3 ms·
The article is lighting a vintage 1980's straw man on fire. Nowadays, we find the government bailing out Too Big To Fail banks, insurers, and other enterprises
by Zigurd 13y ago
The article is lighting a vintage 1980's straw man on fire. Nowadays, we find the government bailing out Too Big To Fail banks, insurers, and other enterprises that have conglomerated themselves into owning industries that they can convince the government are of national strategic importance.
TBTF means certain corporations have a much higher level of protection than limited liability. You can't liquidate them. Evidently you can't nationalize them. And you can't even stop the bonuses because that would make it look like they are distressed. Feh.
- briantakita 13y ago> we find the government bailing out Too Big To Fail banks, insurers, and other enterprises that have conglomerated themselves into owning industries that they can convince the government are of national strategic importance It's a transfer of wealth. Taxpayer money to the Oligarchy & entrenched interests. I disagree with the OP. Costs should not be externalized. Businesses should be responsible for the havoc that they cause. If they go bankrupt, then it's fertile soil for more responsible companies. What has happened as a consequence is more fiat money will be created to pay off such debts to the insurers. The insurance company should go bankrupt & the government should not bail it out. If that wreaks havoc on the markets, the markets should be corrected to account for this risk. It's better than further hiding the risk by creating more money, further devaluing the national currency.
- vbuterin 13y agoThere are many categories of people behind a "business", but you can generally classify them into three: 1. Employees (incl. management) 2. Shareholders 3. Investors In criminal law, if a group does something illegal outside of a corporate context, then the individuals doing that act (ie. a relevant subset of employees) are always guilty, the people who ordered them (ie. management) are guilty if they knew or should have known what was going on, and the people who financed them (ie. investors and customers) are guilty if they knew or should have known. I'm not a civil law expert, but I would expect something similar to exist there as well with regard to liability. Hence, applying this principle, it seems reasonable to hold management accountable as individuals for a corporation does, and then once we get to individuals and investors it all gets down to what standard we apply for "should have known". On the extreme side, if there is a business which is obviously set up with the mission of supporting terrorism, then investors and customers should be held responsible. On the other hand, if it's a scandal where management expertly hid the details from everyone else, then investors and customers would both be clear. Everywhere in the middle, it's a judgement call for the court. I generally support making investors liable more often; the one thing that worries me is that people will find some way of investing by proxy via derivatives, where if one organization figures out how to base itself internationally so as to be immune from lawsuits then that organization will hold lots of shares and everyone will enter into a contract-for-difference with them. Would setting yourself up to have positive exposure to a corporation's stock price count as investment no matter how it's done? From an economic standpoint, it basically is, but it might be hard to unravel the knots there.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago> Would setting yourself up to have positive exposure to a corporation's stock price count as investment no matter how it's done? From an economic standpoint, it basically is, but it might be hard to unravel the knots there. It's even worse than that. Imagine you find some indigent person and he put his name down as the owner of the business, then you sell him the assets necessary to do business and various consulting services, all on credit. Let the loan payments be well in excess of the profits the business is expected to make, so that he always pays you every dime the business makes and still owes more and accumulates late fees etc. Almost immediately he comes to owe more than the business is worth and so all the profits the business makes will perpetually go to you. You can't cleanly distinguish a loan from an investment. They're the same creature with only modestly different terms. So unless we're going to make people responsible for the debts of their debtors (which would have the snake eating its own tail), you can't get rid of limited liability in practice.
- dalek_cannes 13y agoI believe liability must rest on he who makes the decision. Will the following work? 1. An executive must carry some personal liability for the decisions he took during his tenure. 2. If the decision was made with the knowledge of the board of directors, directors too, carry some liability. 3. If you are an investor, you carry the same percentage of liability as stock. E.g. if you own 10% stock, you are directly liable for $1 million of a $10 million liability (financial or legal). 4. Investors are expected to do their due diligence before buying stock in a company that may be exposed to liability. 5. Investor liability for decisions made in accordance with corporate policies is unlimited.
- einhverfr 13y ago> If you are an investor, you carry the same percentage of liability as stock. E.g. if you own 10% stock, you are directly liable for $1 million of a $10 million liability (financial or legal). I think there is where you run into problems. The real problem is that the investor really is not in a position to ensure that the company is run a certain way. Now if the shareholders vote on a resolution to dump toxic waste in the river, then I think applying liability to the vote in proportion to the share is appropriate. But then those who vote against would have no liability. The reason why limited liability exists is to help ensure that non-decision-makers are protected from the decisions of others. But if you aren't going to give them protection, why not also have a rule that banks who loan money to corporations are liable for misuse of the money loaned?
- Guvante 13y agoI don't see how what you are saying has to do with limited liability.
- einhverfr 13y agoBecause under limited liability, the owners would lose their equity. Under too big to fail, the owners are not liable at all. I.e. for really big businesses, we have gone from limited liability to no liability.
- mdasen 13y agoI feel like this line of thought became dominant even though it's inaccurate. First, Lehman Brothers went bankrupt and was liquidated. What would nationalization look like? Well, it would mean that the government would become the majority or complete shareholder. This happened with AIG. AIG became government owned until the government eventually sold off its interest to third parties. AIG was nationalized, the government owned the company for several years, and then sold it off. General Motors went through bankruptcy and came out owned by the government and the union. That's nationalization. Wachovia and Washington Mutual were sold off at cut-rate prices before they could fail via government intervention. The government could have put up the money itself and nationalized them, but preferred to have private companies take the risk. In terms of the large banks that still exist, the government got a portion of the company as compensation for the government's capital. The issue for many banks wasn't that they had failed, but that the government wanted them a great distance from failing. Think of it this way, many people need their paycheck to clear before they pay their rent. Similarly, banks need people to pay their mortgages so they have the funds to pay out their obligations. Some banks were getting closer to "paycheck to paycheck" than the government wanted. The government wanted them to take the money because chaos is bad for everyone. The government could have nationalized these banks. But, that would have required more money and more risk. If they wanted to nationalize the banks, they would have had to pay out a lot more money than they did and accept more risk. By providing less money, the government ended up without owning the whole of the banks, but it also meant that the amount that the government could lose would be less. In terms of salaries and bonuses, that's an issue of contract law between an employer and employee. It wasn't about whether it would make them look distressed by stopping bonuses. Let's say you work for Chase. The government wants to stabilize Chase and steps in with the government's money. You have an employment contract for the next two years that says you'll get paid $10M per year. Maybe you're the idiot that got them into the mess. Well, is there anything in the contract that lets them terminate or reduce your pay? If not, they can't just alter it because they want to. So, the question here would have to be: why not pull a GM on the banks? In bankruptcy, compensation packages could be changed, people could be removed, etc. The issue is that the banks weren't going bankrupt, but they were in that "paycheck to paycheck" range that the government didn't want. Since the crisis, the government has been requiring banks to carry healthy amounts of reserves and testing that they have enough to whether another crisis. But if you're a bank that is on the bubble, but still making it work, you're going to keep trying to make it work until it all comes tumbling down if the alternative is wiping out all the shareholders. The banks weren't nearly as bad as GM, AIG, and Lehman. So, the government came along and said, "you're going to take our money. We want you to have more reserves and you're going to give us part of your company." While the investment was semi-forced upon some of the banks, they also realized that it was a reasonable price to pay. If the government came by and said you have to give us 100% of your company, they would have said, "nope, we'll gamble that we'll whether the storm." Think of it this way, you think your paycheck won't clear before your rent is due. If I come along and say, "well, give me your children and I'll cover the rent for the few days" you'd tell me to take a hike. Let's say you thought there was a 10% chance that your paycheck wouldn't clear before the rent and I came along and said, "for $100, I'll handle it in the case that it doesn't". That sounds a lot more reasonable. The fact is that some institutions were liquidated and some were nationalized, while others were unlikely to fail, but were closer than would be comfortable. In those cases, shareholders of those companies were hit because the loans had to be repaid with interest and the government received warrants for portions of the companies. But the hit to shareholders was going to be proportional, not absolute. TARP was one of those programs that people really didn't understand, but wanted to be mad about.