10 ms·
Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial revolution?
- rasur 13y agoBecause it's a book, and thus at the whim of the author?
- jaegerpicker 13y agoI'm a HUGE GoT fan (have read the books multiple times) but it's a work of fiction, fantasy fiction as that. The rules don't apply. There hasn't been an industrial revolution because George RR Martin has decided there shouldn't be one in his world.
- maxerickson 13y agoThere still has to be some internal consistency, if too many things happen on just a whim of the author the story falls apart.
- bryanlarsen 13y agoc.f. J.K. Rowling. She wrote a series of books with very little internal consistency, yet made billions doing so.
- rjtavares 13y agoMissing from the analysis is the exploration of Westeros' magical winters. They're described as smal Ice Ages lasting for a few years, and occouring every 5-7 years (if memory serves me). People hoard food during the good years so that they don't starve during the long winters, which are (particularly in the north) complety barren. I imagine that would have an impact on society, particularly on specialization and the pursuit of knowledge a related activities.
- jffry 13y agoThe seasons are frequently described as unpredictable, but over the course of the novels it's suggested that in recent living history they have become elongated. Imagine the effects that a 9-year winter would have on a population. It's possible that these seasons are a part of a cycle where civilization builds up, and then is decimated, which would be a huge hindrance to technological progress.
- Amezarak 13y ago(If you haven't read all the books, don't read this comment.) There's also magic in general. Until relatively recently, societies could accomplish a great deal through magical means, from road-building to instantaneous long-distance communication. For much of the six thousand years, there was probably no reason to focus on scientific and technological advances when you could just use magic. Things apparently changed with the near-extinction of the dragons. Dragons apparently somehow boost magic - it almost disappeared without them, and now it's coming back with them. In the books, Marwyn the Mage (a maester) claims that the maesters were responsible for the death of the dragons, because they couldn't build the world they wanted with magic, prophecy, and dragons around - suggesting that the maesters want a world of science and technology, perhaps with them as the gatekeepers. Lady Dustin also suggests that the maesters are much more political than they pretend.
- antonioevans 13y agoYep, as an entrepreneur it would be pretty difficult for me to have my factory shutdown for 5-7 years because the roads had 5 years worth of snow on them.
- bluedevil2k 13y agoThe article doesn't discuss the effectiveness of the plagues in adjusting the supply/demand curves of labor, thus disrupting the feudal system, thus unlocking the power of knowledge and innovation from the masses. Perhaps in Westeros, the upcoming Winter will have the same effect.
- klackerz 13y agoThat's one of my main pet peeves about fantasy novels. The only author I know who has introduced long term changes in a fantasy world is Brandon Sanderson in his fantasy series Mistborn.
- OscarCunningham 13y agoTerry Pratchett is another.
- Macha 13y agoIn effect, the long term direction of the Discworld books, especially since the start of the watch sub-series is basically "What if the industrial revolution happened in a (mostly) traditional fantasy world?".
- walshemj 13y agoActually that was the reality fracturing and being put back together (sort of) by the history monks - its why you have Elizabethan theater next to an 18 century opera
- koshatnik 13y agoAlso, although this is more the case overseas rather than in Westeros itself, slaves. Ancient Greece and Rome certainly had the knowledge and ingenuity to have industrial revolutions, but with the availability of mass forced labour, there would have been a much smaller cost saving in mechanising tasks. Serfdom kind of does the same thing to a lesser extent.
- marknutter 13y agoBecause GRRM is too busy introducing new characters.
- stephencanon 13y agoI think you meant "killing".
- Macha 13y agoReplacements need to come from somewhere or he'll run out of characters to kill off.
- glenra 13y agoThe article claims loaned money is wasted in "useless pageants and tournaments" but pageants might be the opposite of useless in this context. Having regular events where people travel from near and far to show off their finery encourages the development of technology - and the sharing of information - far in advance of what's necessary in normal day-to-day life. Suppose you're making clothing (or armor, or swords...) and there's one big annual pageant in your region. That pageant constitutes a financial incentive to show off your best work. You now have a reason to save money and build up technological prowess the rest of the year so you can try extra hard to make something extra impressive that one week so the people who wear your stuff at that event will outshine everyone else. Having special show-offish events (generally with an associated crafts fair) leads to an arms race. If one lord has an especially finely-woven blue silk shirt in this years tournament, the next year everybody else HAS to have shirts made that well; the guy who came up with the technique for making it makes out like a bandit and other people copy his techniques. The need to impress others in a limited context produces tech that isn't normally necessary and that tech first spreads to the rest of the elite then trickles down to the masses. Anyway, that's the "crafts fair" theory of how industrial development came about.
- _random_ 13y agoNo colonies to rob?
- wfn 13y agoSomewhat related: "The Last Ringbearer": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Ringbearer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Ringbearer - "an alternative account of and an informal sequel to the events of J.R.R. Tolkien's trilogy, The Lord of the Rings." The novel is based on the premise that the Tolkien account is a "history written by the victors". In Eskov's version of the story, Mordor is described as a peaceful country on the verge of an industrial revolution, that is a threat to the war-mongering and imperialistic faction represented by Gandalf (whose attitude has been described by Saruman as "crafting the Final Solution to the Mordorian problem") and the elves. Author's article on salon.com: http://www.salon.com/2011/02/23/last_ringbearer_explanation/ http://www.salon.com/2011/02/23/last_ringbearer_explanation/ The whole book in English here: http://ymarkov.livejournal.com/280578.html http://ymarkov.livejournal.com/280578.html
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoSurprisingly familiar. But isn't it another idealogical exaggeration in a different direction? Cute though. Maybe a balanced version, where feuding between an agrarian society and an imperial nation rises to war, with atrocities mounting by the imperium's secret police as the naieve masses of farmers slowly accept the need for fighting back? Oh, that was Tolkien's version.
- wfn 13y ago> But isn't it another idealogical exaggeration in a different direction? Yeah, probably! It's just.. an interesting angle, really! I'll quote from the second foreword to LotR[1] (written in 1966) (excerpt somewhere from the middle), because I like it and it's somewhat relevant to all this (tl;dr: just read the second paragraph) As for any inner meaning or 'message', it has in the intention of the author none. It is neither allegorical nor topical. As the story grew it put down roots (into the past) and threw out unexpected branches: but its main theme was settled from the outset by the inevitable choice of the Ring as the link between it and The Hobbit. The crucial chapter, "The Shadow of the Past', is one of the oldest parts of the tale. It was written long before the foreshadow of 1939 had yet become a threat of inevitable disaster, and from that point the story would have developed along essentially the same lines, if that disaster had been averted. Its sources are things long before in mind, or in some cases already written, and little or nothing in the war that began in 1939 or its sequels modified it. The real war does not resemble the legendary war in its process or its conclusion. If it had inspired or directed the development of the legend, then certainly the Ring would have been seized and used against Sauron; he would not have been annihilated but enslaved, and Barad-dûr would not have been destroyed but occupied. Saruman, failing to get possession of the Ring, would in the confusion and treacheries of the time have found in Mordor the missing links in his own researches into Ring-lore, and before long he would have made a Great Ring of his own with which to challenge the self-styled Ruler of Middle-earth. In that conflict both sides would have held hobbits in hatred and contempt: they would not long have survived even as slaves. Other arrangements could be devised according to the tastes or views of those who like allegory or topical reference. But I cordially dislike allegory in all its manifestations, and always have done so since I grew old and wary enough to detect its presence. I much prefer history, true or feigned, with its varied applicability to the thought and experience of readers. I think that many confuse 'applicability' with 'allegory'; but the one resides in the freedom of the reader, and the other in the purposed domination of the author. (I've been listening to the LotR audiobook during my walks in the woods etc. recently. Recommend+++.) edit p.s.: it wasn't me who downvoted you. fwiw, while your tone was somewhat condescending, i thought your comment did add to the discussion. [1]: e.g. http://www.thetolkienforum.com/showthread.php?16713-LOTR-The-second-edition-Foreword-by-Tolkien http://www.thetolkienforum.com/showthread.php?16713-LOTR-The...
- pron 13y agoBreaking up the feudal system with its attendant absurdities would help Feudalism is anything but absurd. In fact, it makes much more sense than capitalism: trust is built slowly, and enhanced by gifts of land and marriage bonds. It was a major cultural change that allowed people in the early modern economy to put blind faith in faceless institutions and unseen strangers. People living in developed countries often don't see how much trust is required to maintain it, and this trust takes ages to build. Children grow up seeing that the "system works" so as adults, they don't rock the boat (well, most of them don't). To them, rampant bribery and nepotism in developing countries seems strange and illogical, but it is the exact opposite. Those "backwards" systems are built around the idea of cultivating personal relationships because you can't trust strangers. The lessons from this is that the converse is also true. A society built around capitalism (and I'm talking capitalism in general; not necessarily predatory free-market capitalism) requires, first and foremost, a lot of trust in the system. If that trust is lost, we go back to feudalism. There is no such thing as trust-free capitalism (specifically, because without trust there is no credit – which, literally means "faith" – and without credit there is no capitalism).
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoJust a coincidence the history of feudal systems is the history of sadists tormenting the people they lord it over? Its all fine and good as long as you are one of the people with marriages and land bonds to barter. But the vast majority of people called it serfdom and died young.
- icegreentea 13y agoYou're claim has minimal basis in history. The number of sadists tormenting their serfs is surely non-zero, but also not systemic. For one thing, lords DEPEND on their serfs for their well being. Their serfs economic output is crucial.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoYeah like historical omnipotent despots cared about their cattle or were smart modern people who understood economics. Every storey about feudalism is about the sadism. Why? Because its exciting I'm sure, but also because it was an absolutely common theme?
- higherpurpose 13y ago> In Europe, industrialisation depended on the dissemination of ideas. The more know-how was spread widely, the more people could hear of an innovation and could copy or improve it, building an accelerating cycle of technological development. This hits the spot for the patent system, which is actually detrimental as it is for technological development. Imagine if back then the "big guys" could sue/take the property of anyone daring to copy or improve on existing technologies? I also doubt that back then many would be interested in licensing the technology, but more in keeping it for themselves to "rule the world".
- claudius 13y agoThe patent system was introduced to solve the latter problem: By openly specifying a solution to a problem, more people could benefit from that solution. Combine that with a period of time where only the original inventor is allowed to benefit and you catch two birds with one stone: - invention is incentivised as people can expect to be protected for a period of time to get their investment back - to do so, they have to share their inventions with the world which then can use it at a later point. The problem today is that the period of protection is much longer than necessary and sensible given the speed of innovation. Just a few decades ago, waiting ten or twenty years for a patent to run out was much preferable to spending ten, twenty or fifty years trying to solve the original problem yourself. The patent system is not the problem, its parameters are.
- GlennS 13y agoI think it's a mistake to think that Westeros has been the same for 6000 years. Rather, the people of Westeros are making the same kind of historical errors that Medieval people commonly did. Evidence: the phrase 'stories about knights before there were knights' (I think this is from Bran).
- riffraff 13y agodid the Reform break the church near-monopoly on education? I was under the impression the printing press had been the big thing there (and also the main enabler of the Reform, which could have been a random isolated heresy otherwise)
- henrikschroder 13y agoBecause: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/MedievalStasis http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/MedievalStasis
- fiatmoney 13y agoIntermittent bitter winters result in negative real interest rates - you'd gladly give up a loaf of bread plus something else now (in summer) for a guaranteed loaf of bread later (in winter). With periodic long-term negative real interest rates, hoarding or investing in hoard-protecting projects (fortresses, larders, giant walls) makes more sense than investing in capital that will become idle in a long-term bitter winter - especially when that source of capital makes you a target.
- bladedtoys 13y agoWhy hasn't Westeros had an industrial revolution? Because no one has ever had one[1]. There was no industrial revolution in China or India or the Muslim world who arguably were more advanced than medieval Europe. There was no industrial revolution in Rome or the Hellenistic era who had vastly more potential in the creation and exchange of ideas than the medieval period. There were no industrial revolutions among the new world civilizations who had larger populations than any medieval nation. There were no industrial revolutions in sub Sarahan African even though there was iron working and abundant resources. Quite possibly the industrial revolution was actually an improbable set of circumstance and people for which ad hoc but inadequate explanations abound. (and so there hasn't been an industrial revolution on that tv show because it is unrealistically unlikely.) [1]With one exception, the one we happen to live in.
- angersock 13y agoFor anyone interested in industrial revolutions in fantasy or medieval settings, I'd recommend checking out de Camp's "Lest Darkness Fall" and Twain's "A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court". Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura is a pretty great CRPG in that setting as well, with fantastic writing and worldbuilding--even if the vanilla version of the game is somewhat buggy and imbalanced.
- moomin 13y agoAnother unique fictional aspect of the Game of Thrones world is that they have a well-documented and well-understood technology (magic) that just plain stopped working. Even things that you'd regard as chemistry e.g. wildfire stopped working when the dragons died. So you're looking at an environment in which normal scientific investigation might be unreliable. For that matter, if you've got dragons, who needs cannons?