4 ms·
I've been following (sort of) the back and forth on this and find it quite interesting. Here's a question though: what happens when the "whale" is really somet
by davidw 13y ago
I've been following (sort of) the back and forth on this and find it quite interesting. Here's a question though: what happens when the "whale" is really something like an index fund that, ultimately, is composed mostly of retail investors? Aren't they getting ripped off in that case? This isn't a rhetorical question, I'm curious to know how it plays out.
- exelius 13y agoYes. But you get ripped off less in an index fund since in general, they are also run by algos within other algos that just rebalance to match whatever they're tracking. The idea if you're an investment firm is that index funds can hide risky investments: they're often large and they're often not highly leveraged. In reality, index funds are the safest way for individuals to make money in the market because you're placing a bet on the economy as a whole.
- harryh 13y agoHere's the CIO of Vanguard (who run some of the biggest index funds in the world) saying that HFTs cut costs: http://www.cnbc.com/id/49434073 http://www.cnbc.com/id/49434073
- daveed 13y agoI think it really depends on what you mean by ripped off. I think that institutional investors looking to place multi-million dollar moves shouldn't be able to just place an order and cry foul when it's not completely filled on all the exchanges either. From another point of view, that's the slippage you get from an improper order placement strategy.
- crdoconnor 13y ago>Here's a question though: what happens when the "whale" is really something like an index fund that, ultimately, is composed mostly of retail investors? Aren't they getting ripped off in that case? Damn right they're getting ripped off. The defense in the OP is essentially "yes, that can happen but it's very rare". Which is about as believable as it sounds.