7 ms·
Standing strong and staying Mozillian
- alrs 13y agoCached: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:v794NTcNKCEJ:www.bitstampede.com/2014/04/06/standing-strong-and-staying-mozillian/&hl=en&gl=us&strip=1 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:v794NTc...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoThe apologists just keep repeating the same argument: that what Eich did was merely expressing a personal view, whilst those opposing his appointment as CEO were a mob on a witch hunt. The reality is that Eich as a supporter of Prop 8 was part of a mob on a witch hunt, one with considerably greater consequences than a CEO resigning from his job. The job of one man doesn't even begin to compare to the civil rights of so many. The continued portrayal of Eich as the victim instead of the aggressor bothers me a lot. To paint Eich as a good guy and those who opposed him as some evil misinformed opportunistic lynch mob is a complete reversal of reality. Prop 8 supporters are the lynch mob, and Eich was one of them. Calling for him to step down is a relatively mild response to that.
- vacri 13y agoThis being said, it really bothers me that OKC and others did not clean up after themselves. Battle won, they just fucked off. No encompassing announcement of "Hey, use Mozilla again, boycott over". They got what they want, Mozilla is once again pure in the diversity stakes, but they didn't bother to clear the bad air. They've basically left the bad taste of the virulent boycott hanging around despite getting exactly the change they wanted. So yes, it was a witch hunt - they only cared about destroying Eich, not strengthening Mozilla, and were happy to damage their Mozillan allies (that they purported to be defending) in the process. Besides, it's possible (and common) for both sides in an argument to be wrong.
- ballard 13y agoYeah I think your interpretation is fair. Taking a leadership stance takes on a higher level of responsibility to do the right thing and be just, and to appear to do that.
- philbo 13y agoThe job of one man doesn't even begin to compare to the civil rights of so many. While this is true, I think comparing a political donation to a witch hunt and a lynch mob is a stretch. It's not really clear to me how the rights of lesbian and gay people have been improved by Brendan's decision to resign. Whereas Mozilla has lost it's founder, new CEO and long-term CTO and, if recent activity on es-discuss is a reliable gauge, the ECMAScript committee has lost its benevolent dictator and the man who invented the language. Are you positive that the world is better without Brendan occupying those positions?
- rimantas 13y agoOk, would you reply with the same were Brendon to donate to KKK or some anti-interracial-marriage organization?
- philbo 13y agoNo, clearly. The KKK was literally a lynch mob. They murdered and tortured and terrorised people and communities.
- chr1 13y agoYou know that KKK were killing people right? and anti-interracial-marriage were not allowing people to live together. Do you think that can be compared to prop8 which only wanted to remove tax cuts and social status?
- lern_too_spel 13y agoNo, what Brendan helped pass was worse than anti-miscegenation laws. With the latter, you might not be able to marry your first preference, but there are plenty of fish in the sea. If you're gay, in post-Proposition 8 California, you could not marry anybody you were attracted to.
- chr1 13y agoDo you really think not being able to live with someone you love is better than not getting the tax cut?
- Osmose 13y agoI love that sheppy didn't tiptoe around how infuriating this whole thing has been, regardless of whether you thought Brendan should step down or not, what with the sensationalist media and misinformed public. I haven't been able to figure out how to constructively express my anger, but this post comes closer to it than any I've seen yet.
- rjzzleep 13y ago> In April 2012, when Brendan was CTO at Mozilla someone (unknown to me, possibly known to others) > For more than 16 years, Brendan fought for openness and freedom on the web, and led many of the people who built that open and free web. This week, in a senseless, vicious convulsion, the web turned on him. these things worry me. especially the latter. it worries me, because regardless of your view on whether he was a bigot or not, brendan protected the open web. his views on that matter were clear, and had a track record. we could have had a powerful, a strong ally, with clear principles. if anything his track showed that he would not let personal opinions(which btw WE DO NOT KNOW AT ALL based on one data point) get in the way of performing that duty. I think we lost an ally. A very important ally by the way. Someone care to explain why someone would read a whole list of donations just to throw dirt at him? the quotes are from the linked article in the article: https://medium.com/p/7645a4bf8a2 https://medium.com/p/7645a4bf8a2 edit: there are some other highlights from that article which i removed from my post to avoid common dissent.
- sentenza 13y agoI was rather sympathetic initially, but the campaigners lost me completely when they went after Firefox. That is just the dumbest precedent they could have possibly set. Because the important question is: What will be the next technology to boycott when a high-profile figure screws up? FreeBSD? Exim? Postgresql? The Linux Kernel?
- Mikeb85 13y agoNo kidding. Linus Torvalds probably has plenty of personal views that are boycott-worthy for the rampaging internet mob...
- bsder 13y agoLook, he doesn't deserve to be CEO. Why? Because he and the PR folks at Mozilla screwed this up so badly. This reaction was bloody obvious. The PR machine should have been smoothing this transition and been ready for the backlash. They already had a big kerfuffle about his Prop 8 donation years ago. Not only should Eich be leaving, but anyone in charge of PR at Mozilla should be fired, as well.
- clarkm 13y agoWhy was the reaction obvious? Didn't everyone already know about his donation from a couple years ago?
- facepalm 13y agoSo people with unpopular opinions should never have jobs?
- rpearl 13y agoNo, People who believe that some groups deserve less rights than others, and take action on those beliefs should not lead companies. Certainly, they should not lead tech companies who have a focus on being open and accepting.
- zimpenfish 13y ago...unless they're really, really good at PR.
- facepalm 13y agoI guarantee you everybody believes some groups deserve less rights than others. For example you just said certain people don't have the right to be CEOs.
- ballard 13y agoI've worked some politically-sensitive .edu and .com, it looks more like it was a setup to get him out of the org. No one works those kind of places without having sharpened their Machevelli playbook. Clearly he failed at that and so should be out on that basis alone, irregardless of appearing to hate the LGBTQ community.
- Udo 13y agoI had been quite certain that Jay Sullivan would become our permanent CEO, after a long and successful “interim CEO” run You're not the only one. Everybody keeps forgetting to point the finger at the real culprit: the Mozilla board. There is certainly enough blame to go around elsewhere, like rabid reactions from all sides, the original unethical deed (contrary to the common simplifications it's not about his beliefs per se, it's about the act of enabling legislation that denies basic rights to a minority). None of these casually-identified factors are really at fault for what happened. Let's shift criticism to where it belongs: the Mozilla board elected someone into the chief public messaging position who seems to be prone to behavior that is fundamentally at odds with Mozilla's core message. In doing so they provoked a very foreseeable public outcry and a series of highly emotional responses which ultimately ended up taking down an excellent technologist and by all accounts likeable fellow human. Everybody has flaws, sometimes they're even crippling flaws. If we mandate every high-profile CEO appointment should be reserved for completely flawless people the result will simply be that from now on only liars get appointed. However, at the same time, a board of directors must display a minimum of rational judgement and refrain from appointing people who unfortunately have flaws that prevent them from doing their job. I feel sorry for what happened to Mr Eich. It's difficult to even imagine how absolutely disappointed and rejected he must feel. I sincerely believe he was looking forward to taking care of things that really mattered. Unfortunately, this was never in the cards. The board set him up for this experience when they should have protected him.
- lern_too_spel 13y agoSure, the board shouldn't have made him CEO in the first place, but Eich could have just admitted that what he did was wrong and fixed the whole disaster with just a single statement. The fact that he couldn't caused many progressive people to distance themselves from the organization. Since Mozilla draws most of its contributors from that population, that would cause more damage to Mozilla than anything Eich could overcome with his leadership.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 13y ago
- roeme 13y agoI don't like the whole affair, and in my opinion, while the discussion might've been appropriate, the turnout is disappointing. And it's been said in here; most actors in this affair didn't act very mature. But what bothers me the most is this: http://uncrunched.com/2014/04/06/the-hypocrisy-of-sam-yagan-okcupid/ http://uncrunched.com/2014/04/06/the-hypocrisy-of-sam-yagan-... (TLDR; Co-Founder of OKC donated to far-right republican opposing gay rights and trying to make abortion illegal; among various other stuff). Assuming that such a harsh action (displaying a message to users with a particular browser and urging them to change) must've been OK'ed at quite a high level, it's not far-fetched to say that somebody is/was quite the hypocrite here.
- lern_too_spel 13y agoThat is not at all the same. Saying that Yagan supports oppressing gays because he donated to Cannon is like saying most of us support the PATRIOT Act because we voted for Obama. Eich donated to a campaign whose sole purpose was to take existing rights away from gays in California.
- roeme 13y agoIt might not be 100% the same, but it's also not completely different. You don't get to pick; if Yagan honestly was against gay discrimination, he shouldn't have supported Cannon. Especially since by 2004, the year of his donation, it was already evident that Cannon was against gay rights. But this is not what I'm trying to say at all. Merely that: If OKC wanted to speak out against Eich, they should've done sone in a mature and careful way - it's what a decent person (be it legal or nature) needs to do anyway, and even more so since rarely one is without fault.
- lern_too_spel 13y agoAs bad as Cannon looks, the far right supported his opponent. http://michellemalkin.com/2008/06/25/shamnesty-republican-chris-cannon-defeated-in-utah-primary/ http://michellemalkin.com/2008/06/25/shamnesty-republican-ch... and http://www.americanpatrol.com/REFERENCE/CANNON-WATCH/040617.html http://www.americanpatrol.com/REFERENCE/CANNON-WATCH/040617.... I'm willing to bet Yagan felt he donated to the lesser evil in this case, but I'm still interested in hearing his official response.
- yeukhon 13y agoThis new CEO search will be very difficult as all candidates will have to go through a very detailed screening processing (well a good search should require that anyway). In particular, anyone who lives in CA and has voted someone who is not in favor of gay will be tossed out right away. Any company that jumps into a heated controversy like this is not acting heroic. Their actions are merely to strengthen the heat. It may appear that OkCupid is really just after that PR stun given how the CEO may have been against LGBT community by voting someone who is against LGBT. One might defend OkCupid's CEO by saying "well maybe he was voting him for some of the candidate's agenda, not the entire agenda. After all, no congressman has perfect agenda that everyone likes. You either choose someone you totally disagree with or someone you partially disagree with, or someone you think is actually helping and caring about people." When we reflect, doesn't that make this whole crisis really stupid and ugly given how we elect people into office based on partial agreement? How Eich is helpful, friendly to his colleagues at Mozilla and outside of Mozilla and yet he is still not the right choice to lead Mozilla. After all, Mozilla's mission IS ABOUT allowing every community to be able to express itself to the whole Internet. How do we do that? By building a browser which people can trust by verifying the source code. By building websites and tools which allow people to share opinions freely. By teaching people how to make use of technology to share opinions. Choosing Eich might have been a really bad choice now that we reflect on history. CEO search will continue and will require triple efforts. Great lesson for all future CEO search. Yet, Mozilla has to take a lot of losses which is unfortunate. I don't like OkCupid. What they did was truly amazingly reckless to me. You can disagree with me all you want. But it is. If you are going to boycott Mozilla over this LGBT issue, where was your boycott when we found out about NSA? Where were you OkCupid when we heard about Russian's ban on gay when the Winter Olympics was happening? There is so many worth causes for a service owner to display a boycott message to its users. Dying children and poor labor in the world. But most don't do that. Why? Neutrality for a neutral service is the right thing to do. Now all the sudden ganging up on Mozilla is fishy to me, OkCupid.
- zimpenfish 13y ago"Russian's ban on gay" doesn't exist. Sochi, for example, has many gay clubs. The Russians passed "you can't promote homosexuality to juveniles" which is very different.
- HarrietJones 13y agohttp://uncrunched.com/2014/04/06/the-hypocrisy-of-sam-yagan-okcupid/ http://uncrunched.com/2014/04/06/the-hypocrisy-of-sam-yagan-...