3 ms·
Probability that story is true | Bloomberg reporting it == Probability that the sources are right * Probability that Bloomberg isn't lying about having sources
by sp332 13y ago
Probability that story is true | Bloomberg reporting it == Probability that the sources are right * Probability that Bloomberg isn't lying about having sources ~= 80%.
The sources could be lying for many reasons. As a prank, to discredit Bloomberg when they report on other NSA stories, because they're embarrassed the NSA didn't know earlier, etc. But Bloomberg knows this and presumably required some evidence to satisfy themselves before reporting. So the deciding factor is really Bloomberg's reliability.
- reedlaw 13y agoWhy do you think Bloomberg was any more thorough in its Heartbleed investigation than Newsweek was in outing Dorian Nakamoto as the author of Bitcoin?
- gwern 13y agoNewsweek was purchased by some shady people and hasn't been famous for investigation for... ever?; Bloomberg is one of the leading financial periodicals which is a major part of the Bloomberg empire and hooked into all sorts of circles. Would you be so skeptical if it was being reported on nytimes.com?
- mikeash 13y agoDon't forget the priors. As soon as I thought about Heartbleed and the NSA (well before this story), I figured there was about a 99% chance that the NSA had found it and had been actively exploiting it for a decent portion of the time it was in the wild. Stacked against that, Bloomberg's reliability doesn't really matter at all. If the sources are good, great! If the story is crap, it's still probably right by accident.