4 ms·
Bullshit. There's something that was left unsaid in the article, specifically "best practices". If the NTSB used the "best practices" mantra like the software
by stcredzero 13y ago
Bullshit. There's something that was left unsaid in the article, specifically "best practices".
If the NTSB used the "best practices" mantra like the software industry did, then there would be no stick shakers, ground proximity warnings, and collision avoidance systems. Thousands more would be dead without such automation. It's amazing that the software industry so often responds to such problems by saying we programmers should do one more thing, and do it consistently without fail. (Then no concrete steps are taken.) Aren't programs better suited to such tasks? We should be using languages or libraries that are memory-safe and give us automatic means of avoiding timing attacks.
When we in the software industry fix widespread safety issues, our answer shouldn't be, "we should've done X, those people are to blame for not doing X, let's all just do it from here on out." If we were fire marshals, there would be no mandatory fire alarms, emergency exits, and occupancy regulations. Instead we'd "tsk tsk" and talk about how those poor victims were "doing it wrong."
If governments were exploiting this bug, they were doing the opposite of what they should've been doing: fixing it once and for all. I've read several users comment that an Ada implementation of TLS would avoid the same class of errors entirely.
- PhantomGremlin 13y ago> Aren't programs better suited to such tasks? You're absolutely right. "Wetware" is highly imperfect; widespread adoption of better tools is essential. > I've read several users comment that an Ada implementation of TLS would avoid the same class of errors entirely. I don't know Ada, but at least according to Wiki it is much more suitable for this sort of programming [1] than using C. So why isn't Ada more popular? Perhaps its time has passed? I do see frequent mention here on HN of other, more recent languages with similar goals. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_%28programming_language%29#Features http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_%28programming_language%29#...