3 ms·
This is a highly emotional article, which sets off a lot of alarms for me. I found several places in the article where I felt the author was doing a lot of hand
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
This is a highly emotional article, which sets off a lot of alarms for me. I found several places in the article where I felt the author was doing a lot of hand-waving and navel-gazing.
But instead of critiquing the article, I would encourage people who are interested in homelessness to actually learn about and help homeless people -- don't sit around reading what one person wants you to think and feel proud that you're one of the few that "gets it" This is a tough subject, and at the end of the day, after learning and understanding what is going on, you might end up taking the side of the cities in some of these cases. I'm not saying the author is wrong -- "confused" might be a better term to use.
- davidw 17y ago> This is a highly emotional article, which sets off a lot of alarms for me. I found several places in the article where I felt the author was doing a lot of hand-waving and navel-gazing. Generally a good sign that it ought to be flagged, especially since the emotional content is not about how people are wasting their lives using vim when they could be using emacs, or something in a similar vein.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI've about had it with the vim and emacs fanboys, davidw. I think maybe I've flagged five articles in the three years I've been here. But some of us (ahem), are much quicker to flag than others! I'm always for mixing up the topics to get things a little more interesting. Do homeless people prefer emacs, vim, or ed? Is Apple using the iPhone to keep Latino kids from attending school? I don't know -- anything but the same fifteen types of stories over and over again.
- blhack 17y agoIf they had somehow involved twitter in this, it would have been okay. Also if it had come from techcrunch. Okay, okay, kidding...to me, hacker news is "news for hackers" -> Things Hackers will enjoy -> not lolcats and news about 4chan -> not reddit.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThis article has brought out all of the hang-wringing and self-hate that I can put up with for a while. I like realistic depictions of problems and solutions a lot more than I do talking about how miserable everything is. It's truly brought out the pessimist in most all of the commenters. Davidw is right -- time to flag.
- halostatue 17y agoEhrenreich is anything but confused on this matter. There is a societal failure here and the criminalization of being poor is a further failure. As I pointed out in another comment, a large part of the modern urban homeless problem is related to the fact that we don't have mental institutions the way we used to. I'm glad we don't, but when we eliminated them we didn't come up with alternatives to house and treat the people who needed them.