Seriously though. Most languages are relatively small (tens of reserved keywords, plus a handful of symbolic operators). I don't think that changing the keywords to be based in another language would eliminate the complexity of getting the syntax correct, nor would it eliminate the logic required to understand the problems a level higher than that. And I am fairly sure there are tutorials available in other languages. I suppose documentation and libraries will be a different matter though.
- tuukkah 13y agoLibraries are in the center when considering the role of natural language in programming and the barriers it creates: Programming languages contain built-in libraries, which consist of a large vocabulary of more or less strange concepts. Also, finding and grasping libraries is the way to effective programming. Imagine turning the tables and learning programming with the APIs in Chinese if you can't distinguish the characters let alone "spell" them. Even those who can program often hit a wall in the land of Haskell with monads, monoids and functors, which are more scary words and new formulations than complicated concepts. Heck, I'm sure some people first stumble in Hello World because it has little to do with a printer. Also outside reserved words: How's an "object" different from an "entity" or how are "variables" in programming like "variables" in mathematics?
- gedrap 13y agoIt has nothing to do with reserved words, it's about learning resources. >>> And I am fairly sure there are tutorials available in other languages. It depends. If we are talking about Russian, Spanish, Chinese, etc - definitely. But it's a totally different situation in smaller countries with their own languages (I am Lithuanian). Of course at some point many people learn English but it's hard for teenagers who want to learn programming and don't speak any of the major languages.