7 ms·
What are the reasons for the government not to switch to linux? I'm not trying to be snarky; it really seems like there are a huge number of benefits and very f
by wyager 13y ago
What are the reasons for the government not to switch to linux? I'm not trying to be snarky; it really seems like there are a huge number of benefits and very few downsides.
I understand that the government has a contract with MS, but it seems like it might actually be costing the government more to take advantage of the contract.
- Igglyboo 13y agoI think it would be great for them to switch but I can think of 2 huge reasons they wouldn't. 1. Retraining the users, very few people use linux so it would be a massive undertaking to retrain their thousands of mostly non-technical workers to use a new, unfamiliar, operating systems. 2. Microsoft Office. Say what you want about LibreOffice and OpenOffice but when it comes to enterprise grade software MS Office is unrivalved, especially concerning Excel.
- awda 13y ago3. And whatever other IRS-focused enterprise software they may be running, probably runs on the Windows platform. Side note: Maybe this gets better in 10 years when lots of things have been written on the managed CLR? Although I don't think the challenge Wine has is running the C++ programs, but implementing all of the stubbed out APIs correctly... the same challenge exists with a C# interface.
- piyush_soni 13y ago4. As good as Ubuntu's latest version and its UI may be right now, anything other than basic stuff you want to do requires command prompt. Normal users who are not geeks can't imagine themselves doing that on a daily basis.
- touristtam 13y agoStill wondering how they even go by doing their job on a computer. If you ever worked in a support role, you'd know that no matter how many years of experience they have, they are most likely being confused by the UI change every time MSFT decide to be 'cool' and 'innovate' (See the ribbon style introduction back in 2007). And this is without the regular nagging of them not wanting to learn where are the options they want to modify, despite the menus and sub menus. With regards to MS Office and MS mail client, sure they are more polished, but does that really matter? Are those people crafting an art piece every time they want to add an image to their report? Just an honest question.
- jussij 13y ago3. Microsoft Outlook. If you've worked at any of these big organisations, you quickly learn Outlook plays a big part in day to day running of the office.
- yeukhon 13y agoIf these are user-facing computer, then the obvious reason is because of what people use and the software they rely on. Even if they do run Linux, upgrade is still a pain in the ass.
- en4bz 13y agoThe major problem is that anyone over the age of probably 40 would be crippled by a migration to say Ubuntu. My parents still struggle with basic stuff on Windows even though they use it (Win7) everyday at work. Throwing something foreign at them would account for so many lost hours the initial cost would end up being extremely expensive. Also Microsoft Office, basically MS's golden egg, is way farther ahead then Libre Office regardless of what people say. All of MS office's services integrate extremely well with each other as much as it pains me to say. At the end of the day all these people need is Outlook, Word and XL which are leaps and bounds ahead of Libre Office, which doesn't even have a mail client. Add in all the lobbyist and money going towards the right campaigns and there's your answer.
- Joeboy 13y ago> The major problem is that anyone over the age of probably 40 would be crippled by a migration to say Ubuntu I accept that migrating to a new platform would entail an amount of disruption, but I don't see what that has to do with anybody being over 40.
- dublinben 13y agoWhy should LibreOffice have a mail client, when there's Thunderbird or any number of other excellent mail clients?
- en4bz 13y agoI'm not saying it should but I figure it would be easier to fully integrate an application that already used the Libre Office subsystem rather that integrating external mail clients.
- quanticle 13y agoTo be honest, I don't see how migrating to Linux would actually solve the problem the IRS is having. If anything, it would make the problem worse. Ubuntu LTS is only supported for 5 years on the desktop. RHEL goes up to 13 years, which is about how old Windows XP is right now. Windows or Linux, the IRS would have run into migration pain as support for its outdated operating system ended. Yes, if they'd used Linux, they would have had the possibility of backporting fixes. Realistically, though, very few organizations outside of the distros themselves backport kernel fixes. Instead of hearing about the IRS making extra payments to Microsoft, we'd be hearing about them making extra payments to Canonical or Red Hat.
- tcheard 13y agoNow I'm not saying the move to Linux is necessarily the right move for the IRS, but you missed the point entirely. The only thing stopping the transition on time was that the upgrades were put on hold because of budget issues, not because it was hard to upgrade. Last I heard, Ubuntu was free to install, so sure they would still have a similar upgrade schedule, but this wouldn't be an issue here, at least in terms of budget for such an upgrade.
- w-ll 13y agoYou're just thinking about the cost of the OS licenses, think about how many man hours it would take to update all those machines.
- tcheard 13y agoOh come on, the man hour cost to install the update is miniscule to the cost of a Windows license per machine (even if they do get site licenses). And if their problem is budget, switching to Linux is a potentially valid fix for this problem, as the cost (even though there is still a cost) would be dramatically lower. Although again I'm not advocating for the change as there are many other issues that would be caused by this transition.
- michaelt 13y ago
- rhelmer 13y agoI think the most important factor is that Microsoft puts a ton of effort into backwards compatibility, to make sure that it is always easier/less risk to upgrade Windows (and Office) than to switch to something else. I know that in the corporate world there are still very many business applications that are mission-critical and very special-purpose (sometimes custom) that were not written in a cross-platform way, and may not be maintained anymore - I would be shocked to find out that it was not this way in the government too.
- PointerReaper 13y agoIt is certainly not backwards compatibility. Every internal review of Microsoft systems within the government indicates they upgrade whenever possible, even to the detriment of keeping versions that "just work". That is one of the frustrating things about succcesses in deployment of open source: a mindset that still wants to put out the latest version due to features and "coolness" instead of patching and keeping stability that would ultimately save money.
- michaelt 13y agoPresumably if they had could switch OSes easily, they would have switched from Windows XP to Windows 7 by now. XP was released in 2001. If they'd adopted Red Hat they'd have adopted 7, and upgraded 22 times, changing distro once to be on Fedora 20. If they'd adopted Ubuntu they'd have had to wait 3 years for the first release (confusingly numbered 4.10), and now they'd be on release 13. Even Red Hat Enterprise Linux didn't become available until 2002, and you'd be on version 2.1, unsupported since 2009. If you suck at upgrading and want something that will be supported for 12+ years, Linux is not for you.
- tcheard 13y agoUbuntu's version numbering system is not confusing at all, it just doesn't follow the standard start with 1 and go up. Ubuntu's version numbering system is the date the version got released, so 4.10 got released in October 2004, and version 14.04 (which gets released in 4 days) means that is is released in April 2014. Not so confusing at all. Edit: Anyway your point is invalid anyway. The reason the IRS suck at upgrading is because they didn't have the budget to pay for said upgrade. Last I heard, it was free to upgrade the majority of Linux distros. Although there may be many other reasons not to switch to Linux, this is not one of them.
- shmed 13y agoThere's a lot more to the cost of upgrading than the price of the license. Licenses for Win7 are nothing compared to the price of upgrading all the custom software they developed over the years to insure compatibility with a new OS. The reason almost no business or organism decided to leave XP for Linux is because it's not economically advantageous to do so. When talking about an investment as big as this, you can be sure that almost every options have been evaluated.
- DatBear 13y agoDo you live in a world where linux just magically upgrades itself on 110,000 computers for free?
- 13y ago
- chimeracoder 13y agoAt their scale, they will need to pay someone for support no matter what, whether that "someone" is Microsoft, Red Hat, Canonical, etc. So, you can't just look at the consumer price tag on a Linux distribution ($0) and compare that to what the IRS is paying Microsoft in support contracts - you have to compare it to the total costs of enterprise Linux support. And if the IRS is having a hard time migrating off of a version of an OS that was released 12+ years ago to its more recent version, I imagine they'd have a hard time migrating to a completely different operating system altogether. Even if the incremental costs of upgrading LTS versions of a Linux distro ended up being smaller, they simply don't have the up-front capital to cover the costs of migrating to Linux in the first place. (Oh, and don't forget that even if they did manage to procure that somehow, as soon as Microsoft gets wind of it, the price for Windows support contracts will magically fall).
- squidfood 13y agoIn my federal government research lab, we have 15+ years of Excel scripts behind a huge amount of our ongoing analyses. Whether this route was the best or not is a bit moot now (Excel dependence grew by individual choices on the local level); currently the expense of the switch would be very high. Also, in any interaction with the outside world (like Universities), Office is still the de-facto standard. An attempt of mine to lead a co-authored study in a Latex document, with several scientists at universities, caused mass confusion (as opposed to just 'track changes' in word). We're slowly creeping to R, python, etc., and Linux is allowed as a choice (about 10% of us choose it). That said, my lab made it over to Win 7 about 2 years ago now... I like the linux alternative, but I like even more that decisions like this are made at a local level, rather than through a massive top-down disruptive push.
- judk 13y ago15 years of this Excel? I guarantee your analysis is incorrect. How much is it worth to get correct analysis results?
- squidfood 13y agoEh, cheap dig. We are under specific legal and regulatory burden to produce, proof, and provide our results for external audits, which happen regularly. QC is a substantial part of the costs of a new system. Thanks for the offer of guarantee, though!
- PointerReaper 13y agoOne of the biggest reasons isn't just the licensing and individual system, but the supporting systems and processes: certification and accreditation processes for security, ability to only pay for one year at a time due to legalities of budget constraints, and items such as mandated ediscovery systems that are tied to the OS and systems architecture they are designed for using. It takes a great deal of experience, planning, and foresight to decouple services and make removal and swap out of key pieces open and even possible to change out. Add to that active defaults by vendors that encourages lock-in as well as the failure to draw in expertise that would survive in such an environment, equates to mediocrity in IT.
- zenbowman 13y agoThere have been billions of dollars poured into government software that runs on Windows. Billions more poured into support, verification and validation of that software. Switching would be very, very, expensive - and its not clear that it would help even in the long run. Additionally, Windows is still THE dominant platform for science and engineering work, especially modeling and simulation. How many engineers (non-CS) do you know that do not use Windows? The most popular CAD software, SolidWorks, is available only on Windows. Alibre, the second most popular one, is also Windows only. The next most popular one, AutoCAD, is Windows and Mac only. 3DStudio Max - Windows only. Most simulation software is also Windows only, at least when I was a government contractor, that was the case. If the government switches to Linux, they'll have to switch en masse - having some people on Linux and others not won't work very well at that scale of bureaucracy. And when even most engineering software isn't available on Linux, that isn't gonna happen.
- Chronic26 13y agoThis. People are quick to say "Linux is the best" when in reality, for most use cases, it's not.