2 ms·
"That quote goes back into the content/metadata issue. There hasn't been any leak so far showing content collection of Americans' communications. All of the deb
by dllthomas 13y ago
"That quote goes back into the content/metadata issue. There hasn't been any leak so far showing content collection of Americans' communications. All of the debate in Congress regarding these programs has centered around bulk metadata collection."
First, the metadata distinction is absurd in this context. The question asked was "Does the NSA collect any kind of data at all on millions or hundreds of millions of Americans." Data on whether I call my mother every Friday is clearly data about me.
Second, even granting the metadata distinction, it's still false using any reasonable definition of "collect". Garbage men collect my trash by putting it into trucks and dumping it in a big pile. Numerous programs have been revealed under which the NSA is reading content of the communications of Americans and storing it in a database. Using "collects", precisely defined, in a way different than the rest of the world uses it in legal opinions and internal memos is possibly iffy but I don't think clearly unacceptable; using it that way with no clarification or definition in a communication directed at people predominately unfamiliar with the distinction you're drawing is nothing but a lie. "Honey, I wasn't lying when I said I didn't cheat on you. I know I slept with my secretary, but the way I use the word 'cheat' it only applies if I cook her breakfast afterwards." The testimony at the congressional hearing may have been such a communication; the opinion letter in the NYT was clearly so.