3 ms·
I think you have a fundamental misunderstanding of the difference between a secular and a religious "marriage". Religious institutions have always been allowed
by bane 13y ago
I think you have a fundamental misunderstanding of the difference between a secular and a religious "marriage". Religious institutions have always been allowed to marry or not marry as they see fit. Quite a few religions and religious factions have provide same-sex marriages long before it was ever explicitly allowed in law.
When most people get a regular 'ol marriage, it's actually two events. Their religious marriage, as recognized by their faith, and the civil "marriage" as defined and recognized by law. You can get one without the other if you wish. Just get a religious marriage, and don't bother with the legal licensing and registration, or conversely, just get a legal marriage and don't bother with the religious aspects of it. I can't say it's always been this way, but it's basically always been this way.
The problem comes from the simply face that there's a very large body of law that required people to enter into an agreement specifically called "marriage" for those laws to apply to them. More importantly SCOTUS has recognized "marriage" as a fundamental right.
In theory, same-sex couple always had the right to get married, legally and religiously (if their religion allowed), and should have had those laws apply to them. But it was only recently when same-sex couples tried to enforce the application of those laws on themselves that the legal hypocrisy became apparent and government attempted to separate those people from their legal right.
If law had used the word "quijibo" instead of "marriage" it wouldn't have mattered any. People could have gotten religiously married, then filed for their quijibo. The word choice is irrelevant, other than the legal inertia that's already behind the word.
- baddox 13y ago> Religious institutions have always been allowed to marry or not marry as they see fit. Correct me if I'm reading this wrong [0], but it seem that a New Jersey court ruled in 2012 that a religious facility could not deny usage to homosexual couple for civil union ceremonies. From my quick Googling, it seems this is a big concern for Christian groups in the US, but I don't know how credible their concern is. [0] http://www.adfmedia.org/files/OGCMA-BernsteinRuling.pdf http://www.adfmedia.org/files/OGCMA-BernsteinRuling.pdf Edit: with a bit more Googling, it seems fairly common for state governments to prohibit discriminating based on sexual orientation for the sale of goods and services, which would (I assume) apply to churches being used for ceremonies. There have also been court cases involving wedding cakes, flowers, and photography. http://abcnews.go.com/US/judge-orders-colorado-bakery-cater-sex-weddings/t/story?id=21136505 http://abcnews.go.com/US/judge-orders-colorado-bakery-cater-... http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/28/gay-wedding-flowers-case_n_3516294.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/28/gay-wedding-flowers... Proposed city law in Kansas: http://www.hutchgov.com/egov/docs/1332537777_170654.pdf http://www.hutchgov.com/egov/docs/1332537777_170654.pdf http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/12/30/nj-rules-against-church-g_n_154128.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/12/30/nj-rules-against-ch...
- pessimizer 13y agoIt's become a big issue in Britain - but that's mostly because they have a state church. It's certainly not outside of the realm of possibility, but I've heard of mixed race marriage ceremonies being explicitly denied by churches in the US, and don't ever remember any recourse that the couples had other than the court of public opinion.
- bane 13y agoWell they always had a recourse. Get married someplace else. Go to a different church, or if your sect forbids it, get to a different sect, and if your religion forbids it, make your own sect, and if that's too much work, just get a civil marriage. I know it's not quite that simple, people get very hung up on where they spend their Fridays, Saturdays or Sundays, but people usually have options of some sort.
- baddox 13y agoSure, but one could say the same for "whites only" businesses in the American south. African Americans could just eat, fill up their gas tanks, buy clothes, etc. "someplace else." The Civil Rights Acts makes it clear that the people (or at least the government) does not endorse that form of self-determination.
- bane 13y agoExcept that religious tolerance, including tolerance for religious organization's religiously grounded specific discrimination stances, is specifically enshrined in the Constitution. Businesses have no similar or even remotely analogous protection. Drawing an analogy between an organized religious organization like a Church and a business like a restaurant is a fundamental misunderstanding of the law. This specific dividing line has been held up over and over again in cases where religious organizations incorporate a business entity, and then wish to push particular discrimination policies specific to their practices into that business. A White Supremacist church is free to be discriminatory, but the bakery it owns and runs as a separate business entity is not for example. However, IIR, a religiously owned organization, like a corporation, may choose to discriminate based on religion. So the White Supremacist Church's bakery, let's say it's Lutheran, may choose not to hire non-Lutherans at its bakery. This was actually held up by SCOTUS in a 1987 decision for a Mormon church owned corporation. edit http://www.ecfa.org/Content/TopicReligiousDiscrim http://www.ecfa.org/Content/TopicReligiousDiscrim