3 ms·
I was actually asked to referee this article. (I think I'm allowed to say that since I declined, I won't say which journal it was, and it's on the arXiv.) Alt
by jessriedel 13y ago
I was actually asked to referee this article. (I think I'm allowed to say that since I declined, I won't say which journal it was, and it's on the arXiv.) Although I agree with everything Scott says, I also recall another fundamental confusion. The author makes a grossly unjustified jump from (a) assuming the Universe as a "computing device" is "performing a calculation"--when in fact this mean our method for making predictions employs this calculations--to (b) concluding that you can construct a physical device capable of harnessing that power so as to perform similarly difficult computations. In fact, all sorts of problems come up in trying to make this leap that have to do with the finite precision of realistic preparations and measurements. The author did not acknowledge them.
For the sections where the paper was strictly discussing my area of expertise (decoherence), the author avoided egregious errors but basically just summarized some well-known ideas in a haphazard way that didn't advance his argument.