3 ms·
That doesn't conform very well to my understanding or experience. Citation?
by dllthomas 13y ago
That doesn't conform very well to my understanding or experience. Citation?
- EC1 13y agoYou're a special little snowflake then. Here's your citation: [SOURCE]
- dllthomas 13y agoWhat?
- recursive 13y agoAs a person who is generally considered to be good with scary numbers, I can confirm that this is exactly how it works for me.
- dllthomas 13y agoFor the record, I have no trouble at all believing that it works that way for many people. The claim was that this is how it works for everyone, and that I find questionable - in my experience, some people work better verbally than visually. I'm pretty good visually, but it definitely feels like I'm engaging different systems when I am reasoning using words than when I am reasoning using images - and I don't expect this generalizes.
- Double_Cast 13y agoI too believe that math is most easily understood geometrically. I've suspected this since highschool, when I personally derived many of these gifs during trig class. I don't have anything more than anecdotes to support this hypothesis, but it shouldn't be surprising given that an entire brain lobe (occipital) is devoted to visual processing [1]. And remember how our first introduction to numbers was "the number line"? The reals are isomorphic to a line, but defining the reals as a line isn't feasible since a line doesn't differentiate the rationals from the reals (or anything in between). But on the other hand, showing kids a line is easier to grok than defining numbers as "an ordered field", isn't it? Also consider that Newton invented calculus using infinitesimals, which made sense to him spatially but didn't find rigorous footing until Weierstrass [2]. Additionally, the Greeks used to refer to finding a figure's area as "quadrature" [3], i.e. finding the area of an equivalent square. If not universal, I'd say geometric interpretations were at least pretty widespread. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occipital_lobe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occipital_lobe [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/(%CE%B5,_%CE%B4)-definition_of_limit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/(%CE%B5,_%CE%B4)-definition_of_... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadrature_(mathematics) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadrature_(mathematics)
- dllthomas 13y ago"If not universal, I'd say geometric interpretations were at least pretty widespread." I'd have had no objection to that. Clearly, many people do learn visually and clearly many people are good at manipulating mental imagery. Support them! Just be careful you're not ignoring those that don't (or at least know that that's what you're doing). If you're going to make a case that there are no such people (or a negligible number) then that needs support. The story here about imagination seems highly relevant (along with the broader point): http://lesswrong.com/lw/dr/generalizing_from_one_example http://lesswrong.com/lw/dr/generalizing_from_one_example
- Double_Cast 13y agoI'm familiar with the typical-mind-fallacy posts and glad to see a LW reference on HN. Just the other day, I read Eliezer's article on Algernon's Law [1]. It's tangentially related. Incidentally, it precedes LW by a decade! His thesis sounds reasonable to me. But I thought MBTI test sounded reasonable too, which I learned doesn't have any empirical backing. So my intuitions may be less than reliable. meh. > According to Galton, people incapable of forming images were overrepresented in math and science. I've since heard that this idea has been challenged, but I can't access the study. So yes, I guess some lack a visual imagination. But I've seen several people enlightened by diagrams, and never seen anyone enlightened via plug-&-chug formulas. So I'd be surprised if a visual imagination did'n confer some kind of advantage in math. I highly doubt that a visual imagination confers a disadvantage, given that Euler had photographic memory. But I concede that the null hypothesis is certainly likely. Yvain says he can't access Galton's study. After a few minutes Googling, I gave up too after I hit a paywal. [1] http://web.archive.org/web/200102021712/http://sysopmind.com/algernon.html http://web.archive.org/web/200102021712/http://sysopmind.com...
- dllthomas 13y ago"But I've seen several people enlightened by diagrams, and never seen anyone enlightened via plug-&-chug formulas." I've personally experienced being enlightened by both, with respect to different things. I probably lean more toward the visual, but don't expect everyone does (without more, carefully gathered, evidence). "I highly doubt that a visual imagination confers a disadvantage" That would surprise me as well, assuming nothing was sacrificed for that visual imagination (and even then I expect a visual imagination to be more useful than many things).