4 ms·
It seems odd that Buffett and the WSJ would call this price gouging. There are high prices brought about by low supply and high demand. Sounds like Econ 101 to
by humanrebar 13y ago
It seems odd that Buffett and the WSJ would call this price gouging. There are high prices brought about by low supply and high demand. Sounds like Econ 101 to me. Am I missing something?
- mullingitover 13y agoThe fact that they can get a better deal on AirBnB reveals that the market is not as supply-constrained as the hotels would like us to believe.
- te_chris 13y agoA better deal for an unlicensed premises.
- scott_s 13y agoExcept that that is adding supply that didn't exist before - before AirBnB was popular, there was no reliable way to exploit it. And while AirBnB is competition, it's not the same thing as a hotel room. My point is that I don't think there's anything nefarious going on. Demand is high, so the hotels raise their rates. And the high demand is predictable because it's due to a scheduled event. Presumably, the existence of AirBnB will cause the rates to go down somewhat.
- digikata 13y agoAn Econ 101 model of the world breaks down in many ways - this is one of them. If the supply is not in doubt, but the hotels all raise the prices collectively knowing that the investor meeting is being held, it could be interpreted casually as price gouging. The situation is like a prisoners dilemma for hotels. If they all raise prices and none of them break rank in price, then they all make more money. BTW, just by pointing out the option of Airbnb, Buffet makes it more likely for a given hotel to break rank in a collective price bump. Another way for Buffet to break gouging might be to publicly announce the price spikes as something driving consideration of future alternates for his meeting. But his past behavior makes that unlikely given that he would likely have to shift to areas with larger travel markets so as not to be a large percentage of the existing travel capacity of the locale.
- scott_s 13y agoI don't see the prisoner's dilemma aspect to this. If a hotel lowers their prices considerably, they will probably fill up fast. Some of the other hotels may lose some business, and have to lower their prices somewhat, but they will probably not have to lower their prices down to what the "defector" hotel did. A prisoner's dilemma situation requires good outcome if everyone colludes, and a terrible outcome for all if even a single prisoner defects. I don't see a terrible outcome for all if one hotel greatly reduces their price.
- digikata 13y agoThe "terrible outcome" is that if one hotel defects, more are tempted to defect (defect or allow the defector to capture more of the profits), and if all hotels compete on price, everybody's profit margin is lower. If demand is actually greater than supply, prices rise, but if supply is greater than demand, then the possibility of the price collapsing because of defection is greater.
- scott_s 13y agoMy point was that the period of defection would not last long, because of the high demand; the cheap supply would be gobbled up quick. The hotel prices are the result of organic market forces, not collusion.
- tvladeck 13y ago> An Econ 101 model of the world breaks down in many ways - this is one of them. Nope, this is exactly what would be predicted by Econ 101: Microeconomics. The demand curve during the shareholders' retreat is shifted up/out relative to a normal one during other weekends, leading to higher prices even given no change to the supply curve.
- jhonovich 13y ago"If the supply is not in doubt, but the hotels all raise the prices collectively knowing that the investor meeting is being held, it could be interpreted casually as price gouging." No, that would be collusion. They would be running a cartel and that would be illegal. Worse, your speculation that Buffet is doing this to get hotels 'to break rank' is absurd. Metropolitan Omaha has ~10,000 hotel rooms (source - http://www.visitomaha.com/meetings/faqs/#.U0R2_61dUnI http://www.visitomaha.com/meetings/faqs/#.U0R2_61dUnI) compared to the 30,000 people who plan to visit _just_ for the shareholder's meeting. There is far more demand than there is supply of rooms, this is simply a rational response to that.
- RickS 13y agoAlso in Econ 101: All else being equal, if you can solve the same problem at a smaller cost, do it.
- jeffdavis 13y agoWhen someone says "price gouging", you imagine a vendor raising the price dramatically when they see that someone is in urgent need of something and in no position to negotiate. For instance, if a gas station owner raises the price to $50 a gallon when they see someone limping up with a gas can, and then lowering it again when they leave. This simply does not apply to an investor conference. There is plenty of advanced notice for people to plan accordingly (perhaps even -- gasp -- invest in more hotels if they are raking in so much dough). It seems pretty simple to me. There's a demand curve for the conference, which determines the ideal total conference price (which sells out the conference just barely). If people spend less money on hotels, that leaves more money for the airlines and the conference ticket price. It won't actually go back to the attendees, because that would create a shortage of tickets.
- d23 13y ago> When someone says "price gouging", you imagine a vendor raising the price dramatically when they see that someone is in urgent need of something and in no position to negotiate. For instance, if a gas station owner raises the price to $50 a gallon when they see someone limping up with a gas can, and then lowering it again when they leave. It seems like your example basically fits the real world one to a T. The investors are coming into town with their "empty gas cans" (i.e. need for a place to sleep) and the prices are jacked up accordingly until they leave town. > This simply does not apply to an investor conference. There is plenty of advanced notice for people to plan accordingly (perhaps even -- gasp -- invest in more hotels if they are raking in so much dough). Are you daft? Yeah, all the investors need to do is build a hotel in advance of the meeting! Or they could try alternative options, such as sleeping on the street, or in an airport.
- jeffdavis 13y ago"Or they could try alternative options, such as sleeping on the street, or in an airport." Or not go to the conference. It's a business transaction: if the total price of the conference, including travel, is worth it, then go and be happy to reap the rewards. If it's not, then don't go, and they are no worse off. That calculation can be made before any other commitment is on the line, and certainly before they actually arrive in Omaha. The motorist probably made a mistake or miscalculation that left him too far from a gas station, which he didn't have any idea would happen when he woke up that morning. He had to make a choice of which direction to walk and he was in for a couple miles of walking, so he could not easily see the price (much less comparison shop) until he had already walked a long distance. The scenarios are as different as night and day. A high price is not "gouging" (by any reasonable definition) unless there are some other factors involved. I'm simply stunned that we are even discussing the idea that hotels are somehow exploiting travelling investors by raising the price by a known amount during known times.
- revorad 13y agoWhen an old brick-and-mortar business does it, it's price gouging. When a hot valley startup does it, it's "surge pricing". Welcome to the tech press.
- slg 13y agoPrice gauging is simple Econ 101 theory. It is drastically raising the price in response to a drastic change in the demand (or supply curve). The shareholder meeting causes the demand curve to become much steeper (i.e. the demand is more inelastic). The hotels know they will sell out supply at a much higher price, so why not raise their prices much higher? It is no different than doubling the price of umbrellas when it rains or raising the price of bottled water immediately following an earthquake. In the theoretical profit maximizing world of Econ 101, it is good business. In the real world of morals, ethics, and public perception, pure profit maximization isn't always the best long term business plan.
- positivejam 13y agoI agree that "gouging" seems like the wrong term, but it was used once in the title and once more in the article: "This price-gouging annoys Mr. Buffett..." So, we don't actually know if Buffet himself called it gouging. He is quoted as saying he wants his shareholders to not have to pay as much, and points them toward a service that might provide a lower price for accommodations. Seems reasonable to me.
- bsder 13y agoSuccessful businessmen only like supply-and-demand when it benefits them. They squall like babies when it works against them, however. And, this will only work until the hotel goes out of business. Then the AirBnB crowd will lift their rates, as well.
- malandrew 13y agoNo, in this case it actually is price gouging. If there are 1000 hotels on the market for a certain weekend in month X. Those hotels will see people search for and book a room. Initially those rooms will go for a very low rate. As the date nears, demand will increase and the price of the remaining stock will rise, so that the few rooms that remain as the weekend nears are made available at really high prices. However if there are 1000 rooms and the hotels know the specific weekend and the nature of the people that will require the use of those rooms and they proactively price all those rooms at very high rates prior to even experiencing the demand, that is price gouging.