4 ms·
It's depressing but not hugely surprising to find that the comment thread is mostly people defending price-gouging. I've just spent a while trying to come up w
by PhasmaFelis 13y ago
It's depressing but not hugely surprising to find that the comment thread is mostly people defending price-gouging.
I've just spent a while trying to come up with an argument against, but really it comes down to whether your personal values prioritize cash flow over being decent to people, and that's not something I can talk anyone out of in a web post.
- grannyg00se 13y agoIsn't that part of a general problem with corporations? It's almost a requirement to prioritize cash flow over being decent to people.
- dragonwriter 13y agoNo, that's a problem with firms where the voting power is distributed among people whose only shared interest is making money. The corporate form is pretty much tangential to this, relevant only in that that form is often attractive to widely held (in terms of equity distribution) firms regardless of distribution of authority, and the more widely distributed authority is (which often roughly parallels equity distribution), the more likely that the only shared interest (or at least, the most salient shared interest) is financial profit. But, conceptually, you can get the same issue with big partnerships, LLCs, etc. -- or even small (in number of partners/members) ones and sole proprietorships, where that's all the partners/members/owners care about.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoYeah, pretty much. There's an interesting observation about audience selection in here somewhere. Your typical hacker tends towards progressive politics and attitudes, and would be likely to condemn price gouging. "Hacker News," though, is associated with Y-Combinator and disproportionately attracts the Valley-startup/venture-capital/exit-strategy subset of hackers, who tend a lot more towards Objectivist-libertarian profit-obsession, so you get what you see here.
- lotsofpulp 13y agoExcept that price gouging commonly refers to taking advantage of people in duress. Voluntarily going to Omaha for a convention and finding that hotel room prices are higher due to higher demand is not duress. Are hotels not supposed to increase nightly rates when there is increased demand? Should hotels in Manhattan sell their rooms for the same price as those in Omaha? There is no "hotel lobby" that's pushing to outlaw selling your own residence on AirBnB. However, it's usually illegal because of the liabilities and disturbances a transient crowd can cause for people living around them, and it's the people that want these restrictions.
- scott_s 13y agoI upvoted your comment for the first two paragraphs, but I disagree with the third. The hospitality industry is big, they have lobbyists, and I would be surprised if they are not lobbying against AirBnB in some way. A quick Google search indicates that they are.
- scott_s 13y agoI don't see this as price gouging, though. Maybe that's just because I have been conditioned to expect lodging to be expensive in places where a popular event happens. But in this case, I see it as normal things-cost-what-people-will-pay effects. Part of it is that I don't see a hotel room, or even an investor visit, as a necessity. Both are luxury goods. Jacking up the price of water after a hurricane? I see that as price gouging, even though it's also following basic supply-and-demand. But water is a human necessity, and I find it repugnant to exploit the circumstances of a natural disaster to charge more for a necessity.
- jeffdavis 13y agoI think what's different here is: (1) The surprise factor -- there is plenty of time to plan for a conference and nobody should be surprised by the going rates. (2) The business factor -- attending an investor conference is a business-to-business transaction. So I personally don't see anything indecent here. Charging a high price is not bad by itself, and can actually have a number of good effects. For instance, if prices are high during times of high demand, then people might naturally share rooms. That's more efficient than a family deciding that the price is low, so they might as well get two rooms; leaving another family with no room at all. An innkeeper who sells out all of the rooms at low price and low density isn't really doing any favors to the people who are out in the cold.
- tvladeck 13y ago> it comes down to whether your personal values prioritize cash flow over being decent to people This is absolutely false. My personal values prioritize decency and integrity, but also logic, and my analysis of the facts leads to the inescapable conclusion that shocks to demand/supply should lead to shocks in the price, and suppressing those shocks just leads to more negative distortions and less value for everyone. It is counterintuitive that, say, when a region is hit by a hard storm and supplies are hard to come by, that those holding the supplies (i.e. gas, water, food, etc.) should experience a windfall, but the windfall is only the consequence of making sure that those precious supplies are only consumed by those that absolutely need it. Are inequalities exacerbated in this scenario? Of course. But there is no good way to get around this fact through the price system (there are other, better ways of addressing inequalities here and elsewhere).
- scott_s 13y agoDuring emergencies, many brick-and-mortar stores do not raise prices, and will eat the cost to avoid making people upset. People hold grudges. You may gain in the short term, but are likely to lose in the long term.
- tvladeck 13y agoAbsolutely some do; I consider that orthogonal to the question of whether or not it would be ethical for them to raise them if they wished, however.
- scott_s 13y agoI point it out as a counter to the tempting narrative of rational economic thinking versus compassion.
- qq66 13y agoAlso, because brick-and-mortar stores don't raise prices (often due to price-gouging laws), people who find themselves in a store with bottled water, for example, will buy much more than they would have if the water was suddenly $50 per bottle. They buy more than they need, leaving none for people who need it just as much but showed up to the store 5 minutes later. When demand exceeds supply, there will be some mechanism by which some demand will be satisfied and other demand will not. In the case of hotels, it's price, in the case of water in an emergency, it's randomness or physical strength grabbing bottles in the grocery store, and in some cases the government steps in and starts rationing goods.