3 ms·
Brendan Eich was not fired because he made a political donation. He was fired because the particular political donation he made is evidence that he is a bigot,
by lisper 13y ago
Brendan Eich was not fired because he made a political donation. He was fired because the particular political donation he made is evidence that he is a bigot, that he has a broken moral code. There is not, and never has been, any justification for denying gays the right to marry except prejudice and bigotry. Every single non-religious argument against gay marriage has been definitively debunked. Therefore, discrimination against opponents of gay marriage is morally justified, just as discrimination against other kinds of bigotry is.
In fact, even if discrimination against opponents of gay marriage were not morally justified on its own merits, it would be at least as morally justified as the discrimination against gays that Brendan Eich once wanted to see enshrined into law.
- obtorto 13y agoIt seems that for half the people on HN the conversation immediately stops with "this is about civil rights, therefore we should not tolerate Eich's intolerance". But marriage itself is not a civil right. It is a pact between two people, a type of contract that we have inherited through a long series of civilizations, to which the modern state associates a number of privileges. Right off the bat, if we consider any of these privileges a matter of equality before the law, then it is the institution of marriage itself that is discriminatory. Why should an unmarried person pay more taxes than a married person for the same income? Why cannot they name a friend instead of a spouse as a dependent for health insurance? And so on. How is it acceptable to discriminate against people who are not in a romantic relationship? Why are we tolerating this obvious injustice? The answer is that, traditionally, these have not been seen as rights, but as privileges. The state grants these privileges to married people, at a cost for the community, because these is believed to be a public interest in the promotion of marriage. If that is the case, it is entirely legitimate to debate whether this public interest exists both in the case of heterosexual and homosexual couples, and furthermore, whether it still applies to anyone at all in modern society. A lot of the traditional justifications for public support of marriage were based on strongly differentiated gender roles, and it should be clear that they are no longer applicable. As for new rationales of public interest, none have been advanced, other than "discrimination" - which, again, would be an argument for abolishing marriage, not for extending it. In any case, this is a matter on which there is ample room for debate amongst well-intentioned and rational people. It is not right to nip the discussion in the bud by framing anyone who holds a different opinion as a bigot.
- sliverstorm 13y agoIt's awfully convenient that his discrimination is immoral, while your discrimination is not only moral but a moral imperative, isn't it?
- lisper 13y agoNo, it's not convenient, it's simply a fact. The discrimination against Brendan was based on something that he did. Discrimination against gays is based on something that they are. The former is morally justifiable, the latter is not. It really is that simple.
- sliverstorm 13y agoNo, you said he is a bigot, and that is why you advocate discriminating against him. Let me quote you: Brendan Eich was not fired because he made a political donation [...] he is a bigot
- lisper 13y agoOK, let me be more precise: he was fired because he donated to a cause that cannot be justified on any grounds other than bigotry, and when called on it, failed to repent. So I don't know whether he is a bigot or not, but he definitely acted like one, and when given the opportunity to repent, he chose not to. That's enough to justify his removal from the grown-up table.
- microscopic 13y agoI understand you are passionate about this topic but please consider this line of thinking: Here is what I am seeing: "The discrimination against Brendan was based on something that he did." [therefore the discrimination is morally justifiable] He did what he thought was right by his own standards. I don't suppose you are for punishing people who do things based on what they believe is right. Rather, you want to punish Brendan, in part, because of the nature of his belief. If Brendan had NOT donated, would you have wanted him to resign? Perhaps not, because, then you would argue, it is okay for him to have bad ideas, so long as he doesn't act on them. It is because Brendan had donated to a cause which you disagree with, that you want him to be punished. Because a donation to a cause, in itself, is not "morally" reprehensible. You wouldn't punish people for donating for a cause. Rather, your problem is with the cause he donated. Your problem is not with Brendan, it is with the anti-movement against taking gender out of the equation in legal marriage. Brendan has a different standard than you do. It is clear that you believe Brendan has a bad standard. But who is to say Brendan's standard is better or worst than yours? It is with this line of thinking that you might reconsider whether it is, in fact, "morally justifiable" to discriminate against Brendan.
- microscopic 13y ago"He was fired because the particular political donation he made is evidence that he is a bigot, that he has a broken moral code." Just because a person is a bigot doesn't necessarily mean that s/he is a bad person. I've met racist people and even I am able to maintain some level of respect for them. This is what being open-minded is. Hurting people just because they have a different philosophical belief than yours is the same kind of narrow-mindedness that leads to racism and religious fanaticism in the first place. Back in the past, if you said the world was round, people would classify you as crazy by virtue of you having an opinion that the majority did not believe. This kind of narrow-mindedness holds back open dialogue and progress. As 'bad' as it is to be your definition of a bigot, to denote all bigots as having a broken moral code is as negative as bigotry itself. I hate how people have this misconception that you have to hurt people to make them change.
- lisper 13y agoI didn't say he was a "bad person", I said he had a "broken moral code." Those aren't the same thing. Maybe his moral code is only a little bit broken and he's otherwise a fine person (I have no idea). But this little bit matters a lot if you're the CEO of a company. BTW, I am not taking a position about whether removing Brendon was the correct decision (I don't have enough information to have an opinion about that), only that is was justifiable.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> He was fired because the particular political donation he made is evidence that he is a bigot On what basis is the claim justified that "he was fired" at all? And, if he was fired (or, at least, given the choice to resign or be fired), what evidence is that that it was because of the donation (whatever it might provide "evidence" of), and not because of Mozilla board's concerns about the way he responded to the controversy over the donation? Managing corporate image is, after all, part of the CEO's responsibility.
- lisper 13y agoI simply used "fired" as shorthand for "pressured to resign." And I think it was because of his inadequate response, not the initial donation. If he had fully repented, apologized, admitted he was wrong, I think he might have been forgiven. But that's not what he did. But my point is simply that however you reckon it, his ouster was justified.
- daveqr 13y ago> the particular political donation he made is evidence that he is a bigot This is silly. It's nothing of the sort.
- lisper 13y agoOf course it is. It may not be proof but it is definitely evidence. He wants to deny gay people equal protection under the law. One of the reasons one might want this is anti-gay bigotry. In fact, in light of the fact that all of the objective arguments against gay marriage have at this point been completely debunked, I don't see too many other possibilities.