6 ms·
Serious reading takes a hit from online scanning and skimming, researchers say
- terranstyler 13y agoTLDR: People's brains become optimized for TLDR
- petercooper 13y agoI'm an extreme version of this because it's my job to read several hundred articles every week and curate and summarize them, so my entire reading process has been optimized to rapidly grasping something, contextualizing it, and moving on. It's amazing how good you can get at this over time and I consider it to be a very positive thing in terms of my reading. In other contexts, I think there have been a few slightly negative psychological side effects, such as struggling to watch full TV shows without fast forwarding through the "boring" bits, or choosing to watch other people playing computer games on YouTube rather than playing them myself because I get bored too easily. But in general I seem to thrive on having an impatient, jumpy brain.. for now!
- DonaldH 13y ago> choosing to watch other people playing computer games on YouTube rather than playing them myself because I get bored too easily Could you please elaborate a little bit on this? I'm intrigued - I assumed that actively playing a game would be less boring than passively watching someone else play. I'm not a gamer though so I really have no idea.
- zokier 13y agoI can't answer for parent comment, but one possibility is that youtube (in theory) allows skipping ahead, real games do not.
- worrieddot 13y agoWith "Let's Plays", you're there for the commentary, it's not just a quiet walkthrough. The downside of this is that you, as a viewer, have no timely input (episodes are sometimes done in batches and uploaded over a week or two). But.. maybe that's the attraction, back to the days of yore when you would yell at the Jeopardy/Wheel of Fortune contestants for not getting the obvious answer! Source: I watch LPs constantly while working, it's good background noise and gives me an easy outlet to divert my attention.
- petercooper 13y agoI think it's a bit like watching TV vs reading a book for a lot of people. When something is on a conveyor belt into your brain, it's easier to let it flow even if the experience is cheaper, whereas playing a game or reading a book requires a significantly extra level of 'participation'. Of course, it could just be that I'm getting old, the dopamine hits from gaming aren't there as much anymore and that I'd rather watch skilled people at work ;-)
- mironathetin 13y ago"It's amazing how good you can get at this over time and I consider it to be a very positive thing in terms of my reading." How do you check, how good you are? Do you have other persons reading the texts carefully and compare to your summaries?
- petercooper 13y agoFor me it's more business-like than that: am I more productive? There's also an element of (occasional) reader feedback and the increasing size of the audience and positive reaction to the materials. These things do not measure quality with any finesse, but do at least provide a crude indication of whether the perceived quality is above or below audience-acceptable levels.
- johnchristopher 13y agoWould you be okay with providing more context ? What kind of articles are you summarizing and for how long have you been doing it ? Have you read Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry Into the Value of Work from Crawford ? Any opinion on his description of a content farm ? Are you reading literature ? Any changes in your reading pattern ?
- Synaesthesia 13y agoDefinitely find this to be true, trying to read a complex Umberto Eco novel after a steady diet of web scanning for the last 10 years is quite a task! But worthwhile. I have to force myself to read properly for the first time in a long time.
- askar_yu 13y agoThat moment when you're skimming through an article which is about skimming and scanning. Yet you keep speeding and scrolling through the content which in turn is revealing what you're experiencing as you're just reading about it.
- rdwallis 13y agoScanning and skimming is a problem caused by UI. The way we scroll text on computers and other devices destroys reading flow. I built an extension / bookmarklet that allows you to scroll websites in a different way and goes a long way to solving this problem on desktop browsers. I hope no one minds me reposting it, it was very popular on hn a while ago. http://www.magicscroll.net/ScrollTheWeb.html http://www.magicscroll.net/ScrollTheWeb.html
- cliveowen 13y agoI find that line more distracting than scrolling. I don't know what the solution might be, but this is not it.
- rdwallis 13y agoThe line takes a bit of getting used to. The trick is not to use it to underline the text you're currently reading but to keep the line a good distance ahead of where you are in the text.
- zokier 13y agoI think it might be more natural if it had gradient below the line: http://i.imgur.com/8ku3OoL.png http://i.imgur.com/8ku3OoL.png I'm not sure if white or black gradient would be better though.
- rdwallis 13y agoThanks, this is a common suggestion and I've tried a version with a shadow below the line. It is far more distracting especially when you use the autoscroll feature (play button at the bottom right corner.) If you want to experiment the source code is at https://github.com/rdwallis/MagicScrollWebReader https://github.com/rdwallis/MagicScrollWebReader The line is an impossible challenge to design because the break between pages should be very obvious but also not distracting to the reader.
- laichzeit0 13y agoI do this because I don't want to spend too much time reading crap or second-rate writing. Essentially stuff someone decided to blog because they're bloggers or had a "cool" idea. If something takes 30 minutes to write, I probably want to spend about 30 seconds reading it. But on great works which an author has spent years thinking about before even committing it to writing; or have gone through several revisions of it, I will devote my time to slow-reading and understanding.
- ColinWright 13y agoPrint version, avoiding the ads and giving simple, direct text, instead of having to meander around the ads and inserts: http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/serious-reading-takes-a-hit-from-online-scanning-and-skimming-researchers-say/2014/04/06/088028d2-b5d2-11e3-b899-20667de76985_print.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/serious-reading-takes-a-... Edit: Interesting - a down-vote.
- tokenadult 13y agoColin, it wasn't my downvote, and I hardly ever downvote comments like that, but I hardly ever upvote them either, because it doesn't add to the DISCUSSION here, really, to tell people about an optional view of the Web content that is (usually) easily discoverable by every user. Even in a Hacker News discussion with the immediate context of this discussion, about readability, most such comments are at best a no-op.
- userbinator 13y agoI wonder if this has anything to do with the fact that people don't seem to be as careful and deliberate in reading things like manuals and instructions as they used to. I have on countless occasions pointed someone to an important piece of information in some documentation, and been responded to with an "oh, I looked here but I didn't see that."
- coldpie 13y agoI think that might partly be due to the deluge of useless information in most documentation. I read through the instructions for a meat grinder we picked up the other week. It had about 10 pages. About half of one page somewhere in the middle was real content (how to attach it to the stand mixer, how to prepare the meat, etc.), and the rest of the packet was recipes and pages and pages of warnings and warranty information and other garbage. It's easy to skip the important bits when they compose just 5% of the whole product.
- logn 13y agoOn a meta-level... I think this style of reporting is terrible for the topic. There are three main voices: the journalist, the scientists, and an everyday person. The only one I trust on this are the scientists and the others are just confusing the whole issue. On top of this, there are some humanities professors the journalist treats as scientific authority. All of this is woven together in a pseudo-science tale that's really not worth a careful read.
- coldtea 13y ago>On top of this, there are some humanities professors the journalist treats as scientific authority. Well, they are. Their field is how humanity understands itself, and what traditions (historical, literary, etc) and values we have. The results of the "real" scientists are useless when not valued and judged under a humanist interpretation. E.g, scientific measurable fact: "We're reading less". OK, so what? Is that good or bad -- not with regards to mere "evolution" (which might not even be applicable to such timespans and matters), but concerning the kind of society we want to build? That's where the humanities professors come into to play (as does "the man on the street" -- we're all men on the street, after all).
- logn 13y agoDiscerning any scientific results from this article was impossible when filtered by all non-scientists. I'm happy to see lay/ethical/moral discussions of research but I'd like to at least clearly see the science first. The information presented in this article wasn't different than what any average group of people could have come up with over lunch, but it's written with this authoritative and dramatic tone like we're all learning something. They bring up some startling 'scientific facts', that the internet may be permanently changing our brains and destroying reading ability. There's some confused explanations of evolution (or lack thereof) thrown in. Can we all try to understand this first before we zip to a pleasant concluding paragraph from a mother raising kids?
- Raphmedia 13y agoThis happens to me a lot. I have to take a pause and consciously focus on reading the text that is in front of me. Otherwise, I simply skim it. Sure, I get enough information to understand the article and talk about it, but I hate how I can't read a whole text as easily as I once did.
- zokier 13y agoThis is one reason I like to read anything significant on Kindle. Scanning and skimming is not really something Kindle tends to, having only small amount of content visible at time (I tend to have relatively large font size) and slow page turn speed.
- dwc 13y agoAlso, having a dedicated device for in-depth reading makes it easier for me to switch into that mode.
- arjie 13y agoI feel like the Kindle has too little text available, though. I read certain kinds of fiction far faster on actual books than on the Kindle. Perhaps the text size I find comfortable would be much better on a Kindle DX. Also, the fact that Kindle 'pages' for a text file are not fixed is a bit of a problem. For instance, with a real book if it refers to a previous event and I wish to read it again (sometimes climaxes can be great to read again) I can usually remember a page range and a location on the page (top left, right side) that lead to me being able to identify it in seconds, but I've often gone backwards in a Project Gutenberg eBook to find that the location of the words has changed! A very disconcerting effect.
- dublinben 13y ago1. If you decrease the text size on a kindle, you can display quite a bit of text on each screen. 2. E-books don't have a concept of "pages." They're essentially responsive html documents, and should be full of links (both internal and external).
- kisielk 13y ago> Humans, they warn, seem to be developing digital brains with new circuits for skimming through the torrent of information online. This alternative way of reading is competing with traditional deep reading circuitry developed over several millennia. Where's the evidence that we've developed "traditional deep reading circuitry" over several millennia? That's presented in the article without any justification.
- fluidcruft 13y agoI agree with this criticism. I'm also skeptical that literacy rates have ever been high enough to plausibly drive selection pressure.
- mcguire 13y agoIndeed. Given the availability of reading material and the skill of reading, any "circuitry" would have to be a relatively recent effect in the general population. Further, if "new circuits" are developing over a few tens of years, why would anyone expect the "traditional circuits" to have taken longer? It seems to me unlikely that this is anything other than an individual behavioral difference.
- saturdaysaint 13y agoFor those interested in further reading (ha), I can't recommend Nicholas Carr's The Shallows: What The Internet Is Doing To Our Brains enough. Just a profound meditation on technology's effect on humanity, particularly pertaining to our Google/internet era. Frankly, he's more skeptical about technology than I am, but I find his perspective genuinely useful for raising interesting questions that have changed my thinking.
- dwc 13y agoI'm pretty sure that I read more longer pieces than I used to, as so much is available for any topic of interest. In fact, I must decline to read some things simply due to time constraints. Contrast that with getting a magazine once per month, where I was much more willing to "curl up with a good article" even if it wasn't so good, where I was willing to wade through asides on the colorful characters of the main players. These days, I want non-fiction articles to get to the damned point. I'm fine with long articles, but I don't want my time wasted. Not long ago I began reading popular coverage of an exciting scientific finding. The article began with something like this: "John grew up in a small Ohio town. His father was a clerk at a hardware store and his mother worked for an optometrist." Close tab. That might have been fine pre-internet, but it's not what I want now. Things have changed, but writers and editors are still operating in the old model. I don't mind humor, style, interesting biographical bits, et al, but I want them to occur in reasonably sized chunks inline with the actual subject matter. But mostly I want the information that was promised in the headline. For fiction... I still buy books and read them on kindle. I buy and read more new books now than I used to. I don't think I'm all that unusual among people who habitually read.
- crpatino 13y agoI don't think this is the same phenomena the article was talking about. It is not that online readers lack the ability/patience to read long pointless text-walls. It is that they seem unable to grok longer, come complex texts. As a programmer, I have been reading online my whole adult life, and probably spend online much more than the average (but "civilians" seem to be catching up, fast). I do not feel I am particularly affected by this effects, but I (and I suspect you as well) have do deal on a daily basis with complex, artificial, information dense constructions all the time. Contrast that with the mindless stream of tweets, likes and lolcats that fall on the typical user every day. Also, I as well as you read fiction but online and in paper. It's hard to measure but I'd say at least a million words per year. This quantity is not typical at all. On the other hand, even amateur fanfiction is authored with an audience in mind and goes to at least an order of magnitude more composition and editing than whatever piece of crap we send/recv over the privacy of out SMS on a daily basis. So yes, I think you are pretty well protected from the debilitating symptoms of these new disease (if you allow me to call it that way).
- jwmerrill 13y agoScanning and skimming is good, most of the time. It means you are taking an active role in deciding what parts of a document are relevant to your purpose. In the bad old days, you had fewer alternatives and higher switching costs, so you just read what was in front I you. With the internet, the next best alternative is so available and so good that you might as well spend some time browsing and quickly discarding the fluff so you can find the really good stuff. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meta_learning http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meta_learning
- mixologic 13y agotl;dr
- epo 13y agoIf you scan or skim then you miss stuff. You have no idea whether or not what you missed is important because you didn't see it. And so comments by people self-importantly declaring themselves to be more effective by scanning/skimming are in effect saying "I didn't read that bit because I knew it wasn't important and, despite not having read it, I know I was right not to read it". What you mean is you have an impaired attention span. Scanning or skimming can only be optimal with carefully structured texts where you know what to expect, e.g. textbooks where the beginning and end of chapters contain synopses.
- 6d0debc071 13y agoWhat I mean is that time is finite and a piece only has so long to convince me that it's worth reading in depth. While it's possible that a mostly skipped paragraph contained something worthwhile, if I've read a decent number of other paragraphs from that source and they didn't, that's not the way to bet.
- npsimons 13y agoIt's been said before[1] and I'll say it again: some things aren't worth your full reading attention. Heck, even if they were, you don't have enough time to read everything[2]. That being said, I am a little worried that people (at least myself) aren't getting as "deep" into topics as they might have used to. I try to solve this by (very carefully!) picking books that I can slowly digest, over multiple readings. If nothing else, just reading them at the inspectional and superficial levels can help me decide whether I need to go back for more. [1] - See "How to Read a Book" [2] - https://what-if.xkcd.com/76/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/76/
- whoopdedo 13y agoWhenever I start reading an internet article in depth, I get a nagging feeling that I'm putting more effort into reading the article than was put into writing it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]