3 ms·
I think you misunderstand communities. Vibrant communities are full of people who share a materially common set of opinions about various things. They engage an
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
I think you misunderstand communities. Vibrant communities are full of people who share a materially common set of opinions about various things. They engage and interact within that world view.
At the same time people evolve and communities evolve. Sometimes you move away from the community, sometimes they move away from you. Either way, you can end up feeling like an outsider in a group you once considered yourself to be part of the 'in' crowd.
Because a large part of anyone's current point of view is driven by past experience, communities often segment by age but sometimes segment by politics or world events (the mechanism is that people take away different things from the same experience, it "changes" them in different ways, and that puts into further out or closer to other members of the community.
The internet "echo chamber effect" as you call it is defeated by visiting multiple communities and watching and noting the differences. That your favorite 'hang out' on the Internet has become distasteful to you can no more be "fixed" than you can will your favorite eatery or bar to exist for all time.
Things change, people change, places change. Keep moving and an open mind.
- sakagami0 13y agoSpeaking for Reddit, it was an unfortunate consequence of the pseudonymous and point system. As communities got larger, there would be less and less tolerance for discussion and focus would stray towards quick (easily digested) posts. Although, the counter point is that people in general are less likely to produce discussion. Or, that a lack there of of easily digested posts invokes discussion.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoSo does the karma/points thing make it an attractive nusiance for trolls? It does seem to encourage participation which is one of the challenges of any community (way more lurkers than speakers)
- clavalle 13y agoI think that analysis is interesting but incomplete. I think that there are two different kinds of interaction in social media: growth oriented interaction (show and tell) and approval/support oriented interaction (counselor sessions). Show and tell takes more work. You have to teach your community members something to be successful. But it is also more enriching because it encourages meaningful comments that explore and expand on the ideas shown to the group. Support group posts are much easier. Just relate your story, grievance, or thought. Meaningful comments are harder to come by because they tend to be simple messages of support or derision or a comment that could be their own support group post -- people will tend to go ahead and collect points with a second post rather than 'hijacking a thread'. I believe the reason support group posts begin to dominate even in social forums that start off as member enrichment oriented is because they are easier and everyone harbors them. Through sheer numbers one strikes a chord and gets voted up. Then another, then another. They are easy to craft so the raw number of posts begins to guarantee that the forum will become dominated by support group posts. At the same time, it becomes harder and harder to teach the group something new: the circlejerk effect.