4 ms·
I prefer the direct link. The document isn't dense. I found it pretty straight-forward, actually. It isn't short, but unless you are a member of the "tl;dr" co
by dalke 13y ago
I prefer the direct link.
The document isn't dense. I found it pretty straight-forward, actually. It isn't short, but unless you are a member of the "tl;dr" contingent, the gist is pretty easy to discern.
The trick is that things like "Count one charged Auernheimer with conspiracy to violate CFAA § 1030(a)(2)(C) and (c)(2)(B)(ii)" translate to "Count one charged Auernheimer for breaking a law" and things like "See Perez, 280 F.3d at 329; see also Rodriguez-Moreno, 526 U.S. at 281-82 (citing Hyde, 225 U.S. at 356-67)" are references that you don't need to resolve in order to understand.
It also helps if you can translate things like "It is far from clear that this Court has ever “adopted” this test. We have mentioned it only once." into "oh no you didn't".
- wpietri 13y agoWe are all members of the tl;dr contingent for most things. In an age of information surplus, it's a survival skill.
- dalke 13y agoBy "tl;dr" I refer to the attitude that rejects reading something solely based on its length. That is not a good survival skill, any more than rejecting all but candy is a good survival skill in an age of calorie surplus.
- hmsimha 13y agoThere's a difference in that analogy, though. You don't want to overconsume calories; you do want to consume as much information as possible. If we were trying to maximize calorie intake over time, corn syrup would probably be the winning route.
- dalke 13y agoThat's an interesting observation. I don't agree with it though. You suggest that one should consume information up to one's limits. When then does one create information? Even if that information already exists - quoting Westheimer, 'A couple of months in the laboratory can frequently save a couple of hours in the library.' - the process of creating the knowledge is good practice for when one needs to create new knowledge, and for evaluating the validity of existing knowledge. I do think your second sentence is apropos, but in a different way than you intended. Corn syrup, while calorie rich, provides neither protein nor necessary vitamins and minerals. For that matter, reading summaries is often information poor, compared to the underlying material.
- mpclark 13y agoHeavens no! I'd much rather have a good summary than dive into documents written for domain specialists by other domain specialists. For legal documents, research studies, academic papers and the like the cognitive load associated with wading through the original usually by far outweighs the marginal return. The caveat is, of course, that one must be careful with one's choice of summariser.
- dalke 13y agoDid you find this court judgment "dense"? I didn't. I even found the judgment's summary of the case against weev to be clear and informative, and others here agree. I encourage you to read court decisions, research studies, and academic papers. Many are clear, insightful, and educational. It's also true that many are not, but I'm astonished by the number of people who don't even try. At the very least, it's hard to judge the summarizer without sometimes comparing summaries to the primary literature.
- marvin 13y agoI don't even know who weev is, much less that he was convicted for something, when this happened and why. A tl;dr would be much preferable to reading the court documents with no context.
- dalke 13y agoI think it's fair to say that if you don't know who weev is, then very little about the case would interest you, including a summary of the legal decision. Similarly, there's a posting now titled "Finally, usable GCM cipher suites in SChannel" ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7574678 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7574678 ). I don't know what a GCM cipher suite is, nor what SChannel is, nor why it's a relief that this has happened. The link itself is not insightful. While it expands GCM as "Galois/counter mode", that's meaningless to me. BTW, in this case, 'weev' matches some 63 other HN posts, though several provide no more summarized context than this link text. (Eg, a couple of other posts directly to other legal documents, a story about visiting weev in prison, and a letter from weev while in prison.) A Google, Yahoo, and Bing search all return http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev as the first hit. Perhaps one of those can provide the background you're looking for?
- mpyne 13y agoWell I'll go ahead and agree that for the most part many legal decisions are fairly straightforward. And even their length is usually due to dumping in tons of citations and systematically examining the various components of whatever legal test they're talking about. It's written to convince higher courts and other judges in a way that can withstand their scrutiny. But as long as you're willing to hit the "I believe" button a few times while reading a legal decision they actually don't take too long to get the gist of.
- belovedeagle 13y agoAlong the lines of the "I believe button"; I've found after reading several legal briefs and opinions, I'm able to quickly determine based on a section's heading whether it's interesting contentful content or just legal cruft. I'm 95% convinced (though without evidence) that everyone in the legal profession does the same, though obviously they must have a broader concept of what's interesting content. The rest is just citation copypasta, and that's okay.