3 ms·
As the author, could be flamewar territory. If so, I apologize. Although I'll point out that we've had many such discussions on HN without it getting bad at all
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
As the author, could be flamewar territory. If so, I apologize. Although I'll point out that we've had many such discussions on HN without it getting bad at all. I've seen a lot of Dawkins articles posted here without much rancor. For some reason atheism seems a much cooler subject than say, current politics.
I think you make a great point about morals. I just want to clarify that I wasn't trying to take the position that all morals are based on religion, just pointing out that the author says that morals are structured on some higher understanding of values than just the individual. That you can't talk about morals in a modern sense without tracing them structurally back to Christianity, even if your morals are completely religion-free.
It's an interesting discussion, which is why I'm taking up the project of reading the books. I'm a big fan of how smart people deal with tough questions.
- jacquesm 17y agoI think the title pulls it solidly in to flamewar territory, we'll see how it pans out. I commend you for doing your best to avoid controversy :) EDIT: HN controversy formula: credits for article / comments on article
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI'll be honest -- I'll probably get as much insight from reading the comments here on HN as in reading these books (as long as we don't start flaming) so hopefully the discussion can be enlightening for other readers on HN as well. Sometimes in startups and small teams we have to make decisions with incomplete, inaccurate, or disputed information. There are no "right" or "wrong" answers, yet we still have to decide and begin execution. In these cases it's extremely fascinating to me to see how people debate and make decisions. Posting the current article (and picking the subject) is just a proxy, a simulator, to see how HN readers think in such situations. Plus it gives me a place to make notes from my reading.
- eru 17y ago> That you can't talk about morals in a modern sense without tracing them structurally back to Christianity, even if your morals are completely religion-free. Why single out Christianity?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThat's a question for Hart, although I'll give it a shot (since I read the book) I think the qualifier here is modern, western ideas of morality. When you come up with some system of morality, like Kant's Universal Imperative, or utilitarianism, or existentialism, you end up right back with either Christian thinkers or thinkers who were so influenced by Christianity as to be reacting/growing from that influence. These ideas are a integral part of Christianity's impact on modern, western thinking.
- jacquesm 17y agoThere was plenty of thought on morality before Christianity existed. Ask the Jews (and plenty of others). And before them the Mesopotamians and Egyptians.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoAbsolutely. I've always been an admirer of the stoics (reading Meditations right now) I'll let Hart speak for himself when it comes to outlining all of those. You'll have to read the book. I can't do justice to his argument as I'm still processing all of it.
- ErrantX 17y agoA lot of the Christian (or religious) morals are also ones we now (rightly) reject. Such thing as homosexuality being immoral. When people make the point about religion and morals I always have to think: yes the influence is there (but no, it's clearly no the ONLY source) but that influence is not all good. And it is irrelevant in modern times: religion seems to now be catching it's morals up to the rest of society (example: IVF children) EDIT: I think the title "Atheist Delusions" isnt helping the point TBH.
- jacquesm 17y ago> A lot of the Christian (or religious) morals are also ones we now (rightly) reject. Such thing as homosexuality being immoral. I think that is 'in progress', we have some movement but nothing definite yet. As long as there is a 'religious right' there will be controversy, and the 'noise' is getting louder rather than less so. Plenty of people wonder what the fuss is about that gay marriage thing, and how come politicians allow themselves to be set up and used the way they do. Common sense as a morality guide here (you should not tell others how to live is a very nice example of a rule to live by that conflicts with how religion operates) is 'cleaner' than using religion (or what passes for it).