4 ms·
This article only makes sense if Uber has monopoly power in the markets where it operates. If it is successful in its lobbying efforts, won't it be easier for
by rahimnathwani 13y ago
This article only makes sense if Uber has monopoly power in the markets where it operates. If it is successful in its lobbying efforts, won't it be easier for Uber-like competitors to spring up?
I realise there are network effects in a two-sided marketplace, but how strong is the lock-in on the drivers' or passengers' side? Wouldn't either use multiple services and go with the one which offers the best price at the time?
- barnabee 13y agoThis is in line with what I've seen in London - suffice to say it's easier and cheaper to get a car around London than it's ever been, the only people losing out are the black cab drivers who used to profit from what amounted to a monopoly on certain journey types. Specifically: 1. Black cabs hailed on the street have a set (very high) price, only pre-booked cars can be cheaper. Uber and others are "just in time, pre-booked" services and so cheaper. Here, Uber and others are creating competition and improving the functioning of the market. 2. Uber have at least 4 (popular, at least with people I know) competitor apps in London - Hailo, GetTaxi, Kabbee and Addison Lee. All do similar things with their own take (Hailo finds black cabs with their extortionate prices and supposedly better service, Kabbee is an aggregator for many local and often very cheap minicab companies - but with highly variable service levels, GetTaxi I think is similar to Hailo and Addison Lee is a private car firm who employ a lot of drivers and have been around since long before Uber). All are vying for customers and responding to the competition with deals and pricing improvements - another sign of a healthy market. 3. The algorithms appear designed to find the most profitable sweet spot at any given time to keep prices as high as possible while minimising spare capacity - that's sensible and how any company should (and do) act. Even if it's irritating when surge pricing is in play, it's completely reasonable. I have 4 of the above taxi apps installed and pick the best one for each job - which often turns out to be Uber, so good for them. Bottom line - you can never rely on one company to create a competitive market but if anything, the attention and lobbying Uber has brought to the sector seems to have created a fairer market and benefited consumers.
- kalleboo 13y agoExactly. I love Uber. Whenever I'm in San Francisco, where the taxi market is completely broken. I've never felt the need for Uber when I've been in places like Sweden, Singapore, Japan, etc, since in these places regular cabs work just fine. In all these places local taxi companies also have hailing apps or SMS services, so simply adding streamlined payment and reputation services doesn't a monopoly make.
- mbesto 13y agoI used to live in Europe and I echo this sentiment. Getting a taxi in London, Stockholm, Munich, etc. has never been an issue. Dually, the price is fair as you can hail an alternative mini-cab (in London for example) at a reasonable rate and the service is on par with that of a black cab. When Uber came to London for example - the only difference from a consumer perspective was that (1) cabs were auto-dispatched based on technology (as opposed to a manual dispatcher like Addison Lee, etc used) (2) the car and driver quality was much higher and (3) the mobile app works universally regardless of whether I'm in London or Brighton. In NYC, Chicago, LA and SF the cab situation is atrocious, and very few private markets are set up to compete against the existing medallion monopolies.
- nhaehnle 13y agoUber is in the position of a network provider, and hence in a position where it can naturally become a monopoly via network effects. Any market with network effects has high barriers of entry and therefore reduced competition, unless regulation exists to lower the impact of network effects (e.g. mandating interoperability).
- vdaniuk 13y agoThe important part you are missing is that there is already a monopoly on cab services precisely because of regulation. Uber is currently disrupting this monopoly. So what you said, but other way round.
- wisty 13y agoI don't think it's that strong a network. Drivers are businessmen - they aren't going to shun another app just because it's too much trouble to sign up. So there's big no chicken / egg problem - any competing network with half a chance of taking on Uber will get plenty of drivers. It's kind of like eBay stores, not the "sell and buy junk from strangers" eBay. And since there's only one product, the customers won't flock to Uber because they want variety. I'd rate it lower than eBay and far lower than Facebook in terms of the strength of the network.