4 ms·
I think you should read it again. We talked about the term "to live of". It's pedantic as was claimed that with that i meant would die from. Especially if you
by ThomPete 13y ago
I think you should read it again.
We talked about the term "to live of". It's pedantic as was claimed that with that i meant would die from. Especially if you know anything about what happens to people who make that little a year in terms of government subsidizing.
Let me repeat. This discussion has NOTHING absolutely nothing to do with what other people do in other countries. We were talking about the US we where talking about the problem of wages being pushed into two extremes.
- tptacek 13y agoI agree that wage disparity in the US is a problem, but the reason you gave for it was false. Specifically, you said that the reason that wage disparity is a problem is that it is impossible for a family to "live on" the incomes from a Wal-Mart job, and therefore the government is required to subsidize them. You made an argument that was trivial for Chris Stucchio to dismiss: for every Wal-Mart employee making $14,000/yr, 6-8 Indian people are living with far less (PPP adjusted!), and raising families while doing it. Now you're stuck; you either have to come up with an argument that Indian people are different from Americans, or that Indian people are "not really living". Neither argument is fun to defend, as you've made very apparent. My suggestion is, make better arguments, or at least, don't complain so loudly when your bad arguments are routed by facts. Look: neither of us are going to solve income inequality by talking about it on HN. As you can see by the pale cast your comments seem to be taking on almost as soon as you write them, it's unlikely you're going to do much of anything to move the world forward by advocating for this issue today. But one thing we can do to make the world better is to get better at having discussions with people that disagree with us. Maybe start with that here on HN. I find 'yummyfajitas arguments painful to read. Most of the time, they create an annoying feeling of knowing he must be wrong, via a sort of deontological spidey-sense, but not knowing exactly how to rebut him. But that's a good thing, not a bad one: it means that to argue with him, you need to do better than playing to a crowd of people who already agree with you. And after all, what would be the point of doing that?
- ThomPete 13y agoAgain. I can point to places where people have it much better than in the US what does that prove? You are basically saying that we can't discuss the US because there are other places where people are worse of. Otherwise it make no sense to point to other places where people are worse of. This is not about argument, this is about premise for the discussion. I am not buying yours or any other who use other countries as an argument for why it's not a problem that people on low wages have to be subsidized. If you don't think it's a problem they have to be then we disagree. It's as simple as that.
- tptacek 13y agoFrustrating, isn't it! It's a problem, but the problem isn't that low wages at Wal-mart are making it impossible to live a meaningful life, because the world is full of people doing exactly that despite even worse conditions! We don't think about it a lot because of our cultural context. But, like Chris said: "check your privilege". The (rather gigantic) example of Asian rural poor might foreclose on your argument that Wal-mart wages are "un-livable". It might not if you can marshall a better argument, but that's not the tack I'd take. What you're missing is that "Wal-mart wages are un-livable" isn't the only argument against income inequality; in fact, it's one of the poorer ones, as I think you've now seen.
- ThomPete 13y agoYou are basically cherry picking things I said out of a larger discussion and taking a premise that was forced into this discussion in order to claim "someone is worse off". Here is what I wrote: "...The problem is that the jobs that are left for those without a tech degree of some sort aren't appreciated by the market and is forcing salaries down way below what is possible to live off. Walmart is a much more accurate way to look at what automation does..." That was then turned into a discussion about the term "possible to live off" which frankly in the context we are talking here is juvenile and unnecessarily pedantic. Do you really believe that I meant will die from? But sure I am guilty of falling for it given I was assuming at least some intellectual honesty from the person I was discussing with. I now see it was just a way to throw the "someone is worse off" card which is very convenient yet completely besides the point. I never even made an argument against income inequality so why you judge my posts on that is beyond my understanding. And unless you or anyone else is talking about a global redistribution of wealth comparing to other countries is not only weak it's a false claim of morality. Each country should be able to discuss the merits of it's own societies status quo without having to point to people starving to death in Ethiopia.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI find 'yummyfajitas arguments painful to read. Most of the time, they create an annoying feeling of knowing he must be wrong, via a sort of deontological spidey-sense, but not knowing exactly how to rebut him. Part of the reason for this is that my underlying values are nearly the same as yours. In terms of values, I'm nearly a standard NY liberal [1]. For example, you probably favor either Basic Income or a Welfare State - I prefer a Basic Job. Our underlying reasons are the same (don't let people starve), we just differ on which policy will actually achieve the best outcome for the lowest price. In contrast, someone with libertarian values would be fine letting people starve, even if he preferred a Basic Job to other policy proposals. [1] The only big points where my values differ are on inequality, which I don't view as an intrinsic problem (maybe it's an extrinsic one, but I'm unconvinced). I also don't buy into the racial/sexual collectivism of modern liberalism - I.e., I don't believe "women" have rights, I believe only an individual woman does.
- tptacek 13y agoMaybe. You seem at heart to be a consequentialist. Although I wouldn't call myself religious, morally I sort of see myself as a straightforward product of Catholic school. Also: perhaps because you're better at math than I am, you come across to me as somewhat astringently rationalist. It's noticeable in discussions where logic and orthodoxy conflict, for instance in discussions about race and IQ. I get how that's a result of the issues selected for discussion on HN, and the way they tend to get discussed; you could be mistaken for a libertarian in the same way I could be mistaken as a shill for NSA. Happily, in neither yummyfajitasland nor tptacekland will anyone be starving, although tptacekland also has single-payer health care.
- khafra 13y ago> Maybe. You seem at heart to be a consequentialist. Although I wouldn't call myself religious, morally I sort of see myself as a straightforward product of Catholic school. Interesting--normally I see neo-reactionaries linking progressivism with christian tradition; and it's not meant as a compliment. I don't think I've ever seen a progressive endorsing that link before. Also, I should note that I'm a consequentialist (although in practice I try to use virtue ethics), and closer to tptacekian politics than yummyfajitian politics.