4 ms·
He has not said anything hateful. No, he just gave them money. Given the choice, I'd rather he stand outside of Mozilla's corporate office holding an allcaps s
by Karunamon 13y ago
He has not said anything hateful.
No, he just gave them money. Given the choice, I'd rather he stand outside of Mozilla's corporate office holding an allcaps sign covered in slurs ala Westboro Baptist than financially support them. At least his personal actions don't contribute to further oppression in that case.
doesn't mean he should be the target of a smear campaign
What smear campaign? Every criticism of Eich that I've both read and given focuses on 3 objective and concrete things.
1. He donated money to a group that can be charitably described as a "hate group". This alone wouldn't be so bad, but:
2. He had a chance to walk that back, say that he changed his mind, say that was a long time ago, and did not. In fact, he quit his job rather than do so. Which leads into:
3. He poorly handled this entire event, which calls his credentials for being a CEO in the first place into question.
That's not a smear campaign by any conceivable definition of the words.
That's why I'm rejecting the gay rights movement's online bullying tactics.
Again, 3 facts. Not opinions, facts. Facts cannot be bullying, else any critical analysis of something important to a person becomes "bullying".
He did not turn the blame around to say your perception is wrong.
He went well out of his way to avoid directly confronting anything that would have confirmed or denied this verbally. But, his actions did that for us.
He is the target of your hate
I appreciate your zen, but I do not hate Eich. I think he was a poor choice for CEO and is a hypocrite. He's not someone I'd care to work with or under since he demonstrably dislikes me for who I am, having never met me.
That is not hate. If I have any vitriol at all, it's directed at his defenders and those that want to make him a martyr for "freedom of speech".
It's not proven that he behaved badly
Donating $1000 to a hate group is not "behaving badly"? This is a matter of public record.
Express how much pain Prop 8 caused. Express why this is an inequality & how that affects you. Don't act with vengeance
Which I've gone well out of my way to do. Yet somehow, just be repeating facts about Eich's observable actions, I am acting with "hate" and "vengeance".
Sorry, but I do not see it.
- briantakita 13y ago> Donating $1000 to a hate group is not "behaving badly"? Prop 8 is a proposition, not a hate group. This redefinition is scary and files a "hate group" as being anyone who disagrees with your position. Supporting a proposition is his right and it is ok. I don't see his intent as being hateful. Ignorant, but not hate. > If I have any vitriol at all, it's directed at his defenders and those that want to make him a martyr for "freedom of speech". That sounds like you hate me now. It also sounds like you hate freedom, sorry to say. I'm aware of the cliché, but you said it. Funny how the moderates are targeted by extremists. --- I'm getting into activism myself, so I understand how important this is to you. All I can say is keep your humanity & honor in the process. Your movement will be better off.
- Karunamon 13y agoThe political organization that's behind Prop 8 (the people that Eich donated to, since you can't donate to a bill) quacks like a hate group in a number of ways, not least of which is they dehumanize and make fun of LGBTs. If you have not already, please view that slate.com link I sent you a couple posts ago. You can ignore the text there as it's basically what I've been saying here verbatim, but I would ask you to pay special attention to the videos - they are actual ads that the group put together and which actually aired in California. Maybe then you'll see why I apply this label - I didn't just arbitrarily dredge it up as the worst possible thing I could think of to call them. >That sounds like you hate me now. I find it very puzzling that you say I am practicing all this hatred by saying I find Eich's actions repugnant, and now you're saying I'm practicing hatred toward you by simply having a (remarkably civil and productive) discussion with you. Yet Eich is the guy who wants people to be second class citizens. Does. Not. Compute.
- scintill76 13y agoThis article[0]? My response is that Eich didn't personally approve these ads, and may have had no way of possibly knowing what his money would actually fund. (I'd be interested in evidence about the visibility of any prior work, the timing of his donation, etc., though.) If you find simply supporting the idea repugnant, sure, but then arguments like "he donated to a hate group" and Slate's "The Campaign for Prop 8 Was Unprecedentedly Cruel" aren't really necessary. If they pushed a law that is hateful to the core, it's less relevant how hateful or not the group itself was. I suppose if he did see and regret the ads, he could have said so, but AFAIK has said nothing. Then again, he probably felt that doing anything other than a long thorough apology, donating to pro-gay-marriage groups, crying for forgiveness, etc., would dig the hole deeper. [0] http://www.slate.com/blogs/outward/2014/04/04/brendan_eich_supported_prop_8_which_was_worse_than_you_remember.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/outward/2014/04/04/brendan_eich_s...
- briantakita 13y ago> I find it very puzzling that you say I am practicing all this hatred by saying I find Eich's actions repugnant > If I have any vitriol at all, it's directed at his defenders and those that want to make him a martyr for "freedom of speech". I'm saying Eich freedom is being violated. I'm just repeating what you said and referring to your "vitriol". I understand where you are coming from. However, it's easy to misconstrue a position that someone took. Notice I used some weasel words such as "it sounds like". I could misconstrue your statement as you hating me. I believe that Eich's support & position is being misconstrued. He should be able to express the reasons for his support without fear of reprisal. I would not be surprised if he & his family were harassed, as harassment seems to accompany such emotionally charged situations. I would be fearful if I were publicly targeted like that. Even if you are right, you never bully people into agreeing with your position. I watched the commercials. The last one is ridiculous, since the couple should have answered that marriage is about love and not necessarily about having children. However, none of the commercials struck me as overtly discriminatory. The one with the two princesses, is somewhat discriminatory; However the position of parents (with religious convictions) should have control over their children's education at least deserved some consideration. To a parent, it coercive to (without warning), teach a child something that they disagree with. The ads expressed some legitimate concerns that should be addressed. There was even a point where someone was afraid that people's jobs would be targeted for their beliefs. Obviously that fear is well founded. I'm failing to see how this is a hate group. I believe some of the Prop 8 supporters were bigots, however, the campaign itself does not seem like it is based on hate. I fail to see how Eich is an aware supporter of hate groups.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]