3 ms·
> But the biggest problem facing the 16 patients who had signed up for the surgery was that the lead doctor, William H. Dobelle, was ill. He died while the 16th
by twic 13y ago
> But the biggest problem facing the 16 patients who had signed up for the surgery was that the lead doctor, William H. Dobelle, was ill. He died while the 16th patient was still recovering from surgery in hospital.
> The project ended with his death.
> “When he died, there was no medical journal on the 16 patients, with myself being the first one implanted. Nothing was ever written and documented.
What the fuck? An experimental surgical procedure is being conducted, and nothing is recorded outside on elderly doctor's brain?
- Retric 13y agoI suspect he may have had encrypted his notes/HDD and with his death the information was lost.
- pyronite 13y agoWhat reason do you have to suspect this extraordinary measure?
- Retric 13y agoI have seen it happen and know of several cases where large amounts of valuable data was 'lost' until someones password was cracked. PS: Escrow services and wills are something that many people don't use. It's the old if I am gone I don't really care mentality.
- hueving 13y agoIt's like a two-step procedure on OSX. Hardly extraordinary and most likely an obvious first step on machines that will contain patient records.
- jakobe 13y agoIt's also odd that the patients had to pay for the experimental surgery. This doesn't sound like a serious clinical trial, it sounds like a hack performed by some back-alley doc in a dystopic science fiction story...
- nnq 13y agoIt just shows that the old doc was a brave maverick that had the courage to go through with it even without the funding he needed! That's why everything probably fell through after his death. He probably funded most of it with his time and money, took all the shortcuts he could because he had to (hence the poor reliability - it failed after eight weeks), and asked the patients to pay for the rest. It's not a dystopic science fiction story, it's how slow and cumbersome and real world engineering based medical research works, and how the only way to make any meaningful progress fast enough (if you're not in one of the few well funded and well staffed places in the world, working on one of the few projects that are considered "important"), is to work around the system, cheat and look for sloppy shortcuts, ask the poor patients for money directly, and how everything crumbles when the one genius/madman that pulled all those tricks to make it work goes out of the picture.
- Trufa 13y ago> it sounds like a hack performed by some back-alley doc in a dystopic science fiction story... I mean, they did manage to give him back his sight for a limited period of time, that's pretty amazing technology if you ask me, not the kind a hack would achieve, but yes, it's very unfortunate that he lost it again, that must be some terrible pain. I agree it might not sound too professional, but it seems to me that it's more about how this article is putting it and the reality may be more complex.
- userbinator 13y agoThe style of experimentation that he did definitely fits the definition of "hack" in the sense of the hacker spirit, i.e. he didn't really care for anything other than getting it working. "F*ck the regulations, if these people want to see again then that's what I'm going to make happen."
- namlem 13y agoI mean the doctor was legit. He was licensed and the procedure worked. He was just negligent when it came to record keeping.
- nnq 13y agoConsidering how primitive the tech looks, someone could surely reverse-engineer it... but good luck trying to get funding for it and trying to find surgeons willing to take the risk of it blowing up in their face, because they will inevitably take the blame for any "bug" the tech could have :) The old doc was probably brave enough to do it while circumventing the whole regulatory process and using his personal reputation and charisma and professional relationships to pull it through and get the funding he needed, so again, good luck finding anyone to replace him.
- privong 13y ago> What the fuck? An experimental surgical procedure is being conducted, and nothing is recorded outside on elderly doctor's brain? The data may exist. But it's non-trivial to recreate an experiment or interpret results with only lab notebooks, especially for experiments which were not completed. Despite the best of intentions, even with well-kept notes, not everything is recorded – the doctor's not-completely-formed thoughts (e.g., on topics such as where the experiment should go next, possible issues that might arise) would be the key to moving forward and might not hvae been recorded because they weren't at an advanced enough stage to commit to writing (in the sense that not everyone immediately writes down every idea they have about something, even if that idea later becomes crucial).
- frozenport 13y agoOne doctor can't do this work alone!? What about the guys that made the hardware. This story is missing some key details.