4 ms·
Julia, I think you need to spend some more time considering MMC's analysis and hopefully some more significant changes to how you present and market the costs o
by zaroth 13y ago
Julia, I think you need to spend some more time considering MMC's analysis and hopefully some more significant changes to how you present and market the costs of these loans.
I had never heard of 'flat rate' vs 'declining balance' interest rates. As far as I'm concerned, it's abusing the word to call your fees an 'interest rate' because they are not. They lack the necessary property of a 'interest rate', that is, being based on balance over time. What you are charging is a fee, based on the starting balance and period. I think you should stop calling this an interest rate, and I'd be surprised if it's not illegal to do this anyway.
It sounds like your 'service fee' is ALSO a flat rate fee based on the starting balance and period, which makes splitting it out and consistently footnoting it in your marketing seem deliberately misleading. The reason we insist on APR is because you can't hide anything from it. When lenders make up terms and market them, it's almost invariably because they are trying to hide costs. Somehow this cost hiding is always couched as 'better for the borrower'.
The "it's only 63 cents" trick won't work with this crowd. Because we understand how "interest rates" are supposed to work. If it's just 63 cents, then easier to refund it than write the blog post. But 5% of $2m is $100,000 so lets get real.
MMC includes a screenshot showing 'About this Loan' a few times during the article;
Amount Requested: USD 50.00
Repayment Period: 6 weeks
Grace Period: 1 week
Offered Interest Rate: 25.00%
Service Fee: 5.00%
One-Time Reg Fee: USD 11.78
Total Amount (Including
Interest and Transaction USD 51.73 (30.00%)
Fee) to be Repaid:
It was confusing to me, even with the explanation in parenthesis, that the 'Total Amount' did not actually include all the fees. You should call it a 'Partial Amount' if you want to leave parts of the total amount out. Otherwise, it should actually be, you know, the total amount.
If you can get users to pay the 'Registration Fee' completely independently of getting a loan, then by all means, have them pay it separately, and keep it out of the loan statement. But, what I imagine really happens is, users pay this fee to get a loan, then it's a loan fee, and you have to include it when you do things like report your total loan costs!
- jkurnia 13y agoHi zaroth, Am I understanding correctly that you are suggesting we not use the term "interest", but instead call the amounts borrowers pay to lenders a fee? That is worth considering. It would avoid much of the confusion over flat rates versus APR, and would still be clear to borrowers that the amount represents the cost of the loans. I'd be interested to hear others' perspective on whether Zidisha ought not to use the term "interest" at all, but instead replace it with "fee" or some other term.
- eric_cc 13y agoAre your fees based on an interest rate?
- zaroth 13y agoThey have a "Service Fee" and an "Offered Interest Rate" both of which are calculated the same way, based on the starting balance, and the loan period.
- zaroth 13y agoI think the problems run deeper than that, because you have multiple different groups you are trying to communicate with, and some of them are getting incorrect information here. If borrowers want to know how much they are paying in interest rate, then I think you should tell them in terms of APR. If borrowers want to know how much they are paying in terms of dollars, then that's easy, just tell them. I think itemizing out fee A, fee B, fee C, is just a silly game. If you go back to your "About this Loan" table, what you call 'Service Fee' and 'Interest Rate' are the same thing, just combine them. Then, if I want to know how much they actually cost, I have to look at Total and subtract $50? But then it's still missing the "one-time fee". What if the table did say; (and I'm not saying you should do this) Loan Date: April 14, 2014 Repayment Date: June 2, 2014 (7 weeks) Amount Requested: USD 50.00 Loan Fees: USD 13.51 (200% APR) Total Amount: USD 63.51 Of course your system knows if I'm a repeat borrower, and can automatically charge the $11.78 or not. Look, it's a hard truth that the first loan has terrible terms because of the registration fee, but you can't hide from it. The only problem with this is it doesn't really help me understand how much it's going to hurt if I need more than 7 weeks to repay. But I don't know enough about your payment model to really comment on that.
- jkurnia 13y agoHi zaroth, This makes sense, and we are already doing some of that. In the loan application form that borrowers see, the 5% fee to Zidisha and the interest offered to lenders is in fact combined. Borrowers choose any combined rate from 5% up to a maximum of 30%, with a text description indicating that the first 5% of this is paid to Zidisha and the rest is paid to lenders. The loan application page also indicates the registration fee, as a cost separate from the combined interest / fee rate that the borrower selects. We separate the service fee from the lender interest in the loan applications that are displayed to lenders, because the intent is to indicate the maximum interest that they can expect to receive from each loan proposal.
- shehi 13y agoHi All, I have benefited from zidisha loans. Currently am on my third loan >>https://www.zidisha.org/microfinance/loan/Shehi/4590.html https://www.zidisha.org/microfinance/loan/Shehi/4590.html . The interest rate is in two parts: one part 5% fixed (transaction cost) and the second is flexible ( set by borrower when applying for a loan. For example my loans average at 13-15% annual interest. Zidisha loans help and are affordable compared to kiva intermediadies like Milango microfinance ( about 29% plus mandatory monthly savings) & SMEP microfinance. Thank you