3 ms·
It has been known for a long time that one can arrange 7 cylinders to be mutually touching. That was written about by Martin Gardner decades ago, and was set a
by ColinWright 13y ago
It has been known for a long time that one can arrange 7 cylinders to be mutually touching. That was written about by Martin Gardner decades ago, and was set as a puzzle.
The result had the cylinders touching at the end of one with the length of the other, so the question arose, can one arrange to have seven cylinders all mutually touching, without using the ends. The easiest way to say this is to ask for seven infinitely long cylinders mutually touching.
This has only recently been settled, hence this paper. It's believed impossible to arrange eight identical infinitely long cylinders to be mutually touching. I suspect the result is in fact known, but I haven't searched diligently for it.
There is an associated puzzle that uses cylinders that are very short - think coins. How many coins can you arrange to be mutually touching?
Consider that a puzzle. I can do 5. If you can do more, there's a mathematical paper in it for you, should you care.
- lotharbot 13y agoI linked to another related puzzle elsewhere in this discussion: there appears to be a solution for 9 cylinders of infinite length but different radii. It's not clear what's known about the case of 10 cylinders. So there are known solutions for 5 coins, 7 identical infinite cylinders, 7 identical finite cylinders (maybe more), and 9 different infinite cylinders.
- darkmighty 13y agoIs there an example of a similiar non-trivial problem for which there is an inexistance proof? I'm not a mathematician so I have a hard time picturing a way of proving this sort of thing when the number of objects is "tricky" (not too high, not too low), apart from simply showing a counterexample.
- Strilanc 13y agoHow about the fact that there are no more than 5 platonic solids [1]? (See the proof in the article) 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platonic_solid http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platonic_solid