3 ms·
But any method for helping people become more productive is going to require significant effort and enforcement. Possibly, but I'm not sure we should take that
by kbenson 13y ago
But any method for helping people become more productive is going to require significant effort and enforcement.
Possibly, but I'm not sure we should take that at face value. There's another Planet Money story[0] about the efficacy of just giving money to people. If you accept that reducing poverty lets people become more productive by applying more of their available effort towards actions that do more than just sustain life, I think this at least puts enough question to that assertion to make it something that needs qualification.
One possible way to help is to use technology to reduce the need for large corporations, by making more and more things doable by smaller and smaller groups of people.
How does that account for the increased efficiencies gained from being large, e.g. bulk logistics? Walmart, split into 5,000 smaller individual stores, would likely not be able to match the prices of Walmart the mega-corporation, even if only due to bulk shipping and purchasing efficiencies (and leverage) gained by the single larger version.
Great discussion though, +1's all the way up the stack for you and mrow84.
[0]: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/10/25/240590433/what-happens-when-you-just-give-money-to-poor-people http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/10/25/240590433/what-hap...
- pdonis 13y ago> There's another Planet Money story[0] about the efficacy of just giving money to people. It does look like many of these people used the money to increase their productivity, yes (for example, by starting businesses). But from what I can see, GiveDirectly has only been in existence since 2010. I'll be interested to see what their numbers look like ten years from now, if they're still around. (My prediction, for what it's worth: (1) the fraction of people receiving their money who actually become more productive will go down (more people trying to game the system); (2) their overhead will go up (more money being spent on trying to prevent people from gaming the system).) It's definitely an experiment worth trying. > How does that account for the increased efficiencies gained from being large, e.g. bulk logistics? I said "more and more things", not "all things". Yes, there are probably some areas in which economies of scale are large enough that large corporations are more efficient on net than smaller ones. But I suspect there are fewer such areas than most people believe, and I think technology can make there be fewer still.