5 ms·
Great comment. I'll add an observation: we should be encouraging people to drive fewer miles To do this we basically need denser neighborhoods, as Edward Glae
by jseliger 13y ago
Great comment. I'll add an observation:
we should be encouraging people to drive fewer miles
To do this we basically need denser neighborhoods, as Edward Glaeser points out in The Triumph of the City (http://www.amazon.com/Triumph-City-Greatest-Invention-Healthier/dp/159420277X?ie=UTF8&tag=thstsst-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957)—but http://www.amazon.com/Triumph-City-Greatest-Invention-Health... he points out, as does Matt Yglesias in The Rent is Too Damn High, that the big problems are with local zoning requirements, which by and large forbid density increases.
There are lots of local battles going on regarding density, and I agree that these are good things: "living closer to where you work, using mass transit, biking, and walking more," but they can all be encourage or discouraged by zoning. In most of America they're discouraged.
In the meantime better mileage is at least an improvement.
- jimmaswell 13y agoA lot of people simply don't want to live in a crowded city in an apartment crowded on every side with other apartments. I'd prefer a location in a low-density suburban area (with a lot of forest around me) where I could get to the city in a few minutes.
- ghouse 13y agoWhich is fine. But I'd prefer not to subsidize your lifestyle choice I do now through my taxes that subsidize your fuel, roads, and emergency services.
- MrRecycle 13y agoAnd I don't want to subsidize your police force, welfare programs, or subway with my taxes, but I'm not out there complaining about urban hipsters. More power to them. If you don't like suburbs, don;t live there, and leave them alone.
- robotresearcher 13y agoThe net subsidy is usually from city to suburbs and countryside. Besides, many suburbanites work or take entertainment in the city, where they get utility from the city services.
- tsotha 13y ago>The net subsidy is usually from city to suburbs and countryside. Because of progressive taxation and the fact you have to pay people a lot more to live in dense cities. Any time you want to propose a flat tax you'll have my support.
- twic 13y agoNo, because cities are much, much more efficient.
- tsotha 13y agoI know people keep repeating that, but I doubt it's actually true. See my other comment.
- robotresearcher 13y agoI'm a fan of flat taxes. But you miss the point: a large fraction of those suburban dwellers work and get paid in the city. Cities like London have literally millions of daily commuters. Money flows out of cities because they contain a lot of taxpayers that consume resources efficiently. Collecting the garbage from a 200-unit condo building is way cheaper than visiting 200 houses in a suburban subdivision. Yet the dollar value of the house and condo are similar and they pay similar taxes. If the city condo dweller works at the next desk to commuting suburbanite, they get paid the same and pay the same taxes. The suburbanite costs more to service and consumes more energy, etc. Also, cities have a higher ratio of taxpayers to non-taxpayers. There are fewer kids and retirees living there, for example. I'm not against suburbs at all. Often a great place to live, particularly with kids. But it's helpful to understand their costs.
- tadfisher 13y agoThat is your prerogative, but you do not pay 100% of the extra cost for the lifestyle you prefer.
- jimmaswell 13y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7539781 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7539781
- nowarninglabel 13y agoThat's a false dichotomy. There are ways to create suburban areas with forests and local gardens that are much higher density than our current suburban outlay while still being enjoyable to live in. However, it requires giving up the McMansion style of building. The only way for this to happen though, in my opinion, is to incentivize developers into planning these types of neighborhoods vs. McMansion lands (and I say this from an experienced standpoint with a family of real-estate developers).
- jimmaswell 13y agoYou misunderstood. I meant literally around me. House surrounded by at least a mile or a few miles of woods. If the houses were lined up in front of the forest you could increase the density, though. But the way I posed it originally, not so much. What's your threshold for where a house becomes a "McMansion?" What would you think of ~1200sqft, two stories with a basement, with a good yard?
- baq 13y agoi think it's the quantity. it's not one house, it's that there's a neighborhood with a thousand of very similar houses.
- lttlrck 13y agoHow is that alone a density issue?
- Retric 13y agoThe lower the neighborhood density the less incentive there is for local retail. Without local retail everyone is forced to drive and in some cases drive fairly long distances when the area is full of low density houses. Still, the internet can significantly reduce peoples need to drive because package delivery can be much more efficient than driving to a shopping mall.
- malandrew 13y ago
- jvm 13y ago> A lot of people simply don't want to live in a crowded city in an apartment crowded on every side with other apartments. I'd prefer a location in a low-density suburban area (with a lot of forest around me) where I could get to the city in a few minutes. This is always an interesting aspect of the zoning debate to me. People who prefer to live in suburbs often seem to oppose zoning that allows densification. But if more development were allowed in cities, there would be less pressure to densify the suburbs. Seems like it would be a win-win for both lifestyle preferences.
- CalRobert 13y agoTrue, but the profoundly high cost of living in a dense, walkable area might indicate that more people want to do this than that market allows.
- matt__rose 13y agoUnfortunately, if you follow that train of thought to it's logical conclusion, such a place is a contradiction. If everyone wanted to live in a low-density suburban area, these low-density suburban areas have to be built farther and farther away from the city, well more than "a few minutes" drive. To see the fallacy of this you only have to look at places like Toronto, or Atlanta.