6 ms·
> the smartphone emerging as the platform of choice vs the desktop browser This is repeated from blog to blog but is it really true? Smartphones outsell deskt
by bambax 13y ago
> the smartphone emerging as the platform of choice vs the desktop browser
This is repeated from blog to blog but is it really true?
Smartphones outsell desktops because you change phones every 18 months while a desktop will last maybe a decade or more; but do people really prefer to use their phone if they have a choice?
It would seem to me people who use a phone most of the time are people who don't have easy access to a desktop: young people, or people who don't have a job or whose job keeps them away from a desk (lucky them!)
When I'm around people who use a smartphone, I never see them engaged in anything more complex than listening to music, texting, or playing some super-simple game such as CandyCrush; they're never "browsing" anything, searching, writing, composing, etc.
So if you're doing social or communications, sure, mobile first makes a lot of sense, but how about other domains?
Do people use Github from mobile platforms? The Github app for Android apparently has "100,000+ downloads", which doesn't seem like a lot?
It would be interesting to know the numbers for Github (for example), of mobile vs. desktop usage.
- smacktoward 13y ago> When I'm around people who use a smartphone, I never see them engaged in anything more complex than listening to music, texting, or playing some super-simple game such as CandyCrush; they're never "browsing" anything, searching, writing, composing, etc. The thing is, for the vast majority of people that's all they were doing with their PCs anyway. They weren't composing librettos, they were just checking email and playing Farmville. So to them it doesn't feel like they've lost anything.
- jarrett 13y agoThat rings true, yet casual users are not the only profitable market for software. Not by a long shot. Look at companies like Microsoft, Autodesk, and Adobe. They do very well selling professional software--software that's never going to translate well to a phone-sized screen.
- trhway 13y ago>software that's never going to translate well to a phone-sized screen. an here is the next multi-billion of dollars :)
- btrautsc 13y agoMeh. I'm not sure. I am on mobile constantly. I don't particularly enjoy the experience. Instagram/ Snapchat/ Twitter/ Spotify are all nice - but doing real world work, heavy email, hipchat discussions, really anything with significant amount of info going back and forth is inconvenient (for me) on mobile. Yes, most of the world is starting with mobile and that is all they know, but my feeling is with low cost pc's/ chromebooks/ surface-type tablets - we'll see those as places where "work" happens
- altcognito 13y agoIt seems at least reasonable to try to compare smartphones to the innovation of the microcomputer. Mainframes/supercomputers have a particular purpose. When microcomputers/pcs came along, they filled a new purpose, but they didn't necessarily try to replace everything workstation and mainframes were doing for a very long time. They will never do everything that a compute cluster does. The same will likely be true for desktops for a while. I imagine that mobile phones will do much of what desktops do eventually, but it's going to take a long time to get there.
- sirkneeland 13y agoOr as Steve Jobs put it, PCs will be like trucks and phones will be like cars. I don't think he was wrong.
- samstave 13y agoPCs are like vehicles. Tablets are like bikes. Phones are like feet.
- alandarev 13y agoAuthor does not say that smartphones is a preferred choice for developing. Look at everyday of an average person, and you will notice that most are indeed spending significantly less time using PC's than few years ago. I am scared to observe that these people use nothing beyond facebook.
- taylorwc 13y agoStrongly agree with your sentiment. HN users are at the extreme end of the curve, and I'd wager that the average HN regular spends a good deal more of his/her day on tasks or activities that may never be well-suited to mobile. Contrast this with a typical non-techie user, who uses Facebook, Twitter, and their weather app.
- awwstn 13y agoThe way I've thought about this is in terms of available attention and routine. I may spend more time staring at a computer monitor, but that time is spent on my work routine, where new tools and apps are added sporadically at best. My phone, on the other hand, is where I spend time in a less routine way. Much of this time is up for grabs and the way I spend it changes on a much shorter cycle. But, to your point about other domains, I think the obvious answer is that there are certainly myriad products that don't need to be mobile-first today, if mobile just doesn't tie into their users' primary workflow. But even most of those services (HipChat, say) can become far more powerful by adding mobile apps. GitHub would be silly as a mobile-only service, but there are plenty of cases where accessing from mobile could be valuable.
- Roboprog 13y agoI think part of the confusion is that "mobile" means both phone and tablet. Phones and tablets might run the same OS, but tablets are much more viable as a PC/laptop replacement. Maybe not yet, but soon. I can "dock" my Nexus tablet with an external monitor, and bluetooth keyboard & mouse, and do a considerable amount on it (email, taking notes, even some development), then take just the tablet with me for review or minor changes, as well as simply looking at things with a mostly big enough screen. For that matter, adding just the b/t keyboard is pretty useful. In a pinch, I can run the same apps & content on my phone, as well, which complements the system, though the phone is a poor viewport for most content. People might downplay the capabilities of a tablet, but the configuration mentioned above is considerably better than anything that I used to do actual work in the 80s, and the resolution, though not size, matched most of what I worked on in the 90s.
- mtdewcmu 13y agoI too use my tablet and phone these days for things I used to do on a pc. The natural question to ask, then, is what's the difference? What differentiates pc from mobile? I guess it's the OS, mostly. Android uand iOS are distinctly different from windows/OSX now, mostly because they're stripped down. But if they take on the same tasks as pc OSes, they'll have to get bigger, and then will the difference still matter?
- Roboprog 13y agoYou can use the apps on mobile devices w/out the keyboard in a pinch, of course. The way the apps are partitioned so they can't crap all over each others' DLLs and registry entries helps some as well. The single-source app store may or may not be a win for everyone, but making apps keep to themselves helps avoid fouling the whole OS install.
- mtdewcmu 13y agoI'm proposing that the more iOS/Android devices grow to intrude on the PC's domain, the more they will become just like PCs.
- 13y ago
- obeattie 13y agoYou are forgetting about emerging markets (and pretty much anywhere outside the US/Europe). These places are completely leapfrogging desktop technology and going straight to mobile. It isn't just the case that the end user can't afford desktops: think how much infrastructure is needed (in terms of power, connectivity, etc) for a desktop device versus a smartphone or tablet.
- ac29 13y agoDesktops do need better power infrastructure, though something like a NUC could be powered by a small solar panel. A Rpi or ARM-based chromebox is even lighter on the power needs. Haswell (or ARM) based laptops can do 10 hours on a charge and wouldn't even need a consistent power supply. Not sure what you mean by connectivity -- desktops and mobile devices have the same options: wireless (3/4G, etc), and wired (via wifi for the mobiles). A desktop surely doesn't require buildout of a infrastructure-heavy wired network to have comparable connectivity to a smartphone.
- obeattie 13y agoWhile these technologies can run on this power, they simply aren't consumerised, or even in the rear view mirror of non-HN types right now. You also have to consider the use-cases: a smartphone or tablet can be used to author documents, browse the web etc (even if the experience isn't perfect), whereas a desktop computer cannot practically be carried in the pocket and used as a vital in-the-field communications device. As far as connectivity goes: again, you're talking about a hypothetical. While there's no reason you can't create a low-bandwidth experience on desktop, the fact remains that simply opening my email transfers over .5MB. Opening my Facebook account transfers more than 1MB. Doing this on my phone uses a fraction of this data.
- thomasz 13y agoIt may be hard to believe, but people actually want a fridge before they even think about buying a computer or mobile phone
- Zigurd 13y agoIf it is true it isn't surprising. Mobile devices don't just outsell PCs, they are more powerful than an old PC, and people do prefer to use them. Many people have the choice of using a work PC for personal matters or using a smartphone because they can't or won't spend for both a personal smartphone and a PC, or they won't spend to update an old PC. As for writing, I have seen a lawyer compose a professional letter on an iPhone at blazing speed. Apparently, being able to do that anywhere is more important to her than the advantages of a bigger screen and keyboard. GMail on a tablet is superior to the Web interface, and I can rip through a lot of email responses on a tablet or even a phone while I'm waiting for my tires to be changed.
- ryanklee 13y ago>> the smartphone emerging as the platform of choice vs the desktop browser > This is repeated from blog to blog but is it really true? Just an anecdote: In our household, we have multiple tablets, laptops, and a mid-tier desktop with a huge beautiful screen. My wife prefers 99% of the time to do everything on her iPhone 5s.
- burntroots 13y agoDoes she spend most of her time in a web browser or a dedicated app of one kind or another?
- div 13y agoMy girlfriend does everything on her iPhone 5c. From the occasional glances, she's mostly doing one of these: 1. Playing a game 2. Browsing on online clothing shops, both mobile websites and native apps 3. Keeping up with friends and colleagues via Whatsapp 4. Pinterest 5. Facebook So I'd say most of her time is spent in native apps. edit: linebreaks
- burntroots 13y agoMany thanks for the response. It's also what I observe other mobile-centric people around me do. They don't spend a ton of time in the browser, but they do use it. It's encouraging, in a way. Sort of like a slow computing movement.
- ryanklee 13y agoNative apps, here, as well. In fact, whenever she's complaining about UX, it's always browser based.
- ssully 13y agoIts a preference, but I have a number of friends who only will use a laptop or desktop if they are watching Netflix or doing work. Even if they have a laptop inches away they will still use their phone for YouTube, Facebook, and any other browsing. I have one friend like this who had a mishap that resulted in a blowtorch in his trunk burning a hole right through his laptop. By some miracle the laptop works. It runs like shit and looks awful, but he refuses to replace it because he has no reason to. He rather use his smartphone for the majority of his computing needs.
- eli 13y agoDepends on the task, for sure. A majority of emails are opened on mobile.
- jjtheblunt 13y ago> This is repeated from blog to blog but is it really true? Yes.
- the_watcher 13y agoI can tell you from working with a company with a high SEM spend, we have seen total search volume increase, but desktop search volume is decreasing in both real and relative measures (caveat - I am only sure of this for our search terms, but anecdotally, it seems to match what I have heard).
- AJ007 13y agoLooking at a site with like w3schools browser stats ( http://www.w3schools.com/browsers/browsers_stats.asp http://www.w3schools.com/browsers/browsers_stats.asp ), you would assume mobile is small. If you have a consumer facing mass market web site, those numbers will look totally different. Search advertising gives you a glass window to this. Mobile is dominating the desktop, not by 4% as w3schools reports, but by 50%+ and growing. The interesting story here, to me, is native app verse website. Which wins?
- scholia 13y agoWow, someone who takes anything to do with w3schools seriously ;-)
- BenefitOfDoubt 13y agoAnother reason why smartphones outsell desktops by so much is that for a family of 5, there is going to be 5 phones (assuming two parents, and three kids over the age of 8). Everyone needs their own phone because they all leave the house and need it to communicate with each other. The family PC is more often a shared resource. Some of the kids may have their own laptop, but phones more of a personal item.