3 ms·
I don't disagree with your analysis, but people don't gain or lose rights based on government whims. People have inalienable rights that can be respected or vio
by humanrebar 13y ago
I don't disagree with your analysis, but people don't gain or lose rights based on government whims. People have inalienable rights that can be respected or violated. This may seem like a semantic point, but I think it's important that to remember that fundamental rights, like the right to to a fair trial, exist no matter whether the law and its agents honor those rights.
When governments fail to respect inalienable rights, they lose legitimacy.
- XorNot 13y agoInalienable rights is verbage that sounds good, but means practically nothing. Do you have a right to life? Well no - America is one of the only first world nations to still have the death penalty. Liberty? The standard faire of our justice systems is to remove that. Pursuit of happiness? This is the only one I'd argue everyone does have, that actually is inalienable. The loss of that tends to actually cause problems. But everything else comes stamped with some big provisos about one's place and actions within society, and a discussion where we hamstring ourselves over what is and isn't a right ultimately is what erodes those we do have - worrying too much about whether something is a right, rather then if what we're doing is right.
- humanrebar 13y agoI sounds like you agree that what is right exists outside of legal definitions, which was my point. The point being that moral authority does not derive from the legal code. To the extent that governments can be blamed for failing to protect the rights to life, liberty, property, conscience, etc., they can be found to be immoral or unjust. And at a certain point, the laws of the government (or even the government itself) loses legitimacy. This was really the thesis of the Declaration of Independence.