>"Also, there's a lot of subjectivity here." This feels like a case where subjectivity is the PRIMARY consideration. All of the proposed metrics are trivially

>"Also, there's a lot of subjectivity here." This feels like a case where subjectivity is the PRIMARY consideration. All of the proposed metrics are trivially gameable, and anyway don't represent "goodness" in any way. I'd throw this one to the users with a typical popularity/voting dynamic, with a twist: separate voting and leaderboards for "best neocities site" and "best geocities site", roughly corresponding to "good + modern" and "entertaining + retro". It would be sad to have the top sites populated entirely by slick parallax and flat design when Neocities is supposed to be a direct descendant of the weird and wild Geocities.