5 ms·
More generally, it seems the more we look into the seemingly-simple emotion of disgust, the more complicated it gets. While I hate to just drop a Wikipedia page
by jerf 13y ago
More generally, it seems the more we look into the seemingly-simple emotion of disgust, the more complicated it gets. While I hate to just drop a Wikipedia page in a comment link, it seems to be a pretty good starting point on the topic: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disgust http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disgust It's fascinating stuff.
The other nice thing about this article is that it seems to refrain from judgments, which is a problem this general field has had. First, study scientifically. Then, if necessary, judge unscientifically as needed. (No sarcasm. A judgment here is necessarily by definition unscientific, but that doesn't make it wrong... just unscientific, and don't forget it. Unscientific is not a synonym of "wrong" any more than scientific is a synonym of "correct".) However I think that when you study the differences carefully, and with an open mind, it becomes much more difficult to say that one side is right and one side is wrong on the question of "the proper level of disgust". Disgust is a blunt instrument, like any other emotional reaction, and turning something so broad and vague "up" or "down" inevitably results in errors either way. This is especially true when you remember that not all humans live in the same situations... for a middle-class American living in a safe neighborhood, excessive paranoia about out-groups is probably unreasonable, but for someone living in a tribal area, insufficient paranoia about out-groups may very well get you killed.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoDisgust is only one of the relevant psychometric dimensions in Jonathan Haidt's model, which is where this bit comes from. In a nutshell, Haidt found that liberals reason about moral problems almost exclusively through the lens of fairness, while Consevatives use a larger "moral toolbox." http://www.moralfoundations.org/ http://www.moralfoundations.org/ One of the more interesting observations out of Haidt's work is that conservatives can reliably articulate the ideas of liberals as a liberal would. But the inverse is not true. Liberals have difficulty emulating perspectives that include concepts such as the divine.
- saraid216 13y ago> One of the more interesting observations out of Haidt's work is that conservatives can reliably articulate the ideas of liberals as a liberal would. But the inverse is not true. Liberals have difficulty emulating perspectives that include concepts such as the divine. In the interest of not setting off a flame war, I'm going to point out that this phenomenon can be explained in at least two directions (the obvious one and the reverse) and leave it at that.
- gnaritas 13y ago> Liberals have difficulty emulating perspectives that include concepts such as the divine. I would hope so, since divine anything is simply ignorant and doesn't belong in any moral toolbox.
- c0achmcguirk 13y ago> I would hope so, since divine anything is simply ignorant and doesn't belong in any moral toolbox. Please save your intolerant ignorance for your atheist message boards. There is nothing ignorant about belief in God.
- gnaritas 13y ago> There is nothing ignorant about belief in God. There's little more ignorant than an adult who still has an imaginary friend and insists he's real.
- c0achmcguirk 13y ago> There's little more ignorant than an adult who still has an imaginary friend and insists he's real. Oooh, can I argue the same way? I mean, by begging the question and arguing using ipse dixit? Here goes: There's little more ignorant than an adult who doesn't believe in God.
- gnaritas 13y agoOh you've confused an insult for an argument; not surprising for one who prays to the sky. Go find some fellow delusional people in a church or something, this is Hacker News, not the Delusional Daily.
- c0achmcguirk 13y agoFeel better? So back to your original comment about moral toolboxes--what would belong in yours? How do they get there? What morals do you think others should follow?