4 ms·
Calling this particular device "bullshit" misses the big picture. Considering how little we actually know (and I don't mean, "some studies on 200 people have sh
by pron 13y ago
Calling this particular device "bullshit" misses the big picture. Considering how little we actually know (and I don't mean, "some studies on 200 people have shown"; I mean actually know) about how a healthy (as in non-sick) human body works[1], most of the products and techniques regarding health are pretty much bullshit, from miracle diets, super-exercises, wonder shakes and magic devices. This is not to say they don't perform their specific functions such as tweaking blood sugar or cholesterol levels, but that the relationships between those metrics and general health are more conjecture than knowledge.
What is happening here is something else altogether. It is a psychological phenomenon that some might say resembles religion, but in any case touches on a very primeval function of our psyche. Jonathan Haidt says it's the manifestation of the "purity" value among liberals[2]. Whatever this health craze is, it is far from scientific. Even people who are otherwise very careful in interpreting scientific research, change their lifestyle based on two studies on 300 people in total, that found a decrease of 40% in the incidence of a type of cancer that affects 1 person in 2000.
In fact, heated debates over findings of such dubious nature, and a far more dubious relevance to actual day-to-day living, is a common form "religious study" among the faithful, not unlike debates in Jewish Yeshivas.
Entrepreneurs – some of them believers themselves – rush to fill the demands of this As a pseudo-scientific religion's worshippers. There is nothing wrong with that. But it should be clear that they fill a very real, and very serious, psychological need, but one that has nothing to do with actual health. As such, calling a particular magic device "bullshit" is not unlike criticizing the efficacy of a particular batch of Virgin Mary icons.
[1]: To clarify: we know how it works, but not how each of a gazilion parameters – from weather to sleeping habits to genetics to diet to exercise – affects it.
[2]: http://www.ted.com/talks/jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind http://www.ted.com/talks/jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind
- __david__ 13y agoNo. This device purports to be able to measure glucose levels non-invasively. That is 100% verifiable, and most likely BS (to an accuracy that a diabetic would need). Considering that diabetes is a real illness and that glucose monitoring is very important to keeping diabetics alive, this kind of thing doesn't get a pass by being "religious," like a magnetic anti-sea-sickness bracelet might.
- Morendil 13y ago> This device purports to be able to measure glucose levels non-invasively. It doesn't. The campaign page specifically disclaims that.
- lotu 13y agoThe more concerning thing is the apparent lack of engineers that would be able to design, build, and mass produce such a device. The video consists of the video of the CEO at a desk the looks like it is prop, and stock videos. There is no evidence that this company owns office space or employs anyone, much less is capable of making such a device.