4 ms·
Japan's maglev technology (EDS) is very different from Germany's maglev technology (EMS) that's being used in Shanghai. One pulls the train up electromagnetical
by ChrisNorstrom 13y ago
Japan's maglev technology (EDS) is very different from Germany's maglev technology (EMS) that's being used in Shanghai. One pulls the train up electromagnetically to a steel track and the other uses permanent magnets to push the train away from the track. Both are still going nowhere. And it's for good reason.
● Both are extremely expensive per mile compared to HSR (high speed rail). Sure it's faster than high speed rail but a technology doesn't make it because it's better, but because it's more practical to implement.
● Service is not as tried and trusted as HSR. Germany's test facilities have been torn down after the Shangai maglev was built and Japan's maglev hasn't been expanded. On an emotional human level it just doesn't feel trustworthy. If you're not growing you're dying.
● Both technologies are proprietary whereas HSR has more companies and manufacturers to chose from.
● HSR could probably compete with maglev speeds by building a wider gauge track, using larger wheels, and implementing more aerodynamic designs to reduce drag and power consumption.
● Germany and Japan are pitching their maglev trains while they themselves aren't avid users of them.
=== Lessons ===
If you want something to succeed sometimes you have to set it free.
If you're not expanding or growing you're dying.
If you want people to use your solution, instill trust by investing in and using your own solution.
- rangibaby 13y agoA full Tokyo-Nagoya-Osaka maglev (SCMaglev) line is under construction in Japan right now, with the Tokyo-Nagoya leg due to be in operation by 2027.[0] As if late, traditional HSR is getting a lot of competition (in Japan at least) from domestic flights that cost almost exactly the same and take about the same amount of time. This has led to a resurgence of the "old" airports in Tokyo, Nagoya and Osaka. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuo_Shinkansen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuo_Shinkansen
- snogglethorpe 13y agoYou don't appear to have kept up with Japanese maglev development in the last decade or so. Japan actually is going ahead with a major maglev line, to the tune of almost $100 billion (privately financed by JR central).
- ulfw 13y agoJapan is spending a crapload of money building their maglev line between their two biggest cities. How is that being 'no avid users' of them?