4 ms·
I don't want to get too caught up in quibbling over definitions, but I do feel like there's a point worth making here: There is a difference between a "consulta
by mindcrime 13y ago
I don't want to get too caught up in quibbling over definitions, but I do feel like there's a point worth making here: There is a difference between a "consultant" and a "contractor", and I think it's worth being aware of. It may or may not matter to any given individual, but to some it will. And to be fair, some of this is subjective, but here's the way I've observed it over the years...
First of all, what do I mean by "difference between consultant and contractor"? Well, if you go off as a freelance / solo developer, your business card may say "consultant" but you'll still be "just another developer" in the eyes of most clients, and in that role you're really just a contractor. That is to say, you're contract labor... just a cog in the machine, another brick in the wall if you will.
If you're on a 6+ month engagement where you show up every day from 8-5 and write code in a cubicle all day, you're probably more contractor than consultant.
OTOH, a "consultant" is seen as having valuable and highly prized insights and knowledge, and is paid to help solve a problem, or work through a situation... which may or may not involve writing code.. if it does, it would probably be highly specialized code that only a small number of people could write. But ideally, if your "consulting" you would be doing just that - working with a high level executive (CTO, CIO, VP) or at least a mid-level manager, and providing them knowledge and insights to deal with a situation.
If your work product for an engagement is a report or presentation of some sort, and one or more recommendations about what the firm should do, or what choice they should make between a set of competing alternatives, then you're in more of a "consulting" role.
Anyway, that's my take. Like I said, some people won't care about any of this. But it matters in that a "consultant" (per the above definition) is seen as more of a colleague / peer to management, isn't necessarily sitting in a cube from 8-5, and generally isn't seen as "hired labor". If that kind of thing is important to you, I suggest specializing in something where you can be paid to sharing your insights, not just for writing code.
- atiffany 13y agoI'm not sure if I see your point as it relates to the article. Are you saying that you think I should be describing another path apart from the ones I have listed? I get that the difference between the level of services you're describing for a "consultant" vs. a "contractor," but I think that has more to do with the capacity of the individual contractor/consultant than the label itself.
- mindcrime 13y agoNo, not making any comment about the content of the article... it's a great article. This is just more generally addressed to people who are thinking about going into "consulting" or "freelancing" or "contracting" or whatever one wants to call it. I just want to point out that people should be aware that just because they refer to themselves as a "consultant" doesn't mean that they will necessarily be treated as such. And again, a lot of people may not care about the distinction. For someone who is used to sitting in a cube 8-6 as a W2 employee at Initech, they won't be any worse off if they're sitting in a cube from 8-6 as a C2C freelancer. But for people who think that going freelance is the route to more respect, more freedom, and less of that "cog in the machine" feeling, then I advocate spending some time thinking about how to make that leap to "consultant who gets paid for sharing insights" as opposed to being just another (apparently fungible) nameless, faceless coder.
- tommyo 13y agoSeems the comment is trying to highlight the difference in staff augmentation consulting (what they're calling a "contractor") and strategic consulting (maybe that isn't an appropriate title, but driving business/design decisions). As someone living/working in Seattle/Bellevue as a consultant, both resource types are highly sought after, especially in larger enterprises in the area. It could be worth noting that just out of school or in a general field, it might be easier to land a staff aug gig at a larger firm than a strategic role running one's own consultant business.
- jessriedel 13y agoI found this comment very helpful. I'm still confused about how the nebulous term "consultant" is used generally, but at least in the (developer-specific) HN universe I understand it to mean something like "software developer who is paid as a contractor, with some claim to a specific expertise". For the record, this is not at all obvious to outsiders.