7 ms·
Citations, or you are just promoting your opinion. I'm also curious about the numbers showing that 55mph is the most efficient. I do not particularly dispute
by taeric 13y ago
Citations, or you are just promoting your opinion.
I'm also curious about the numbers showing that 55mph is the most efficient. I do not particularly dispute that this is the case for the majority of vehicles. I am curious as to whether or not this is as it has to be, or because that is the way vehicles are built in the US. That is, could you do better with different high speed gearing?
- squeakynick 13y agoThere's a wealth of information here http://www.fueleconomy.gov/ http://www.fueleconomy.gov/
- exue 13y agoIt's not always the most efficient for every car, but there are lots of charts showing this tradeoff. Some cars are more efficient at 65 or 70 than 55 (97 Celica), but in modern gas cars, 40-50mph is where you hit a peak, and you start getting worse from there. 40mph on the highway is painfully slow though, so people generally pick an optimal point higher than that. (One inconsistency I've found is how the Motor Trend test below sees a very high peak at about 40MPH and a decline after, while other sources show a flatter peak). And 55MPH seems more like a magic number the author picked, but not a bad one if we don't know the model. Generally cars are geared so the engine begins entering its optimal / most efficient RPM range where it can produce more torque in top gear around 40-50mph, and rolling resistance and wind drag (which is a cube function of speed) contribute to make mileage worse after that. Usually the speed at which you first shift into top gear and cruise comfortably is close to optimal. Efficiency doesn't start dropping for a while because of the cubic nature of drag, and the engine sometimes is more efficient at higher RPMs for a bit (see nols' post on manufacturer optimization). Fun fact: At top speed (254mph), a Bugatti Veyron will use its 26 gallon tank in 12 minutes. An older chart: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a9/Fuel_economy_vs_speed_1997.png http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a9/Fuel_econ... A newer chart: http://blog.automatic.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/mpg-vs-speed-all.png http://blog.automatic.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/mpg-vs-... Motor Trend chart: http://image.motortrend.com/f/roadtests/sedans/1208_40_mpg_compact_sedan_comparison/38489659/40-MPG-comparison-constant-speed-chart.jpg http://image.motortrend.com/f/roadtests/sedans/1208_40_mpg_c... http://www.motortrend.com/roadtests/sedans/1208_40_mpg_compact_sedan_comparison/ http://www.motortrend.com/roadtests/sedans/1208_40_mpg_compa... (One thing that bothered me is how the Civics in the last two charts were so different)
- taeric 13y agoAs I stated in a sibling, this still boils down to "this is how current cars are built." I would imagine if you looked at the average vehicle built in, say, the 1940s, you would see a vastly different "optimal" number. Which is all to say, do we expect this to stagnate forever at 55? Is this a hard physical limit? I understand drag gets higher there. Are there no tricks left to us? And again, I fully concede that this is likely not the most pressing fact around. Just one I am curious on.
- exue 13y agoOK, now I understand where you're coming from. The physical limit is that at higher speed, we must expend more energy per unit of distance, to overcome drag (relatively little is lost in braking or rolling resistance of tires.) [1] So on any planet with an atmosphere you will have to contend with this. The 'ideal' speed isn't really even 55MPH, but lower if you had all variables at play to get the maximum MPG at any speed (probably 30-40MPH), but manufacturers expect people to cruise on the highway faster so they adjust the gearing. If you're asking how to push out the curve so that going faster than 75MPH doesn't offer a huge loss of speed, lower drag coefficients are the trick. Or switching out of the 4-wheels-on-ground automobile. [1] http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/05/Energy_flows_in_car.svg/555px-Energy_flows_in_car.svg.png http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/05/Ene... In this generic diagram, the ratio of drag (air)/rolling (ground) resistance is 11-to-7. As you get to higher speeds, the ratio tips even more in favor of drag. Fun fact: The Bugatti Veyron gets 2.15MPG at its top speed of 250MPH.
- taeric 13y agoThis was exactly the angle I was looking for. I am still not entirely satisfied with this, as it does not flat out state why better gearing couldn't achieve some increase. That is, my naive understanding is aligned with what a sibling post said. That there is an "ideal" torque rating of my engine. Seems that if my cruising speed isn't stuck at that number, than some gearing changes could be made to put me there. Why does that not work? (Adding a 7th gear, for example, seems to be a natural idea.) I'm curious to hear that the ideal speed would actually be below 55. Do you have good references on that? Also, I'd assume the "switching out of the 4-wheels-on-ground" refers to such as trains and friends?
- nols 13y agoGenerally the most efficient is highest gear-lowest RPM, and with car makers that's usually around 55-60. You could change the fuel efficiency to different speeds(I'm sure they're adapted to local markets with metric vs Imperial), but it would be worse off for most people to do that. It's not simply a gearing issue to change fuel efficiency, it's also the ECU controlling the fuel/air going into the engine. They aim for optimal fuel efficiency for normal driving, and that seems to be the sweet spot. Contrary to what I've heard before, changing fuel efficiency to higher speeds wouldn't make things better. It's also not that simple because drag increases exponentially with speed.
- taeric 13y agoThis is still not any more satisfying than "because this is the way they are built." Also, I should say that I realize this is a side show. One that I think should get less attention. No matter how much more efficient you make a car, I doubt I would ever be able to do better than local transit. (I, of course, welcome evidence otherwise.)
- exue 13y agoRight now local transit in the US is often less energy efficient per passenger-mile than a solo-driven Prius or Insight, or even the average-loaded (gasoline) passenger car. The numbers vary of course based on passenger load and route efficiency of course. http://www.templetons.com/brad/robocars/trans-energy.png http://www.templetons.com/brad/robocars/trans-energy.png
- nols 13y agoCars are built for their purpose, designing cars to be super efficient at speeds they're never driven doesn't make any sense. The higher speed efficiency is a trade-off between all the varying speeds the cars are driven and the limitations of physics. They could also produce extremely fuel efficient cars by ignoring the safety laws (even get around them by building trikes that don't have to abide by the laws) but they'd either not be allowed or never bought because they're impractical.
- sliverstorm 13y ago55mph is a sweet spot where the engine is operating close to peak efficiency and air resistance hasn't yet exploded. There very much are cars that are most efficient at 65, but that is because they sacrifice efficiency elsewhere. Peak efficiency is the intersection of many curves- gearing, rpm, aerodynamics, speed... Aerodynamics is possibly the biggest factor though, hence the common point of 55
- greatsuccess 13y ago55 MPH is nothing of the sort. My BMW reaches the same efficiency at 75 MPH as your honda does at 55 MPH. This has been debunked years, no centuries, NO EONS ago when Ronald Reagan decided to enforce a federal speed limit in exchange for provisioning interstate construction money. Its a fallacy, its wrong, and its well known. Stop spreading the 55 MPH is efficient pablum. Are you seriously all 18 year olds in here?
- trhway 13y ago>55mph is a sweet spot where the engine is operating close to peak efficiency and air resistance hasn't yet exploded. i think 55 is just the speed of EPA "highway" efficiency tests
- sliverstorm 13y agoAnother important bullet I forgot- the national maximum speed limit was 55mph until 1995. Cars were probably made to target that.
- wodenokoto 13y ago> Citations, or you are just promoting your opinion. This is an inherently flawed statement. If you follow the citations in a scientific paper at some point, the citations are going to end. A scientific article that consist only of citated information doesn't bring anything new to the table, it only summarises.
- baddox 13y agoI think most people, when requesting a citation in this context, would also be fine with a description of an experiment (preferably a repeatable one) and a record of the empirical result of that experiment. That's the "base case" you're talking about in the otherwise infinite regression of citations.
- taeric 13y agoBut this offered nothing other than some slight preference with a compelling argument that the differences in spending are more obvious. Yet, even in stating this, the conceit is held that "higher mpg is always better." So, my citations desire would best be settled by any sort of empirical study showing that they actually affected buyers in the desired way.