3 ms·
It's important to understand here that the judgment was not vacated on grounds that had anything to do with the crime charged -- the Court didn't conclude that
by otterley 13y ago
It's important to understand here that the judgment was not vacated on grounds that had anything to do with the crime charged -- the Court didn't conclude that he wasn't guilty.
Instead, it was vacated for lack of venue. In other words, he got off on a technicality.
- xal 13y agoWell, while technically you are right (heh), there is actually an opinion stated on the whole case as well: We also note that in order to be guilty of accessing “without authorization, or in excess of authorization” under New Jersey law, the Government needed to prove that Auernheimer or Spitler circumvented a code- or password-based barrier to access.
- otterley 13y agoThat's not an opinion, that's just a legal citation. The Court expressly avoided an opinion: "we need not resolve whether Auernheimer’s conduct involved such a breach..."
- Spooky23 13y agoIt's not that simple. Venue was key to establishing the severity of the crime.
- otterley 13y agoThat statement makes no sense whatsoever to me. (And I am an attorney.) Venue is a procedural, not a substantive matter.
- jdbernard 13y agoMy understanding is that they were trying to try him according to specific laws passed in NJ that would classify his alleged actions as felonious. INAL but that seems to make a pretty substantial difference.
- pcwalton 13y agoA quote from the opinion mentioned in another comment: "To enhance the potential punishment from a misdemeanor to a felony, the Government alleged that Auernheimer’s CFAA violation occurred in furtherance of a violation of New Jersey’s computer crime statute, N.J. Stat. Ann. § 2C:20-31(a)"
- otterley 13y agoI think we're all in violent agreement here. In order to adjudicate the substantive matter in the case, proper procedure must first be assured, which includes assuring jurisdiction and venue are proper for the case before the Court. My point here is that the question of whether the law applied was never analyzed by the appellate court because it found the venue was faulty.
- logn 13y ago> the Court didn't conclude that he wasn't guilty Part of their justification for vacating based on venue was that a proper venue very likely would have resulted in different charges or verdict.
- otterley 13y agoWhere in the opinion does the Court say that? If they did, it would be a serious procedural error that would likely be overruled on appeal. A court cannot take substantive issues into account (other than where the alleged activity took place) when determining whether venue is proper.