9 ms·
Automation doesn't "kill jobs" at all. I'm tired of news articles that try to pass of "jobs" as some sort of discrete, easily quantifiable units. "Over a milli
by wyager 13y ago
Automation doesn't "kill jobs" at all.
I'm tired of news articles that try to pass of "jobs" as some sort of discrete, easily quantifiable units. "Over a million jobs are being shipped to china", "12,000 jobs created", etc.
That's not how labor works. Or at least, it's a useless and misleading way of thinking about labor.
Sometimes automation makes a certain type of labor irrelevant. Those laborers need to find a new job (which possibly involves retooling) or starve (or, today, live off some sort of welfare or charitable income).
We are not even close to simply having no labor left that needs doing by humans. That's the only way you can really "kill" jobs; replace all human labor altogether. Otherwise, humans will just move to whatever they're still good at. Because of automation, the world will always be able to support those new jobs. The market will force this to be the case.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Automation doesn't "kill jobs" at all. Perhaps, but it certainly reduces the relative value of labor vs. capital. "Kills jobs" is, as popular simplifications go, not at all bad. It's certainly more accurate than: > Because of automation, the world will always be able to support those new jobs. The market will force this to be the case.
- andkon 13y agoExactly. Thinking that "the world" will miraculously support anyone is to be willfully ignorant of how power and money actually get distributed. And while "the market" (lol) will create new jobs every time some previous labour marketplace is disrupted, there is absolutely no guarantee that it will provide the same amount of jobs (or, really: demand for the same units of labour). From there, it sorta follows that everyone's wages will drop: same number of people looking for work, but much less need for workers? The workers lose income as a result, meaning that there's both less demand for workers, and the work that is now available isn't going to pay your bills.
- ThomPete 13y agoIt has NEVER created the same amount of jobs. It has always looked like that because new markets where liberalized, but technology creates less jobs than it destroys. The upside of this is that it make many things very cheap. But it's not good news for most of us unless something change.
- wyager 13y ago>technology creates less jobs than it destroys. What a blisteringly stupid sentiment. If this were true, there would have been an obvious monotonic decrease in employment since humans started inventing things.
- ThomPete 13y agoTechnology today is not the same as technology 50 or 70 years ago. You are assuming that just because something used to be the case it will always be so. But that is missing the point. The situation we have today is increasingly that you either need a STEM degree or primarily have jobs that are loosing their ability to provide a middle-class income. Those jobs in Wallmart jobs will be automated sooner or later and there is no alternative. So call it stupid all you want. The reality is that the US is loosing jobs and not because it doesn't have a great environment for creating jobs, simply because technology allow for automation, outsourcing and the decline of the middle income job.
- wyager 13y ago>Technology today is not the same as technology 50 or 70 years ago. You're kidding, right? The industrial revolution "unemployed" orders of magnitudes more people than current technological changes. >The situation we have today is increasingly that you either need a STEM degree God forbid that the only jobs open to humans require mental exertion, right? I sure do love the fact that a huge fraction of the minds on earth are spending eight hours a day doing the really important things, like putting more Duck Dynasty t-shirts in aisle 12.
- wyager 13y ago>Perhaps, but [automation] certainly reduces the relative value of labor vs. capital. Automation does four things: 1. Drastically decrease the value of labor in the now-automated field. 2. Slightly decrease the value of all labor (by increasing the supply of free labor). 3. Slightly decrease the costs of all products (via #2). 4. Drastically decrease the costs of products which are now produces automatically (via #1). These things all work out to be positive-sum for humanity. If this wasn't the case, it wouldn't make any economic sense for businesses to automate in the first place.
- ThomPete 13y agoOf course it would make sense for that specific business to automate. Thats WHY they do it. TO save money to increas productivity to make money in the competition they are in. You are arguing for some sort of utopian perfect system scenario that simply isn't the case.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> These things all work out to be positive-sum for humanity. If this wasn't the case, it wouldn't make any economic sense for businesses to automate in the first place. No, it makes sense for businesses to automate if the effect is positive-sum for the specific businesses owners whose businesses are automating, regardless of the effect on humanity as a whole.
- ThomPete 13y agoYou are missing the point of the automation discussion. The problem is that the jobs that are left for those without a tech degree of some sort aren't appreciated by the market and is forcing salaries down way below what is possible to live off. Wallmart is a much more accurate way to look at what automation does.
- MWil 13y agoFrom a certain viewpoint that's not even the problem. The problem is when a person doesn't gain value in other areas or have the opportunity to gain value in other areas, either on their own initiative or through the labor directly. Treat every job like that job's on the endangered jobs list and try not to put all your eggs in one basket. Now, I'd personally have a problem if you didn't add the opportunity portion I mentioned above b/c then it just turns into another "bootstrap" fallacy.
- yummyfajitas 13y ago...forcing salaries down way below what is possible to live off. This is an exaggeration. It may be forcing salaries below the level necessary to support US middle class consumption levels, but there is a huge gap between that and "possible to live off". Where I live, even the middle class don't live in homes with 2 rooms/person or own a car (unlike poor people in the US). A full time minimum wage job pays $14,500/year. GDP/capita (adjusted for purchasing power) in Bulgaria is $14,100. In Brazil it's $11,700, here in India it's $3800, and in Haiti it's $1200. Yet people continue to live. (These numbers are adjusted for purchasing power, so don't argue that it's cheaper to live over here.) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_...
- ThomPete 13y agoCould you live on 14.500 a year? That 1400USD a month. If you have kids good luck with that. 50 years ago GM was the biggest job creator in the country. Average hourly wage was quite good to live off. Today Wallmart is the biggest and many workers need extra help from the goverment to even make it. The problem is very real.
- skybrian 13y agoOf course we aren't close to having no work worth doing - for volunteers. The hard part is coming up with something that people will pay for. This seems to be tricky enough that most startups fail at it. The market isn't a magic wand. If buyers and sellers can't agree on terms then the sale won't happen, and the labor market is particularly illiquid. It's not at all clear that businesses want to hire large numbers of unemployed people under any reasonable terms.
- malandrew 13y agoTell that to all the horses that ended up unemployed during the first industrial revolution that never ended up finding employment in other activities. Horses lost out because they weren't retrainable to perform other productive activities. Up until now most new jobs have been within the grasp of those people willing to go through a little training. However, now we're eliminating jobs fast enough and the new jobs we're willing to fill require a level of knowledge that are either impossible for certain workers or at least "economically impossible" since the cost and time necessary to train is too high to make sense.