4 ms·
The objective of this tests seems to be more to prove a point than to be fair, I'm not surprised. And the test looks like it's blind, but not double blind. It
by raverbashing 13y ago
The objective of this tests seems to be more to prove a point than to be fair, I'm not surprised.
And the test looks like it's blind, but not double blind.
It seems all rigour goes out of the window in order for the researchers to prove their point
And of course taste is subjective, but a misadjusted violin will not sound great even if it's a good violin. (Same with a bad violin, modern or old)
> "professional violinists can't tell the difference between
modern violinist and old Italians," then I think we need a
> different study in which violinists are actually asked to
identify that
Of course.
- ricardobeat 13y agoI'm not convinced there is much interference from the conductors to warrant a double-blind study. Either way, I believe the original paper never claimed that "professional violinists can't tell the difference", that's the media twist. It proved beyond reasonable doubt that professional musicians do not prefer the antique models based on any objective qualities.
- russelluresti 13y agoI wouldn't even say the study proved that point. The fact that the older fiddles couldn't be adjusted for sound optimizations while the new ones could makes a huge impact on the study - it invariably unlevels the playing field.
- rquantz 13y agoNormals don't understand the difference an adjustment can make. You can tap the sound post half a millimeter and feel like you're playing on a completely different instrument.
- ricardobeat 13y agoI believe rare instruments like those are always kept in pristine conditions, and nowhere it is mentioned that the new ones had adjustments done, you can assume they all were received in 'normal playing condition' from their owners.
- sukuriant 13y agoIt's a reasonable assumption to make that the new ones had adjustments done. Even larger was the unchanged strings. I could easily imagine that the older ones, since they're not allowed to be modified in any way, had older strings than the new ones. That alone could produce a huge difference.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoThat's a difference, but it's a difference with obvious large implications for using the things in performance as well as experiments. As such, it's hard to see how it's a problem in the experimental design; if you're not allowed to adjust the Stradivarius while it's in your possession, maybe a newer model really is the right choice for a concert?
- sukuriant 13y agoThat is fair; but, my assumption in this situation is that if the musician owned the instrument themselves, they would have been allowed to tune it. Not being allowed to change details may have been a way for the benefactors of the instruments to keep them from being harmed
- thaumasiotes 13y agoWith Stradivarius violins costing millions and millions of dollars, I always assumed that the people playing on them didn't, in the typical case, actually own them (much like how science is now mostly practiced by professionals funded by grants, instead of by the bored idle rich). But I'm not informed on that point; it could be very different.
- analog31 13y agoI don't know the exact breakdown of numbers, but it's increasingly common for a Strad to be owned by a benefactor and loaned to the musician. I don't know of any other artifact that straddles such extremes of being a treasure but also a work horse. Even the owners of lesser instruments have to deal with the implications of taking a valuable and delicate instrument out of the house to play in a saloon. For this reason, tweaking a Strad is unlikely to be done casually. Re-stringing? Sure, at the very least E strings, which break all the time. But a set of fiddle strings is damned expensive, and takes time to break in so they don't sound too harsh, so re-stringing has to be coordinated with one's performance schedule. Online, one can find a list of every known Strad, its history of owners, etc. Interestingly enough, a couple of them are listed as missing or stolen.
- DrStalker 13y agoI'd say they proved conclusively a modern violin you can adjust is preferred over an old violin you can't adjust, and pragmatically that's the only meaningful test since since there doesn't seem to be such a thing as an older violin you are allowed to adjust freely.
- Fishkins 13y agoAccording to the abstract, the study was performed "under double-blind conditions" http://www.pnas.org/content/109/3/760.full http://www.pnas.org/content/109/3/760.full