5 ms·
So you would vote for the President of the United States when he was not in support of gay marriage, and that's OK, but if the new CEO of Mozilla holds the same
by chris_wot 13y ago
So you would vote for the President of the United States when he was not in support of gay marriage, and that's OK, but if the new CEO of Mozilla holds the same stance you will?
Don't think I've seen Obama apologizing for his past stances on gay marriage. What's the difference again?
- masklinn 13y ago> Don't think I've seen Obama apologizing for his past stances on gay marriage. I don't know if he formally apologised, but he talked about his own change of heart and he did things and directed his administration towards gay marriage[0]. And even before his final shift, Obama definitely presented supportive stances towards LGBT groups. And AFAIK he never went and gave money to actively remove LGBT civil rights. > What's the difference again? Er… one changed his mind and stance, the other not? [0] his case is significantly complicated by his support for gay marriage during his original 1996 Illinois Senate run, moving to indecision in 1998, support for civil unions in 2004 (senate) and 2008 (presidential) before snapping back rapidly to support — as early as 2008 he called for the repeal of DOMA, voted against the federal marriage amendment and publicly opposed Prop 8, giving support to "fully equal rights and benefits to same-sex couples under both state and federal law."
- 001sky 13y agoBy your standards Mozilla is a bunch of racist bigots 70% of blacks people voted for prop 8 This is why it is illegal to litmus test political beliefs under california employment law. So, somebody has to pick their poison on this. Its not an easy issue...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- toxican 13y agoThere's a difference between having a stance and doing something about it. AFAIK Obama never actively fought gay's rights, he just had a negative opinion of it. Mozilla's CEO took action against homosexuals and donated money to a cause seeking to deny them rights. The difference is the difference between thinking something and acting on it. But that's just how I view it.
- 001sky 13y agoObama campaigned in california in 2008 2008 was a presidential year 2008 prop 8 was on the ballot He is on record -- in california -- supporting a definition of marriage that excluded same-sex couples While speaking to "special interest groups" who supported prop8 === That is "action" with intent...it is cut and dry.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Obama campaigned in california in 2008 True. > 2008 was a presidential year True > 2008 prop 8 was on the ballot True, and Obama is on record in California in 2008 specifically opposing Prop 8 and all similar attempts (Prop 8 wasn't unique) attempts to write a similar defense of marriage into state and federal (there was an active move to do that, too, then) constitutions. > === That is "action" with intent...it is cut and dry. Sure, action against the position Eich was for.
- 001sky 13y agoYou seem to avoid the obvious issue. He encouraged and sought the approval of blacks and religious groups who overwhelmingly (7/10) voted against prop8 and led to that ballot measure being passed. He used <specific language> about <the subject> to win their favour. So he was not in any way neutral on this issue. It is impossible to argue.
- toxican 13y agoUsing that logic, Republicans clearly support gay marriage for seeking the approval of young adults, who overwhelmingly support gay rights.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 13y ago> So he was not in any way neutral on this issue. It is impossible to argue. I am not arguing that he was neutral, I am arguing -- as is manifestly and unquestionably the case -- that he was on the opposite side of Eich. He specifically condemned Prop 8 and similar measures. The fact that that opposition was in spite of the fact that he very publicly stated that he shared some of the moral beliefs that others claimed made support of Prop 8 necessary, if anything, underlines his opposition, rather than mitigates it, as his position was that Prop 8 (and similar measures to enshrine a man-woman definition of marriage in Constitutions) were wrong in the then-current environment even given the moral belief that marriage ought to be between a man and a woman.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> So you would vote for the President of the United States when he was not in support of gay marriage, and that's OK, but if the new CEO of Mozilla holds the same stance you will? Even when Obama was "not in support of gay marriage", he condemned Prop. 8 and similar moves to enshrine prohibition of same-sex marriage in Constitutions -- whereas Brendan Eich donated money to the Prop. 8 campaign. > So you would vote for the President of the United States when he was not in support of gay marriage, and that's OK, but if the new CEO of Mozilla holds the same stance you will? I've seen Obama, at a minimum, change his mind very publicly, has never once advocate any change in law or policy hostile to same-sex marriage, and has used the power of his office to direct that the government first stop defending existing statutes hostile to same sex marriage, and then take other substantive steps in support of it. Meanwhile, Eich said that his donation doesn't prove that is a bigot, but hasn't done anything to indicate that his hostile position has changed. > What's the difference again? The fact that their positions in 2008 weren't the same to start with, and that one of them has very publicly moved to a very much more pro same-sex marriage position since then. IOW, there's pretty much nothing similar at all.