15 ms·
I am not misreading your comment. I am telling you that this discussion has nothing to do with how other countries are doing its not an argument for anything I
by ThomPete 13y ago
I am not misreading your comment. I am telling you that this discussion has nothing to do with how other countries are doing its not an argument for anything I have been talking about.
What is it sopposed to be an argument for? In Scandinavia everyone is getting free healthcare. Whats the argument?
I have been talking about the fact that technology is driving some types of jobs up in yearly salaries and other types of salaries down. The middle class is disappearing and those jobs that are available for a growing number of people does not allow them to live for that salary.
So no I am not misunderstanding anything and I am not being downvoted because of that. I am being downvoted because some people are getting emotional.
- tptacek 13y agoNo, what you're doing is insisting that the plight of Indian subsistence farmers has nothing to do with the plight of Section 8 tenants in Englewood. What everyone else is trying to do is figure out why that would be the case. Both groups of people are humans. One group doesn't have consistent running water or electricity. The other does, along with a car, air conditioning, cable television, and schools. The existence of the former group is very inconvenient for your belief that the latter group isn't paid enough to live on. You're being downvoted because you're simply wrong. That doesn't mean income inequality isn't a problem; I happen to believe it is a problem, unlike Chris Stucchio. But not for the false reason you think it is.
- ThomPete 13y agoThis is as an absurd discussion. If you think it's without problems that the US have to subsidize many people who have jobs because it's worse in India then we disagree. I think it's problematic that the salaries in the US seem to be pushed into two extremes. If you think it's a problem that technology ends up pushing those two extremes in the US no matter what happens on the north pole, india or bangladesh, then we agree. There is nothing inconvenient about other countries living situation. But if you want to play that game then lets also include the people of Scandinavia, France etc who enjoy free healtcare no matter how much they make. The only thing that seems to be inconvenient here is discussing the situation for those who make 15000 a year. Thats the only reason why for some other worldly reason you want to ignore it by saying other people have it worse. I am not in the wrong here you are. You are just trying to push a premise on to me that first of all isn't an argument for anything as I can find countries where people do in fact get more than 15.000USD a year even if they have no job. And who do in fact get free healthcare. And second of all has nothing to do with what I have been talking about at all. But I see you guys have made up your mind so nothing fruitful is going to come from this discussion.
- tptacek 13y agoThe idea that you'd see an issue bloc made up of me and Chris Stucchio is pretty strong evidence that you're missing something here.