11 ms·
Reasons Not To Raise Venture Capital
- pg_is_a_butt 13y ago#1 reason: PG IS A BUTT
- andrewchoi 13y agoJust some examination of the math: If the VC firm is taking 15% of your company for $15m, then you've got a valuation of $100m. As far as I know, the "We all know that nine out of ten startups fail" applies to all startups, not the ones that are being valued at $100m. Also, I think very few VCs are investing $15m into a company that they expect to have a 90% chance of failure. You're looking at more of a 3-5x on some of the deals to carry the consistent 1-2x that the rest of the portfolio is returning. I don't disagree with a lot of the points in the article, but saying that a VC firm with a $150m fund is betting the farm on one $15m investment exiting at $3bn should raise some eyebrows.
- pgeorgi 13y agoSo the numbers are simplified to make it easy to follow the general point. If they line up _that_ neatly, they usually are.
- andrewchoi 13y agoWhat I'm saying is that there are very few VCs that are hoping for a 30x on one investment to make up for 9 failures. It's an order of magnitude difference, which I think is nontrivial. If it was a general point, it would have been fine, but the difference between a $100m --> $300m company and a $100m --> $3000m company are huge.
- phillmv 13y agoThe way I interpreted it was more, failure in VC terms is "not blowing up". That $15 mil investment might be acquihired, or continue to be unexcitingly profitable, or put up on the chopping block for its patent portfolio. They might not even lose money, but. Also keep in mind that VC funds as an asset class are historically a bad investment: http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2012/05/07/most_venture_capital_firms_suck.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2012/05/07/most_venture_... http://avc.com/2013/02/venture-capital-returns/ http://avc.com/2013/02/venture-capital-returns/ It's not just that the VC expects the average startup to fail; it's also expected that the average VC fails - or at least underperforms the S&P500.
- andrewchoi 13y agoI agree, especially in light of the preference structures that she mentions (and that I believe are industry-standard). But these arguments seem to lead to the conclusion that you shouldn't be an LP, not that you shouldn't take venture money. The only way that this becomes an issue is if the VC has enough of a stake to run their own decision making and executing process, and that (as I understand it) is the line between VC and PE.
- phillmv 13y ago>But these arguments seem to lead to the conclusion that you shouldn't be an LP, not that you shouldn't take venture money. I have a very limited understanding, but the impression I got is that VCs typically have short maturity dates and thus are riskier in nature, whereas PE funds typically have the luxury of biding their time. How this is structured, or why exactly is beyond my ken. So upside being, VCs are incentivized to encourage larger risk taking than what would be otherwise optimal from the perspective of a bootstrapped founder.
- andrewchoi 13y agoI can't speak for the PE side, but VCs aren't investing their own money. They have limited partners (LPs) that provide the money, and expect returns on it. This LP money goes into funds (vehicles to make investments out of). Each fund has a limited lifespan (the company I work for has fund lifetimes of around 8-10 years). This means that all of the money should be returned to investors over that time period. Since VCs can't make all of their investments at the beginning of the fund (for many reasons, chief among them scarcity) they need to show returns in an even shorter timeframe. The bootstrapped founder, on the other hand, doesn't necessarily need to exit the investment in those 8-10 (or shorter) years. There are, of course, serial entrepreneurs for whom that is their goal, and for them (as the article points out) their incentives are aligned. For "lifestyle company" founders (not meant to be disparaging), an exit may not be necessary at all. The key differences are time horizon and exit.
- foysavas 13y ago
- scootklein 13y agoJust looking at YCs returns, the vast majority of the wealth appears to be concentrated into 3 of 600+ starts (Dropbox, AirBnB, and Stripe). Even a Heroku sale for 200M+ is a drop in the bucket compared to $10B private market valuation, say it out loud and it will sound weird. "Dropbox is worth 50 Herokus" Betting the farm implies that they have no other options, which is not the case with VCs, and it's impossible to know which will be their "super unicorns" when they write the checks, so they write lots of checks. There's not much reason to believe YC is unlike other angel groups, individuals, or VC firms, and their data should back up that the majority of their returns is 1 or 2 companies every so often with huge wins.
- andrewchoi 13y agoThe difference is that YC isn't investing $15m into companies, they're investing $20k. The corresponding valuations for the companies that they invest in is $1m on the high end (20k / 2%), not $100m. The risk profile for different check sizes is vastly different.
- scootklein 13y agoThe risk profile as you seem to be thinking of it is an irrelevant metric when you're only interested in the return profile. They're optimizing for dollars returned, not % of companies sold for greater than money put in. Consider a "soft landing" (VC gets their money back), vs complete death (VC gets no money back). When put alongside a $3B acquisition they're both completely irrelevant, even if on paper the 1x money back is not considered a "failure". Check size doesn't appear to matter, the data for YC and for VC that I've seen suggests a similar power-law-ish distribution of returns.
- andrewchoi 13y agoNitpick: VCs are optimizing for % return, not on an dollar return basis. I would say that the risk profile is not irrelevant: if you're betting that 1/10 of your investments are returning your fund, then just one miss is the difference between a good year and "I don't have a VC firm anymore". Compare that to betting that half of your investments are returning your fund: one miss is the difference between a good year and an "ehh" year.[0] That's true; when you compare both of them to a 30x, the difference between a 1x and 0x is small. But what I'm saying is that at a $15m investment, very few VCs expect to see a 30x, and when you compare it vs. a 3x or a 5x acquisition, the difference between no money back and your 1x liquidation pref paying out is much larger, proportionally. The same power law may apply, but you see more of the tails in when you have a much larger sample size. If there were just as many $15m investments happening as $20k investments, you'd see the same result, but there aren't. Off-topic: are you the same Scott Klein I talked to over the summer re: statuspage.io? [0] Of course, that glosses over different probabilities of success and failure, but what I'm trying to say is that VCs are risk averse.
- exelius 13y agoPartially true; practically not. Most VC funds do have exit dates and specific life spans (typically 7-10 years). The way it was explained to me that if you have 10 companies in your portfolio, by year 7 you will have: * 3 total busts. Out of business; zero return on investment. * 4 "walking dead". Still in business, but just barely breaking even. Might as well be zero return because these investments are not liquid (who wants to buy a 7-year-old risky business with no profit?) Anymore these end up as acqui-hires with the VC getting pennies on the dollar. * 2 minor successes. Good, profitable companies that will probably never produce a hockey-stick graph. 2x-3x return. * 1 home run. If you're lucky. 10x return (though usually closer to 5x). Her example was bad, but it was just an example. VC is a tough industry to actually make any money in. VCs don't pressure founders to do things because they are greedy, it's because they're scared of losing their shirts.
- wpietri 13y agoSome actual numbers from Fred Wilson are here: http://www.usv.com/posts/why-early-stage-venture-investments-fail http://www.usv.com/posts/why-early-stage-venture-investments... He makes the interesting point that 2/3rds of his successful investments made major changes along the way.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- exelius 13y agoBig changes in approach are inevitable in early-stage companies: things become apparent after 1-2 years that weren't initially. Early stage companies involve so much uncertainty that trying to stick to a plan for the sake of sticking to a plan is folly. His numbers are in a different context; but I get his point. Venture investing is a portfolio business; you fully expect a high failure rate.
- eloisant 13y agoMaybe the numbers could have been better chosen, but the message is correct: when you raise money, you're raising the bar for what will be called success. This is especially important now that infrastructure is close to free, it's easier now to bootstrap your company or even start it as a week-end hobby. That wasn't true in the 90s or early 2000s when you had to buy costly servers and hosting just to get started. So it is very important to know what your goal is. You want to get a slight chance to be the next Google or Facebook? You'd better raise money. You want to build a sustainable company for you and a small number of employees? Maybe raising is not the best thing to do.
- mandlar 13y agoMirror: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://modelviewculture.com/pieces/five-reasons-not-to-raise-venture-capital http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- bishnu 13y agoI found the comments about the derision of lifestyle businesses interesting, particularly in light of some of the consternation around the Tarsnap price cut [0]: [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7523953 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7523953
- danielweber 13y agoThere's a world of difference between, at one end, taking VC that puts you on a rocket ride of "get rich or die"; or, at the other end, not taking any money at all so that you cannot hire even 1 engineer to help you making the essential backup service into something that's one bus away from losing all my data.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoYou just need this sentence: "VCs aren’t unintelligent. Nor are VCs evil (not all of them anyway). They’re not even necessarily misaligned with you. What they are doing is optimizing for a very specific outcome. Share that alignment, or don’t take their money." If you understand what the VC wants and you want that too, then you are aligned. If you don't then you are making a mistake.
- crusso 13y agoGood advice that most founders who are offered $$$$$$ will ignore without the barest of a thought.
- jfoster 13y agoThat almost gets you there, but founders who misunderstand what VCs want will still take the investment. That sounds like a nitpick, except that, in my experience, lots of entrepreneurs misunderstand what VCs want, thinking that 7 - 8 digit exits are what VCs aim for.
- blinduck 13y agoI'm very curious. What is it you believe VCs aim for?
- billmalarky 13y agoI think he is suggesting VCs want much larger exits than the average founder (at higher risk). Isn't most of Y combinator's success from just a couple massive paydays (airbnb and dropbox etc)? Whereas an exit like reddit in the 15 - 20 MM range is considered a big win for the founders, but quite "meh" for the investors. VCs need big wins to be really successful.
- jfoster 13y agoThanks. That is what I was suggesting.
- 13y ago
- tlogan 13y agoBut there is one important reason why to get VC money: if you have business model working, VC money will help you (or it is necessary) to hire more people and generate more revenue. Now, of course VCs want great returns but they are also ok with ok returns.
- autarch 13y agoBut did you see the bit about preferred investment shares? An "ok" return may be ok for the VC, but it could leave the founders and options-holding employees with very little (or nothing). Contrast this to a bootstrapped company. In that case, an "ok" return can be pretty good. If you're bootstrapped and you own 40% of the company, a $5 million sale is pretty great.
- chiph 13y agoInvestors sometimes say mean things about these “lifestyle businesses” but you don’t have to care what investors think. There's nothing wrong with a lifestyle business, as long as it's run like a business. There can be decent exits (purchases by competitors, private equity, etc). But the employees seldom see a big payoff. In return, you usually get a pretty comfortable work experience.
- watwut 13y agoEmployees seldom see a big payoff. Period. Startups trade salary and benefits now for maybe huge payoff later. The maybe in previous sentence is important, most startups fail. Some business are build to stay there, grow and earn enough for founders to make them upper middle class/rich for the rest of their lives. It is different then Facebook like success, but most would count that as successful too.
- danieltillett 13y agoI have often thought that it would make sense for employees of different companies to pool any equity. You already take on enough risk being employed by a startup business without adding on your equity risk too.
- vonnik 13y agoThat's an amazing idea. What would it take?
- troels 13y agoFor one thing, you'd have to trust the people that you pool with by quite a stretch.
- apercu 13y agoGreat idea, in theory. But even if you simply shared equity across, say, a 20 or 30 person company. The agendas, the politics, the perceived golden handcuffs because of equity ownership. Hard to start a business with 20-30 people. Even if those are your 20 best friends. Now multiply this across dozens of companies. Plus, most startups give options, not equity unless you are a very early employee.
- danieltillett 13y agoThe most interesting section of this article is the very appropriately named section "venture math is a harsh mistress". Out of the 1000 companies 188 were acquired, 28 went bust big time, 8 went public, leaving 80% unaccounted for. What are all these companies doing?
- newaccountfool 13y agoIn my opinion its a no brainer to accept the money, some group is giving you $$$ for you to do what you want to do, and if you fail ther's no real downfall, you just go back to doing what you did before.
- onezerozeroone 13y agoUntil you get into the board meeting and realize you don't get to just do whatever you want to do while telling everyone what is best. If you go cowboy, you better make sure it 100% pays off, otherwise your time to failure is going to be quite short. At best you don't get more funding, at worst you get yourself blacklisted.
- danielweber 13y agoWorst outcome: just slogging along, not good enough to exit but not bad enough to kill so people can get on with their lives.
- j45 13y agoI heard an interesting explanation a while back ago about not seeking venture capital, and instead seeking an investor. Investors are more committed and interested (by the explainer) to the entrepreneur instead of looking for deal flow and exits above all else (which I guess most VCs are more interested in)
- mindcrime 13y agoThe other issue that didn't come out here, is that venture funds are time limited by definition. So it's not just that the VC fund wants their portfolio company to have a big exit, but they want them to have a big exit in a specific timeframe. This is one thing I like about bootstrapping... the timeframe goals are down to a combination of what me and my co-founders want, influenced by competitive issues. But, as it stands, our burn rate is low enough that our "runway" is, essentially, infinite. Except that's not completely true since we don't live in a static ecosystem. Other companies are out there advancing tech and making moves of their own. But still, I generally like not being bound to a VC and having to deal with the whole misalignment of objectives issues. We may still raise VC money at some point, but it'll be if/when conditions clearly mandate it - it's not something we'd do "just because that's what startups do".
- Gustomaximus 13y agoI've seen this time issue with a couple of companies. There hits a point when the VC wants to exit so they start pushing to shut down areas of a business that have future potential to maximise the expense/revenue/profit ratios within their short planned exit window.
- redguava 13y agoAn article on reasons to raise venture capital would be more appropriate. The default should be bootstrapping.
- wpietri 13y agoOh, the article's definitely appropriate, because right now there are a lot of people for whom raising money is basically the point. I mentor sometimes at startup events, and there's a big difference between the people there to build a business and the people who have been freebasing startup propaganda. I never thought I'd be nostalgic for the post-bubble period when startups were unfashionable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 13y agoIt's interesting how things work out. Since we didn't have the connections at first, we wound up getting our company to the point where we don't NEED venture capital to get to where we want to go. We can get there organically. If we take VC, it will be for a land grab and massive acceleration. So in some ways, things work out just the way they should if you don't go out of your way to chase people. Kind of like how you get married to the right person if you just keep being yourself.
- cjf4 13y agoIt baffles me that more startups don't have this approach. If you're going to take VC, you'd damn well be targeted and have a specific idea of how your going to use it to grow your business.
- mccloy 13y ago"2. Raising venture capital doesn’t make you a good person." Is there anyone out there trying to raise money because they think it'll make them a good person?
- velik_m 13y agoI think that would be probably better put as "Not raising venture capital doesn't make you a bad person", but that doesn't sound quite as good.
- Im_Talking 13y ago... because equity is gold.
- graycat 13y agoThe main problem with the OP is that it was looking at broad averages while necessarily venture capital and ambitious start ups need to be quite exceptional. The broad averages say next to nothing about the exceptional cases. In particular, the probability of being exceptional is just irrelevant. Instead, what is just crucial is the conditional probability of being exceptional given the details of the specific project. So, it's just crucial to consider the details of a particular project. A sad part about venture capital is that it is looking for exceptional projects, necessarily ones that will in effect push forward the boundary of computing in our civilization, and doing so with in nearly all cases very poor qualifications in doing or evaluating such projects. And venture capital has another problem: Too few projects on the other side of the table have much potential of such pushing the boundary. For all concerned, only a tiny fraction of the venture general partners have any hope at all of evaluating projects that push the boundary. We should be making much faster progress.
- bsaul 13y agoWonder if any VC would refuse to invest money in a very promising startup after realizing the funders are not "aligned" with the VC goals ( providing the money would give a certain amount of control of course ). We put the blame on funders for accepting, but maybe offering is to be considered as well.
- pushkargaikwad 13y agoThis is what I have learnt from my experience and what I have seen in Indian startup ecosystem 1. VC making money, Company making money and Founders making money are three different things. Don't get confused between them. Most often, the founder get the leftover, with big exit, it can be huge amount but not for everyone. 2. VCs are there to make money. That's it. That is there ONLY goal. Anyone VC firm who is saying that they are behind entrepreneurs, they are NOT. They are only after money and the entrepreneur is between them and money. So if your goal is same as their's, start chasing money. 3. You will lose your freedom for ever once you raise VC money and along with it, your choices.