4 ms·
You are missing the point of the automation discussion. The problem is that the jobs that are left for those without a tech degree of some sort aren't apprecia
by ThomPete 13y ago
You are missing the point of the automation discussion.
The problem is that the jobs that are left for those without a tech degree of some sort aren't appreciated by the market and is forcing salaries down way below what is possible to live off. Wallmart is a much more accurate way to look at what automation does.
- MWil 13y agoFrom a certain viewpoint that's not even the problem. The problem is when a person doesn't gain value in other areas or have the opportunity to gain value in other areas, either on their own initiative or through the labor directly. Treat every job like that job's on the endangered jobs list and try not to put all your eggs in one basket. Now, I'd personally have a problem if you didn't add the opportunity portion I mentioned above b/c then it just turns into another "bootstrap" fallacy.
- yummyfajitas 13y ago...forcing salaries down way below what is possible to live off. This is an exaggeration. It may be forcing salaries below the level necessary to support US middle class consumption levels, but there is a huge gap between that and "possible to live off". Where I live, even the middle class don't live in homes with 2 rooms/person or own a car (unlike poor people in the US). A full time minimum wage job pays $14,500/year. GDP/capita (adjusted for purchasing power) in Bulgaria is $14,100. In Brazil it's $11,700, here in India it's $3800, and in Haiti it's $1200. Yet people continue to live. (These numbers are adjusted for purchasing power, so don't argue that it's cheaper to live over here.) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_...
- ThomPete 13y agoCould you live on 14.500 a year? That 1400USD a month. If you have kids good luck with that. 50 years ago GM was the biggest job creator in the country. Average hourly wage was quite good to live off. Today Wallmart is the biggest and many workers need extra help from the goverment to even make it. The problem is very real.
- pietro 13y agoYou can easily live off 1400 USD per month. In India, they manage to get by for about 3000 USD (PPP) per year. Americans could, too. They’d hate it, but they could.
- ThomPete 13y agoI don't even know if I should take this comment serious. If you are a student, in your youth having no obligations sure you probably could. But these are people often with a family.
- tptacek 13y agoI do not like where 'yummyfajitas logic takes us and would thus like to find ways to disagree with him, but much of what he says checks out. "These are people with families", and also public K-12 schools within walking distance that spend more per-pupil than do many private schools, air conditioning, a car, health care (both directly subsidized by the government and indirectly subsidized by emergency rooms), cable television, and, depending on the city, houses with individual rooms for each family member. And, yes, 24/7 electricity, running water, and flush toilets. It's a little hard to argue that it's somehow easier to be a rural Indian subsistence farmer than it is to be a section 8 tenant. From the vantage point of the Indian farmer, the section 8 tenant is mind-bogglingly wealthy. And the rural poor in India outnumber all people in the US below the poverty line by six to one. Chris Stucchio is right. We need to devise a reasonable argument that one of the most important social issues of our time is making a ~40 million relatively wealthy people even wealthier. Personally, I'd prefer to keep a focus on education and equality of opportunity, and not spend so much time thinking about what 14k/yr buys you in New York City. But you'll no doubt want to tell me that it's easy for me to say that, and I agree.
- ThomPete 13y agoyou are also missing the point. If you considder a salary where the government have to subsidize to make it possible then by definition you cant live of your salary. It doesent matter what you can live off in other countries, as a society you have a problem. A problem caused primarily by technology.
- wyager 13y ago>The problem is that the jobs that are left for those without a tech degree of some sort aren't appreciated by the market So then people in the future get a tech degree, and humanity will be better off, because instead of a million people with a tech degree and 999 million farming, we now have 0 people wasting their precious mind on farming and a billion solving hard problems. Like I said, people will be forced to retool. That is a good thing.
- ThomPete 13y agoYou are talking about retooling as if it's something you can do in a few months. Thats where you and the whole "Market will sort out things" school is wrong. You used to be able to retool fairly easily. That is just not the case anymore. The jobs where that is possible is increasingly paying less and less. THAT is the problem. The real problem. The increasing problem.
- wyager 13y ago>You used to be able to retool fairly easily. That is just not the case anymore. You know, I've never actually seen any evidence of this. People say it a lot, but it's not reflected in the numbers. However, if it is true, it's simply the case that there will be a slight permanent increase in the number of people who are unemployed.
- ThomPete 13y agoyou probably would benefit by knowing som people not in the tech industry. For them this problem is very real, but i see the appologist are blinded by the beauty of the market. Would be easier to convince someone that god doesent exist than make them realize how out of sync with reality ghey are.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]