2 ms·
I'm not qualified to tell the other side of the story. What a cop out. You're, like everyone else who disagrees with this, downplaying Eich's behavior and tryi
by Karunamon 13y ago
I'm not qualified to tell the other side of the story.
What a cop out. You're, like everyone else who disagrees with this, downplaying Eich's behavior and trying to turn activists into the "real" monsters for speaking out.
Why the double standard? Why does one man, Eich, get a pass on speaking out for his personal political beliefs (with cash), but you demonize the the (hundreds? thousands? more?) people who did nothing but say that it was unacceptable?
You want pathetic? Look at your own post. Realize what you're defending. You should be ashamed of yourself.
- briantakita 13y ago> trying to turn activists into the "real" monsters for speaking out If the activists act like monsters, then that needs to be called out as well. Power corrupts. Do you think the activists are immune?
- Ygg2 13y agoNope. Not one bit. Shitstorm like this just reinforces my people that all people are equally capable of evil and good. This time with emphasis on evil. I don't get what does his private belief have to do with making Firefox? Seriously, what? Also replace this scandal with person X becoming CEO and then media discovering he fucked a cat once. Do you think he'd really rise to top ranks and suddenly turn the firm into a place for cat orgies?
- bluntly_said 13y agoYou understand you're the definition of a schoolyard bully, right? I've read all my posts, several times. I'm internally consistent, and I almost always favor cautious respect over ignorant bashing. I'm not even defending Eich, again, I don't know him. I'm stating that a social environment where a man loses a job Mozilla thought he was qualified for because of private personal beliefs and internet outrage is not only actively undemocratic, it's foolish and childish.
- Karunamon 13y ago>I'm stating that a social environment where a man loses a job Mozilla thought he was qualified for because of private personal beliefs Private "personal beliefs" that he reached into his wallet and tried to force into law. This is the one thing that people don't seem to understand. Eich didn't just think gays were second class citizens. This isn't a "thoughtcrime" he's being pilloried for. It was the action. The donation, coupled with his complete refusal to backtrack, explain, or apologize. Just evade and spin all day long. I have absolutely no problem stamping Eich with "unrepentant bigot" on his forehead because he's proven beyond any shadow of a doubt that those are his beliefs. It is both unreasonable and inconsistent to give him "the benefit of the doubt" after his behavior when the donations came to light. There is no question anymore. >actively undemocratic, it's foolish and childish. I don't think you know what democracy means. Publicly proclaim your allegiance to Stormfront or a group that holds similar regressive views for women, and tell me your life will remain unaffected.
- bluntly_said 13y agoNo, I think you've decided that when democracy doesn't cater exactly to your personal morals, it must be wrong. Making a donation based on private, personal beliefs is ENTIRELY the point of a democracy. The correct action is to speak out in support of your ideas, not to cast hatred on those who disagree. Instead of sitting here arguing, you could have gone and made a 10 dollar donation to a pro-lbgt group, and done a lot more good. Instead of forcing Eich to resign, you could have used it as a rallying point to get A LOT of other like minded people to make that same 10 dollar donation. You could have chosen to voice your opinions with both words and monetary support, (like Eich did) instead of attacking the opposition. You aren't doing that.
- Karunamon 13y ago>No, I think you've decided that when democracy doesn't cater exactly to your personal morals, it must be wrong. Which is what every loser in a democracy thinks. At least every time it's a wedge issue like this. >cast hatred Huh, saying someone has no business running an equality-focused company is "hatred" now? Saying someone is a bigot is "hatred"? Yeah right.
- bluntly_said 13y agoLet me put this another way. If your response to Eich getting promoted was to stop using Firefox, I'd support your actions. If your response was to publicly shame him for an opinion to the point where he loses his job, you're a fucking bully.
- Karunamon 13y agoSo in other words, if you as an activist do anything that has a real impact, you're a "fucking bully", but you "support my actions" if I take meaningless, "feel good" steps. Get real.
- dang 13y agoYou should be ashamed of yourself. I appreciate the intensity of the issue, but personal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News. Edit: thanks to seertaak below for pointing out that this was trivial compared to what Karunamon was responding to. I get that it gives the wrong impression to admonish one person while ignoring something much worse. On the other hand, we (and certainly I) can't read all the comments, so there's inevitably some randomness here. I can't promise to get everything right, but I do promise to listen to correcting feedback.
- seertaak 13y agoYou really should be saying that to bluntly_said -- his/her comments are far more unhinged than Kuranamon. e.g. "fucking PATHETIC" "yo FUCKHEAD" "FUCK YOU" "...you're a bully. A fucking FUCKHEAD bully" Two wrongs don't make a right, but "you should be ashamed of yourself" is pretty tame compared to the above.
- dang 13y agoUgh. I couldn't agree more. That comment is far worse, and I've banned bluntly_said. Thank you for the heads-up. We can't read all the comments, and I didn't see that one. Community help is indispensable here. All: When you see a comment that is truly toxic for HN, please flag it by clicking "link" to go to the item page and then "flag" at the top.