3 ms·
but what about things like ctrl-s and ctrl-b in Google Docs? Those are handy and I rarely save a page or create a bookmark by hotkey.
by Pxtl 13y ago
but what about things like ctrl-s and ctrl-b in Google Docs? Those are handy and I rarely save a page or create a bookmark by hotkey.
- oneeyedpigeon 13y agoSee the footnote in the article: "An exception may be if your site provides specific functionality such as in a drawing application. Even in this case it is best to provide shortcuts as an option the user has to turn on rather than one that is on by default."
- netmare 13y agoThis is an inherent problem with web apps, since they're an app within an app. There are two different contexts fighting each other. Who's to say that Ctrl+S should save the app state or the page? Whatever we choose as the default, the non-default scenario would feel awkward when we need it. I can think of two ways to solve this: (1) decouple apps from the browser frame or (2) use a special modifier key for app shortcuts (perhaps re-use the Windows key, e.g. Win+Ctrl+S).
- oneeyedpigeon 13y ago(2) That was attempted (sort of)[1] and it failed pretty badly due to poor browser support and lack of understanding amongst users. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Access_key http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Access_key
- netmare 13y agoYeah, that's pretty messy. As an Opera user I had no idea that other browsers used Ctrl or Alt for access keys. That's just a recipe for disaster. Opera's Shift+Esc combo guaranteed no clashes with browser shortcuts, but it was really kludgy to use.
- 7schlaefer 13y agoYeah. From a usability point of view, I think it's important to hijack some shortcuts, but only those who are not commonly used for such as the one mentioned in the article. I would also argue that this behaviour of blogger is not what users expect, hence it is not a bad behaviour. Wasn't there a pair of shortcuts commomly used for this purpose, Ctrl-K / Ctrl-J if i'm not mistaken?
- 7schlaefer 13y agoYeah. From a usability point of view, I think it's important to hijack some shortcuts, but only those who are not commonly used for such as the one mentioned in the article. I would also argue that this behaviour of blogger is not what users expect, hence it is not a bad behaviour. Wasn't there a pair of shortcuts commomly used for this purpose, Ctrl-K / Ctrl-J if i'm not mistaken?